Indication of the electron-to-proton mass ratio variation within the Galaxy

2025

Read Indication of the electron-to-proton mass ratio variation within the Galaxy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-17665.txt.

Introduction

One of nature's fixed numbers, the ratio of the mass of the electron to the mass of the proton, may not be fixed everywhere in our galaxy. Vorotyntseva and Levshakov report a hint of that shift in a 2025 paper. They compared methanol emission lines from two molecular clouds, one near the galactic center and one much closer to us.

Space telescope data showed the far cloud's lines implying a slightly lower mass ratio than the near cloud's. Lines from the near cloud matched laboratory values, which pins the difference to the galactic center cloud. The shift is tiny, a few parts in ten million, and known measurement quirks do not explain it. The authors call for more checks of a result that would shake a basic assumption of physics.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-17665

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Indication of the electron-to-proton mass ratio variation within the Galaxy Abstract Near ( ≈ 100 \approx 100 pc) and far ( ≈ 8.7 \approx 8.7 kpc) relative to the Galactic center, the molecular clouds SgrB2(N) and Orion-KL exhibit different values of the fundamental physical constant μ = m e / m p \mu=m_{\rm e}/m_{\rm p} – the electron-to-proton mass ratio. Measured frequency difference between the emission lines of methanol (CH 3 OH), – J K u → J K ℓ = 6 3 → 5 2 ​ A + J_{K_{u}}\to J_{K_{\ell}}=6_{3}\to 5_{2}A^{+} 542000.981 MHz, 6 3 → 5 2 ​ A − 6_{3}\to 5_{2}A^{-} 542081.936 MHz, and 8 0 → 7 − 1 ​ E 8_{0}\to 7_{-1}E 543076.194 MHz, – observed with the space observatory Herschel toward SgrB2(N) and Orion-KL corresponds to (Sgr-Ori): Δ ​ μ / μ = ( − 3.7 ± 0.5 ) × 10 − 7 \Delta\mu/\mu=(-3.7\pm 0.5)\times 10^{-7} (1 σ \sigma C.L.). At the same time, comparison of the same methanol lines in Orion-KL with laboratory frequencies shows no significant changes in μ \mu (Ori-lab): Δ ​ μ / μ = ( − 0.5 ± 0.6 ) × 10 − 7 \Delta\mu/\mu=(-0.5\pm 0.6)\times 10^{-7} , while a comparison between SgrB2(N) and laboratory lines indicates a lower value of μ \mu near the Galactic center (Sgr-lab): Δ ​ μ / μ = ( − 4.2 ± 0.7 ) × 10 − 7 \Delta\mu/\mu=(-4.2\pm 0.7)\times 10^{-7} . The reduced value of μ \mu in SgrB2(N) is not explained by known systematic effects and requires further investigation. J. S. Vorotyntseva 1 1 1 [email protected] , S. A. Levshakov Ioffe institute, Politechnicheskaya 26, St. Petersburg 194021 Russia 1 Introduction Precision measurements of fundamental physical constants remain a longstanding challenge for both laboratory and space research. Under terrestrial conditions, experiments with atomic clocks, and, more recently, with nuclear clocks, have achieved extremely tight constraints on changes with time of dimensionless physical constant – the fine structure constant ( \alpha=e^{2}/\hbar c ) at the level of 10 -19 yr -1 , and the electron-to-proton mass ratio ( \mu = m_{\rm e}/m_{\rm p} ) at the level of 10 -16 yr -1 . Differential measurements of these quantities at different points of the Earth’s orbit under conditions of changing gravitational potential of the Sun also did not reveal appreciable deviations in the frequencies of the atomic clocks at the level of 10 -8 . Extensive material on this topic was collected by and analyzed in a recent review [ 1 ] . Spatial and temporal changes in physical constants are predicted in various theories extend the Standard Model of particle physics. The necessity for such extension arises, in particular, from attempts to explain the nature of dark matter. Since it has not been possible to detect dark matter particles so far, suggestions have been made about scalar fields that could manifest themselves as dark matter. These fields can modulate the masses of elementary particles, such as electrons and quarks, and, hence, should lead to small variations of \mu [ 2 ] - [ 6 ] . Changes of this kind can affect in turn the structure of energy levels in molecules, which can be detected experimentally. The search for spatial and temporal variations in \mu