About testing Bell locality at colliders

M. Fabbrichesi † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-1937-385}{\orcidlogo}} , R. Floreanini † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0002-0424-2707}{\orcidlogo}}, L. Marzola ‡ {}^{\ddagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-2045-1100}{\orcidlogo}} · 2025

Read About testing Bell locality at colliders by M. Fabbrichesi † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-1937-385}{\orcidlogo}} , R. Floreanini † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0002-0424-2707}{\orcidlogo}}, L. Marzola ‡ {}^{\ddagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-2045-1100}{\orcidlogo}} (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-18535.txt.

Introduction

Fabbrichesi, Floreanini, and Marzola explain how particle colliders can test Bell locality, one of the deepest checks of quantum mechanics. Their 2025 paper reviews the principles and methods behind these tests. Colliders produce systems of qubits, carried by fermions, and qutrits, carried by heavy spin one bosons, all under strong and electroweak forces.

Quantum state tomography at colliders can witness both entanglement and Bell nonlocality in these short lived systems. The authors lay out how the states are rebuilt from decay products and how the nonlocality tests are framed. The paper serves as a full guide to a young field that moves quantum foundations into the high energy lab.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Fabbrichesi † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-1937-385}{\orcidlogo}} , R. Floreanini † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0002-0424-2707}{\orcidlogo}}, L. Marzola ‡ {}^{\ddagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-2045-1100}{\orcidlogo}}
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-18535

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

About testing Bell locality at colliders M. Fabbrichesi † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-1937-385}{\orcidlogo}} , R. Floreanini † {}^{\dagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0002-0424-2707}{\orcidlogo}}, L. Marzola ‡ {}^{\ddagger}\,{}^{\lx@orcidlink{0000-0003-2045-1100}{\orcidlogo}} Abstract . Quantum tomography at colliders makes it possible to measure the amount of entanglement and test the violation of the Bell inequality. We explain in detail how this is possible and why it offers the possibility of examining from a new angle the feasibility of local hidden variable models. 1. Introduction One of the most characteristic properties of a quantum system is the possible presence of entanglement , that is of quantum correlations among observables that cannot be accounted for by classical physics [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . As entanglement often leads to conflict with common sense, which is grounded on local realism, classical models encompassing standard quantum mechanics have been proposed in order to explain the phenomena in terms of underlying hidden variables. These variables can be deterministic or stochastic but, to mimic the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics, only their average over a characteristic distribution enters the result of measurements in either case. Investigations about these hypothetical variables gave rise to lively debates—often touching intricate philosophical considerations. A first outcome of these discussions—after von Neumann’s rather abrupt dismissal [ 5 ] was shown to be premature [ 6 , 7 ] —is that hidden variables cannot be agnostic about the experimental setup through which they are being measured because simultaneous values to all observables of a quantum mechanical system cannot be assigned in a way that respects their algebraic structure. This contextuality requirement comes from a theorem [ 8 , 7 , 9 ] that severely restricts which models of hidden variables are possible. The theorem holds for Hilbert spaces of dimension larger than 2. For a two-dimensional Hilbert space, there exists a simple non-contextual model for the spin of a particle [ 7 ] . Quantum contextuality has been experimentally tested at low energies by means of photons and other devices [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] and more recently also at high energies [ 16 ] . The discussion was given new scope by J. Bell’s seminal paper [ 17 ] , in which it is shown that a large class of these contextual models of hidden variables, those obeying a locality condition ( Bell locality ), satisfy specific constraints (the Bell inequalities ) that can be violated by quantum mechanics [ 18 , 19 ] . This result makes it possible to discriminate between classical models and quantum mechanics by performing actual experiments [ 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 ] . Many tests of this kind have been performed with various systems, both at low energies within atomic and solid-state physics [ 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] and, more recently, at high energies in colliders experiments (for a review, see [ 33 ] ). At particle colliders it is possible to reconstruct the spin state of the products of a scattering process by using the angular distributions of the momenta—as recorded by a detector—of the related final-state particles. The complete knowledge of the state, obtained through this quantum state tomography process, should be compared to the traditional setting of a Bell inequality test where only joint probabilities along given directions in space are measured. For the latter, since only these probabilities are measured, the final state is only partially determined and this lack of knowledge can be exploited to devise loopholes in the test. At colliders, the complete knowledge of the state closes all loopholes and the Bell test becomes a simple determination of suitable observables on the reconstructed state. Because, sometimes, in physics the equations are not enough---and some explaining is required lest their meaning remains unclear---we discuss in detail the testing of nonlocality at colliders and compare it to the traditional low-energy experiments. 1 1 1 Before embarking on such a discussion, a methodological premise is perhaps necessary: Experiments always compare models against the data. The data are the “real world” and, given a model, we check how well the data fit it. There is no such a things as testing directly the “real world”. The Bell test therefore simply checks the factorization of probabilities (Bell locality) against the data; its results can be used to exclude local theories (if the inequality is violated), as well as quantum mechanics (if the violation exceed a critical value known as Tsirelson’s bound [ 34 ] ). The same holds true for measurements of entanglement. Figure 1. Clauser’s experimental setup (Stuart Freedman, Berkeley [CC BY-NC 4.0]) and the CMS detector (CERN [CC BY-NC 4.0]). Neither is as simple as a falling apple. Let us stress an important point that perhaps makes clearer the complete similarity between Bell tests at colliders and those in atomic physics with photons. All current experiments—be them at low or high energy—must necessarily assume some model about the working of the polarimeter utilized in the measurements. It is the polarimeter that transforms a measured data (light or darkness in the case of photons, angular distribution of momenta in the case of the decay of a particle) into a polarization measurement. In the case of the atomic-physics tests, this equipment consists of the photon polarimeter, while in the case of the high-energy tests, in the polarimetric vector and spin-analyzing power of a particle emitted in a decay. In both cases, its actual operation has to be determined independently of the Bell test or a measurement of entanglement, in separate experiments providing the characteristic properties of the photon polarimeter or of the polarimetric vector. It is only after this step that the experimentally collected data—be them in the form of frequencies, probabilities or correlations—can be presented as those giving photon or elementary particle polarizations. On the other hand, in a analytic computation or a Monte Carlo simulation, the operation of the polarimeter can be obtained through the model itself instead of being derived from some other data. For example, in the case of tests at colliders the polarimetric vector in the fully leptonic decay of the top quark is found to be one because of the chiral coupling between elementary fermions and the gauge bosons in the Standard Model. We are aware that the ideal configuration to test nonlocality against hidden variable models would be, like in quantum information, a black box in which the inputs can be varied at will and the outputs recorded [ 35 , 36 ] . Unfortunately, no present or planned collider experiment satisfies these conditions. Nor do the low-energy experiments in which Bell inequality has been tested. 2. Quantum entanglement Consider a pair of charged particles originating from the decay of a neutral state. They fly apart. If at a successive time and somewhere in space you look and find a charged particle, you know for sure that somewhere else there is going to be a particle with the opposite charge. By a measurement now and here, we learn something about somewhere else that can be very far away and space-like separated. Still, this is not a sign that the two

Read the complete text