Example-Based Learning in Software Engineering Education: A Systematic Mapping Study

T. P. Bonetti a , W. Silva b and T. E. Colanzi a · 2025

Read Example-Based Learning in Software Engineering Education: A Systematic Mapping Study by T. P. Bonetti a , W. Silva b and T. E. Colanzi a (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-18080.txt.

Introduction

Learning by worked examples can wake up passive software classes, but how well it works needs mapping. Tiago Bonetti, Williamson Silva, and Thelma Colanzi map the evidence in a 2025 review. They gather thirty studies on example-based learning in software engineering courses.

The method helped students grasp and apply concepts, and it raised drive and confidence. It also made class talk livelier. Costs fell on teachers, who spent more effort and time building good examples. Some diagrams even carried errors that confused learners. Support tools for teachers lag behind the method's promise. The map shows where course designers should invest next.

Catalog record

CREATORT. P. Bonetti a , W. Silva b and T. E. Colanzi a
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE76 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-18080

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Example-Based Learning in Software Engineering Education: A Systematic Mapping Study T. P. Bonetti a , W. Silva b and T. E. Colanzi a Abstract Background and Context : The discipline of Software Engineering (SE) allows students to understand specific concepts or problems while designing software. Empowering students with the necessary knowledge and skills for the software industry is challenging for universities. One key problem is that traditional methodologies often leave students as passive agents, limiting engagement and learning effectiveness. To address this issue, instructors must promote active learning in the classroom. Among the teaching methodologies, Example-Based Learning (EBL) has shown promise in improving the quality of Software Engineering Education (SEE). Objective : This study aims to investigate and classify the existing empirical evidence about using EBL in SEE. Method : We carried out a systematic mapping to collect existing studies and evidence that describe how instructors have been employing EBL to teach SE concepts. Findings : By analyzing 30 studies, we identified the benefits and difficulties of using EBL, the SE contents taught by instructors, and the artifacts that support the methodology’s use in the classroom. Besides, we identified the main types of examples used in SEE through EBL. Implications : We realized that EBL contributes to student learning, helping in students’ interaction, interpreting and applying concepts, and increasing student motivation and confidence. However, some barriers to adopting EBL in SEE are increasing the effort required by instructors, lack of adequate learning support, and time spent constructing diagrams with errors. Overall, our findings suggest that EBL can improve the effectiveness of SEE, but more research is needed to address the gaps and challenges identified in our study. keywords Software engineering education; active learning strategies; example-based learning; worked examples; erroneous worked examples. † † articletype: REVIEW ARTICLE † † affiliation: a Universidade Estadual de Maringá (UEM), Maringá, Paraná, Brazil; b Universidade Federal do Pampa (UNIPAMPA), Alegrete, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil 1 Introduction Software Engineering aims to support all aspects of software production, applying the necessary theories, methods, and tools to achieve this goal ( Sommerville, (2011) ) . As a discipline closely linked to day-to-day software development processes ( Marques et al., (2014) ) , students must prepare themselves to effectively apply the concepts they learn during practice ( J. Chen et al., (2009) ) . However, optimizing Software Engineering Education (SEE) is a significant challenge for universities because most still adopt traditional teaching methodologies that focus on lectures, leaving the student as a passive agent of learning ( Cunha et al., (2018) ; Fonseca & Gómez, (2017) ; Ferreira et al., (2018) ) . Instructors can minimize this problem by adapting or employing new teaching methodologies. In this direction, the literature indicates that a promising and effective approach is Active Learning Methodologies ( Lima et al., (2021) ; Fonseca & Gómez, (2017) ; J. Chen et al., (2009) ) . These methodologies use a student-centered teaching strategy to ensure students are actively engaged and involved in learning. Besides, Active Learning Methodologies aim to increase students’ interest in the classroom, critical thinking, problem-solving, and decision-making skills, which are fundamental for a software engineer’s success ( Lima et al., (2019) ) . Instructors can adopt several Active Learning Methodologies to improve the teaching process in SEE, and Example-Based Learning (EBL) has been particularly effective ( Van Gog & Rummel, (2018) ) . This methodology demonstrates how to perform a specific task so students can learn a particular content based on observation ( Van Gog & Rummel, (2018) ) . EBL has been used in undergraduate Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) courses, including Mathematics ( Adams et al., (2014) ; Renkl et al., (2009) ) , Electrical Circuits ( Van Gog et al., (2006) ) , Programming ( Beege et al., (2021) ) , and Database ( X. Chen et al., (2020) ) . In addition to these areas, some researchers have explored using EBL in teaching Software Engineering and have reported various benefits, such as increasing student motivation ( Shmallo & Shrot, (2020) ) , better learning outcomes ( F.G. Silva et al., (2019) ) , improved interpretation and application of concepts ( W. Silva et al., (2017) ) , and promotion of essential skills for the software industry ( Tonhão et al., (2021) ) . However, a summary of how EBL is employed by instructors in SEE is still needed. Therefore, this research aims to investigate and categorize existing empirical evidence on how instructors and the Software Engineering community have been employing EBL to teach Software Engineering concepts, as well as benefits and difficulties. To achieve this, we performed a Systematic Mapping Study (SMS). SMS is a rigorous and structured methodology to identify, select, evaluate, and synthesize relevant literature in a specific research area. It allows researchers to comprehend the current knowledge state on a particular topic, identify gaps and future trends in research ( Kitchenham & Charters, (2007) ) . Thus, we realized the current state of the art and determined how SEE researchers and instructors have used EBL, the Software Engineering contents taught by instructors, the artifacts that support the methodology’s use in the classroom, and the benefits and difficulties associated with its use. The main benefits identified are improved interpretation and application of concepts and developing practical skills necessary for the software industry. However, we also observed some barriers to adopting EBL in SEE, e.g., the complexity of understanding the context of the examples and the need for adequate learning support. The study is organized as follows: Section 2 presents the background. Section 3 describes the systematic mapping’s methodology and protocol. Section 4 shows the results. A discussion is presented in Section 5 . Finally, conclusions and future work are presented in Section 7 . 2 Example-Based Learning Active teaching methodologies promote student participation in the construction of their learning, using methods focused on the student’s activity, thus contributing to their autonomy ( Bacich & Moran, (2018) ) . There are several ways to apply active methodologies, and several studies have pointed to the effectiveness of these methods in teaching Software Engineering-related content ( Paez, (2017) ; dos Santos et al., (2013) ; Matalonga et al., (2017) ; Ramos et al., (2018) ) . One active methodology that instructors can adopt is Example-Based Learning (EBL). Van Gog & Rummel ((2018)) defines EBL as a methodology that demonstrates how to perform a specific task or how a particular skill can be assimilated for students. When students observe an example of a successfully executed task, their belief in their ability to perform it increases ( Huang, (2017) ) . For Van Gog & Rummel ((2010)) , there are two ways to use examples during the student’s learning process: Worked Examples and Modeling Examples. To broaden the view of the effects of using examples in the learning process, Huang ((2017)) adds two more ways in addition to the two already mentioned: Erroneous Worked Examples and Peer Modeling Examples. Figure 1 shows a classification of examples according to their pedagogical perspective. [Figure 1 near here] Worked Examples , originated from Cognitive Load Theory ( Sweller et al., (1998) ) , aims to provide instructions for presenting information to stimulate student

Read the complete text