Heterogeneity of household stock portfolios in a national market

Matteo Milazzo, Federico Musciotto, Jyrki Piilo, Rosario N. Mantegna · 2025

Read Heterogeneity of household stock portfolios in a national market by Matteo Milazzo, Federico Musciotto, Jyrki Piilo, Rosario N. Mantegna (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-17778.txt.

Introduction

Matteo Milazzo and co-authors open the full stock registers of Finland to study how concentrated household portfolios really are. The data cover single Finnish legal entities trading on the Helsinki venue from 2001 to 2021. Concentration is read with the Herfindahl-Hirschman index, a standard sum-of-squares gauge.

Foreign investors held the most concentrated combined portfolio, ahead of Finnish institutions and households. Looked at one by one, more than half of retail investors held highly concentrated portfolios. Many household accounts hold just a stock or two, despite two decades of cheap diversification. The long panel lets the authors watch concentration evolve, not just snapshot it. Finance researchers get rare whole-market proof of how undiversified the typical saver stays.

Catalog record

CREATORMatteo Milazzo, Federico Musciotto, Jyrki Piilo, Rosario N. Mantegna
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-17778

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Heterogeneity of household stock portfolios in a national market Matteo Milazzo, Federico Musciotto, Jyrki Piilo, Rosario N. Mantegna Abstract We study the long term dynamics of the stock portfolios owned by single Finnish legal entities in the Helsinki venue of the Nasdaq Nordic between 2001 and 2021. Using the Herfindahl-Hirschman index as a measure of concentration for the composition of stock portfolios, we investigate the concentration of Finnish household portfolios both at the level of each individual household and tracking the time evolution of an aggregated Finnish household portfolio. We also consider aggregated portfolios of two other macro categories of investors one comprising Finnish institutional investors and the other comprising foreign investors. Different macro categories of investors present a different degree of concentration of aggregated stock portfolios with highest concentration observed for foreign investors. For individual Finnish retail investors, portfolio concentration estimated by the Herfindahl-Hirschman index presents high values for more than half of the total number of retail investors. In spite of the observation that retail stock portfolios are often composed by just a few stocks, the concentration of the aggregated stock portfolio for Finnish retail investors has a portfolio concentration comparable with the one of Finnish institutional investors. Within retail investors, stock portfolios of women present a similar pattern of portfolios of men but with a systematic higher level of concentration observed for women both at individual and at aggregated level. keywords Financial market, market heterogeneity, market participants, market ecology, Nasdaq Nordic market, domestic and foreign investors. 1 Introduction A line of academic and professional research considers financial markets as complex systems mantegna1999introduction ; bouchaud2003theory ; sornette2009stock ; farmer2024making . Financial markets are social and economic infrastructures pursuing different goals. Several financial markets exist and each of them is specialised in the trading of one type, or few types, of financial assets. In this study we focus on the stock market that is one of the most prominent financial market. Starting from the eighties of the last century a progressive stock market liberalisation has diffused in mature and emerging markets. Thanks to this process of liberalization, i.e., a decision by a country’s government to allow foreigners to purchase shares in that country’s stock market, today foreign and domestic investment is possible and quite easily performed thanks to broker intermediation in the majority of world stock markets. Stock markets provide credit and investment opportunities to companies and individuals. Market participants in the stock market are therefore inherently of different type. In fact we observe households, e.g., retail investors, companies (both financial and non financial companies) and various types of institutions. These investors can be domestic or foreign with respect to the country hosting the market venue. Classic financial theory predicts that this type of heterogeneity can be subsumed into an appropriate rational agent operating in the market hommes2006heterogeneous ; kirman2010complex . The study of idiosyncratic behaviours associated with the different categories of market participants is a main area of research of behavioural finance barberis2003survey . Financial market ecology has also been investigated in the literature farmer1999frontiers ; farmer2002market ; lo2004adaptive ; preda2019noise . Performing empirical studies of behavioural finance on a scale covering an entire country is extremely difficult if not impossible. The reason of the difficulty lies on two facts. Firstly, investment data at the level of the single investor are data to be kept confidential to protect the privacy of the investor. Secondly, in most of western countries the process of clearing and settlement of stocks is in the majority of cases performed through nominee registration. Nominee registration means that a legal entity, a nominee, is registered in a register of owners of financial instruments instead of the beneficial owner. With this recording mechanism distributed across many chains of custodians, it is extremely difficult to have access to financial ownership of all legal entities operating in a country for all institutions excluding law enforcement agencies and supervisory agencies. In the Western world it exists only an exception to this standard way of tracking stock ownership. This is the case of Finland and, for this reason, stock ownership in Finland is the focus of the present study. In fact financial ownership of Finnish legal entities have been investigated by many studies since 2000 grinblatt2000investment ; grinblatt2001distance ; grinblatt2009sensation ; tumminello2012identification ; lillo2015news ; musciotto2016patterns ; musciotto2018long ; baltakiene2019clusters . Some of these studies have investigated investment pattern of Finnish investors over very long period of time musciotto2021high ; keloharju2021quarter . Having the balance at the start of the period and all the transactions for each asset traded by each legal entity, we were able to reconstruct the portfolios for each one of them. In this work we focused on the analysis of portfolios choices made, in particular, by households. In this paper we consider three macro categories of market participants: (i) retail investors, i.e., individual investors. In the technical literature they are also called households; (ii) non-retail investors, which include institutional investors like banks, insurance companies, investment firms and funds, but also non financial companies operating in various industries, national and local governmental organizations and non-profit institutions; (iii) foreign investors both as nominee registered investors or as foreign legal entity directly investing into stocks. Among these macro category of investors, Finnish households, i.e. retail investors, are the largest number of market participants in the Helsinki venue of the Nasdaq Nordic stock exchange. Here we present an empirical study on the long term evolution of household investment in stocks performed at the level of an entire country. Price discovery in the market is emerging due to the investment decisions of all market participants. In a long term study covering more than 20 years, there are many aspects to take into account to properly analyze the system. The number of investors changes over time and the same is true for the number of stocks listed in the stock exchange. Each listed company can change the number of issued stocks, and they can also merge or split into new entities. Stock splits (direct and inverse) are frequently observed. Another aspect influencing the evolution of the market can be represented by regulatory changes occurring at the level of trading , clearing or settlement. Change on the society as, for example, the emergence of coordination through social networks can also affect the way price discovery occurs in a stock market welch2022wisdom . With the present study, we aim to answer to the following questions: (i) How did market participants and in particular household investors stock portfolios change over a period of time of more than 20 years? (ii) Is it possible to characterize quantitatively how the heterogeneity of the system evolve in time? In the present study we will investigate empirically the degree of stock portfolio concentration and the wealth inequality in stock portfolio investment for all legal Finnish entities and for all foreign investors investing in stocks in the Helsinki venue of the Nasdaq Nordic market over a period of 21 years. The portfolio concentration will be quantified through the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) hirschman1964paternity ; hall1967measures and the inequality of stock investment will be quantified through the Lorenz curve gastwirth1972estimation . The dataset we investigate is provided by the Finnish clearing house

Read the complete text