is related to estimating the quantity \Delta\mu/\mu=(\mu_{obs}-\mu_{lab})/\mu_{lab}, (1) where \mu_{lab} – the laboratory value of \mu , and \mu_{obs} – the value observed in the astronomical objects. This comparison is possible due to the fact that the electro-vibro-rotational transitions in molecular spectra have a specific dependence on the local value of \mu , which is individual for each transition [ 7 , 8 ] . The dependence on \mu is characterized by a dimensionless sensitivity coefficient, Q , which shows the reaction of a given molecular transition with a frequency f to a small change in \mu : Q=\frac{df/f}{d\mu/\mu}, (2) where df/f is the relative frequency shift, and d\mu/\mu is determined by ( 1 ). The values of Q are calculated using quantum-mechanical methods for the transition f=E_{u}-E_{\ell} using the so-called q -factor [ 9 ] : \Delta f=q\frac{\Delta\mu}{\mu}\,, (3) where \Delta f is the frequency change caused by a small variation of \mu , q=q_{u}-q_{\ell} ( in cm -1 ), and Q=\frac{q}{f}. (4) To estimate hypothetical variations of \mu , it is necessary to use pairs of lines with different sensitivity coefficients Q_{1} and Q_{2} observed in the same molecular cloud: \frac{\Delta\mu}{\mu}=\frac{V_{1}-V_{2}}{c(Q_{2}-Q_{1})}, (5) where V_{1} and V_{2} are the measured radial velocities, and c is the speed of light. Note that the conversion to the velocity scale from the frequency scale is carried out according to the radio astronomical convention \frac{V}{c}=\frac{f_{lab}−f_{sky}}{f_{lab}}. (6) At present, the most stringent constraints on \mu -variations in the Galactic disk were obtained from observations of the inversion transition of ammonia NH 3 ( Q = 4.46 [ 10 ] ) and purely rotational transitions ( Q =1) HC 3 N, HC 5 N and HC 7 N: \Delta\mu/\mu<7\times 10^{-9} [ 11 ] . Another perspective molecule for such purposes turned out to be methanol CH 3 OH, and its isotopologues – methanol transitions have high sensitivity coefficients of both signs [ 9 , 12 , 13 ] . Constraints on \mu -variations based on observations of methanol in the Galaxy are established at the level of \Delta\mu/\mu<1\times 10^{-8} [ 14 ] , and for extragalactic objects (at redshift z =0.89) \Delta\mu/\mu<5\times 10^{-8} [ 15 ] . Thus, the expected effect of hypothetical scalar fields on the masses of elementary particles was not revealed at this accuracy level. 2 Methods The most significant problem in achieving a higher accuracy level ( \sim\penalty\ 10^{-9} ) is the errors in laboratory frequencies, which are for methanol lines reach values of 50 kHz in the high frequency range ( f\sim 540 GHz). To reach the level of 10^{-9} , the accuracy must be on the order of several kHz, which is problematic in laboratory measurements. At the same time, astronomical observations make it possible to achieve a rather high accuracy acceptable for precision measurements of \Delta\mu/\mu at the level of 10^{-9} . To minimize the dependence on laboratory frequencies, a slightly modified approach can be used to estimate the \mu -variations, which is as follows. We offer to compare the difference of the measured frequencies ( f_{1}-f_{2} ) of the same pairs of methanol lines with different sensitivity coefficients Q_{1} and Q_{2} observed in two astronomical objects ( a ) and ( b ) at different galactocentric distances. It follows from the relations ( 1 - 4 ) that \frac{\Delta\mu_{a,b}}{\mu}=\frac{\mu_{a}-\mu_{b}}{\mu_{lab}}=\frac{(f_{1,a}-f_{2,a})-(f_{1,b}-f_{2,b})}{\Delta q}, (7) where f_{1,a},f_{2,a} and f_{1,b},f_{2,b} – the observed transition frequencies in the comoving reference frame (corrected for the radial velocity V_{LSR} of the object), and \Delta q=q_{1}-q_{2} – the difference of the q -factors of the compared lines. This method allows us to use only astronomical frequencies without resorting to laboratory measurements. 3 Observations and parameters of Herschel spectra The spectra used in this work were taken from the archive of the space observatory Herschel 2 2 2 Herschel is an ESA space observatory with science instruments provided by European-led Principal Investigator consortia and with important participation from NASA. [ 16 ] . The observations

Read the complete text