Challenging the Law of Energy Conservation Through Superposed Waves Based on Spatial Symmetry of Two RF Sources: Theoretical Derivation and Experimental Verification

Bingli Jiao, Chenbo Wang, Zijian Zhou · 2025

Read Challenging the Law of Energy Conservation Through Superposed Waves Based on Spatial Symmetry of Two RF Sources: Theoretical Derivation and Experimental Verification by Bingli Jiao, Chenbo Wang, Zijian Zhou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-18110.txt.

Introduction

Bingli Jiao, Chenbo Wang, and Zijian Zhou press a bold claim on wave energy in a 2025 paper. Two radio sources, set in mirror posts and humming in step, can send waves that stack as they spread. The pair ask what that stack means for the count of energy in and out.

With a twin dipole model, they track power at the sources and in the joined waves. On their count, both counts clash with the law that energy is never made or lost. They give the math steps and bench tests for the claim. The paper invites checks of a core physics law.

Catalog record

CREATORBingli Jiao, Chenbo Wang, Zijian Zhou
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-18110

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Challenging the Law of Energy Conservation Through Superposed Waves Based on Spatial Symmetry of Two RF Sources: Theoretical Derivation and Experimental Verification Bingli Jiao, Chenbo Wang, Zijian Zhou Abstract This study is grounded in the concept of spatial symmetry, which allows two co-phase RF sources to jointly radiate harmonic electromagnetic (EM) waves, even in presence of electromagnetic couplings between them. The superposition law is directly applied to the two waves owing to their sources, including the EM coupling effects. Our research uncovers a conflict with energy conservation law at the following two levels: (1) the total radiative powers as defined by Poynting theorem, and (2) further, the input powers of the sources. To explore this phenomenon, we create a symmetric dipole model to examine the energy behaviors at the sources and the superposed waves, separately. Both of the results reveal that the energy-doubling phenomenon presents when the dipoles are placed in close proximity. As the distance between the two dipoles increases, it is found that the total radiative power fluctuates in a damped manner and ultimately converges to a value required by energy conservation law. The theoretical conclusion of energy doubling is validated by experimental observations, which show a 1.59-fold increase in power within a microwave anechoic chamber. By analyzing the interactions, i.e., the EM coupling, between the two sources, we characterize a complete phenomenon of energy non-conservation. I Introduction In a linear system, it is well known that the superposition of two waves having identical amplitudes and frequencies can result in a superposed wave whose local power density is quadrupled somewhere due to the co-phase interference, in comparison with that of a single wave. Conversely, with 180^{o} anti-phase interference, the power density can be completely nullified. This suggests that energy conservation does not necessarily hold locally. While, this paper goes further to explore the energy conservation issue over the entire space. For simplicity, we restrict our discussions solely on the constructive interference, since the deconstruction problem can be treated using the same method of this paper. In addition, the near fields are not discussed, as their powers are confined locally. In 1980, Levine discussed a superposition phenomenon in the radiation model, where two harmonic waves undergo constructive interference throughout space by placing the two sources very close to each other, with a distance much smaller than the wavelength, i.e., d/\lambda<<1 , where d is the distance and \lambda is the wavelength [1]. In fact, as the two waves’ amplitudes are linearly superposed, an amplitude-doubling effect results, causing the total radiative power to increase by approximately four times that of one single wave, rather than two times required by energy conservation law. Therefore, the “energy doubling” problem arises because the energy-doubling effect has extended to whole space instead of some local areas. Wishfully attempting to comply with the law of energy conservation, the energy doubling phenomenon was dismissed as a “false paradox” due to an incorrect explanation using the interactions between the two sources[1], as outlined below. Firstly, the explanation separates the EM coupled sources from the application of the superposition law, leading to a power estimation that does not reflect true powers of the sources. Secondly, the two antennas are arranged parallel to one another, maximizing EM coupling between them for getting its weight. These two points mixed together resulted in the vague and incorrect explanation. In fact, the error becomes clear when the two whip antennas are placed in a straight line. Since each antenna’s radiation is zero in the direction of its pole—i.e., toward its neighboring antenna—there is no any EM interactions between them. Nevertheless, the energy-doubling effect still persists, as will be demonstrated later. Due to the incorrect explanation in [1], some studies have been misled, resulting in the failure to achieve either analytical solutions [2-4] or experimental verification. Meanwhile, other researchers continue to debate the issue in their papers, offering viewpoints that are either inconsistent with or contradictory to the law of energy conservation [5-8]. In such, this issue can still be considered an open problem within the realm of classical electromagnetism. As is widely acknowledged, the laws of superposition and energy conservation operate independently of each other. In other words, their validity and application do not necessarily promise one another. This realization drives us to conduct in - depth research on the former and utilize the results to verify the latter, even though that this approach is boldly challenging the fundamental principles of physics. To apply the superposition law correctly, we must apply it directly to the two waves radiated from their sources including the coupling effects between them. In the presence of (EM) coupling, the sources can influence each other. Although the input power of each source may differ from the case where each source radiates independently, the power-consumption of each source should equal the power it radiates. In contrast, if there is no EM coupling, each source radiates as if it were alone, resulting in neither increase nor decrease in power consumption compared to the scenario where a single source radiates on its own. In both cases, the total power-consumption of the two sources should equal the power transferred to the radiative waves, regardless of weather any EM coupling exists . By summarizing the analysis above, we can clearly conclude that if the power summation of two radiatve waves can be doubled through the superposing and, then, the input powers of the sources can be regarded to be doubled as well. When the evidences of energy-doubling are sufficient, we should believe the fact, rather than adhere with the law of energy conservation tightly. This bold move avoids being entangled in the complexities of EM coupling and makes our derivations straightforward in achieving the results, introducing new perspectives into classical electromagnetism [9]–[11]. To be specific, we proposed a spatially symmetric system, in which a dipole model is constructed to ensure the correct application of the superposition law, incorporating the following key characteristics. • Upon spatial symmetry, two identical harmonic dipoles can exist with co-phase radiations physically. • The antennas’ design minimizes the EM coupling for simplifying experimental data. • In assumption of small distance between the dipoles, the total radiative power can be easily calculated at the sources. • More results are obtained by increasing the distance between the two dipoles. • The experiments taken in a microwave anechoic chamber substantiate the theoretical conclusion. Finally, some key technical terms and specifications of this paper are listed in Table I, and the detailed studies are presented in the following sections. TABLE I: Abbreviations and SI Units Abbreviation Description EM Electromagnetic EAF Energy Abnormal Factor GHz Gigahertz (1 GHz = 10^{9} Hz) m Meter °C Degree Celsius dB Decibel \Omega Ohm II Energy-Doubling Phenomenon In contrast to conventional studies, spatial symmetry plays a conceptual role as the physics basis that allows two identical sources to radiate in co-phase manner, in the presence of EM coupling between them. Hence, we can build the theoretical study directly on the two existing identical sources. The following discussions are confined to the linear approximation of radiation in free space. A dipole model is set up by positioning two co-phase dipoles along the z-axis, with the symmetry point located at

Read the complete text