Coordinated Shirking in Technology Adoption
Nicholas H. Tenev · 2025
Read Coordinated Shirking in Technology Adoption by Nicholas H. Tenev (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-17613.txt.
Introduction
Nicholas Tenev built an economics model in 2025 about why new workplace tools can fail. A manager wants staff to spend real effort testing a new tool before the group decides to adopt it. Checking takes work, and no one wants to be the only one who bothers.
When staff can act together, they may all skip the checking, since firing a whole group at once costs the manager too much. A widely useful tool can make the problem worse, because the gain from skipping grows. Workers may even keep using a tool they know is flawed. Tenev links the logic to the mortgage crisis and to new AI tools.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicholas H. Tenev |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-17613
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Coordinated Shirking in Technology Adoption Nicholas H. Tenev Abstract This paper studies a model of technology adoption: a manager tries to induce a group of workers to exert costly effort to vet a new technology before they choose whether to use it. The manager finds it too costly to simultaneously replace large groups of unproductive workers, so they shirk when coordination is possible. Widely applicable technology expands productive possibilities but also provides an opportunity for coordinated shirking, and can thus lead to widespread production failure. Furthermore, even workers who learn that they are using flawed technology may continue to do so. Applications include mortgage securitization in the financial crisis of 2008, and the adoption of generative artificial intelligence. Keywords: technology adoption, principal-agent, artificial intelligence, financial crisis, Gaussian copula, mortgage securitization JEL codes: G01, O33, J33, M52 1 Introduction New technologies are typically expected to increase productivity and output. However, if not properly vetted they may be misused, with potentially ruinous consequences. For example, a formula used to price mortgage-backed securities could understate the risk of widespread defaults, as happened in the lead-up to the financial crisis of 2008. Or to give an example using an emerging technology, generative artificial intelligence (AI) can produce text that seems correct but actually contains serious factual errors (“hallucinations”). This paper shows that the very popularity of a technology can create an agency friction, leading to coordinated shirking amongst those who are supposed to be vetting it. Specifically, workers evaluating new technology may shirk their duty when it is sufficiently widespread in use, since their employers may not credibly be able to threaten to fire all of them. Counterintuitively, new technology can thus result in a drop in output even as it expands production possibilities. This paper models this agency friction, applies it to real-world examples, and discusses policy implications for mitigation. In the model, a lone principal (manager) seeks to induce effort from a group of agents (workers). A new technology has arrived, and is applicable to a certain fraction of the agents. If the technology is “good” it increases production for those who use it, but in rare cases it is “bad” and reduces production to zero. Agents with access to the new technology can exert costly research effort to obtain a noisy signal of whether it is good. After obtaining this signal (or shirking and seeing no signal), these agents decide whether or not to use the new technology. The principal is unable to observe the agents’ effort or signals, but she can observe whether they use the technology and, eventually, their production. She is able to punish agents who fail to produce by replacing them, but some replacements cost more than others, so the total cost is convex in the number of agents punished. The main idea is that the principal may be unable to credibly threaten punishment to large groups of agents who shirk simultaneously: a “too many to fail” problem. The idea that mass punishment may be infeasible has been exploited in various contexts throughout history, such as “round robin” complaints that arranged petitioners’ names in a circle to reduce the risk of individual reprisal, used by 18 {}^{\text{th}} century European sailors ( Leeson 2010a ) and Edo period farmers in Japan ( Masamichi 2021a ) , among others. It also appears in the work of Acharya & Yorulmazer 2008a ; Acharya & Yorulmazer 2007a and Farhi & Tirole 2012a , in which the promise of government bailouts in an aggregate downturn can prompt banks to correlate the returns of their investments. This paper’s novelty is in the application of this mechanism to technology adoption, and focuses on the friction introduced by the interaction of technological progress with the convexity in the principal’s cost of punishment. The focus here is on workers’ technology adoption choices, which can interact with firm-level dynamics: hasty adoption by workers may exacerbate firms’ rushing to establish first-mover advantage ( Fudenberg & Tirole 1985a ) , and undermine waiting for technology to be proven ( Hoppe 2000a ) . Throughout, we apply the model to two important examples of technology adoption—one from recent history, and the other contemporary. 1. Mortgage securitization and the 2008 financial crisis The first application is the adoption of pricing models that facilitated the credit boom preceding the financial crisis of 2008. Gaussian copula models in particular were developed in the late 1950’s but became popular with practioners in the early 2000’s, and were ubiquitous in pricing collateralized debt obligation (CDO) including securities backed by subprime mortgages. 1 1 1 Coval et al. 2009a provide a primer on securitized products and their role in the crisis; see also Zimmer 2012a . This technology became public knowledge in the finance community ( MacKenzie & Spears 2014a ) 2 2 2 MacKenzie & Spears 2014a study the use of Gaussian copula models and their role in the 2008 financial crisis, reporting on 95 interviews of financial services workers, of which 29 took place before July 2007. and allowed risky loans to be bundled into seemingly safer securities, making them palatable to investors with less appetite for risk. But when more borrowers than predicted defaulted at once, the securitized products formed from their loans lost much of their value. A large asset price shock does not necessarily imply mistakes in modeling. However, Zimmer 2012a finds that the degree to which house prices are related is insufficiently captured by a Gaussian copula, even using data available before 2002. And industry practitioners expressed “pervasive dissatisfaction” with Gaussian copula models even as early as 2006 ( MacKenzie & Spears 2014a ) . So despite uncertainty and even pessimism about the use of a new financial technology, its use continued. 3 3 3 In fact, traders who wanted to use models other than Gaussian copulas had trouble convincing risk controllers that their positions were properly hedged ( MacKenzie & Spears 2014a ) . So while using the new technology was essentially free, not using it was made even more difficult by risk policies than this paper assumes. But why? This paper provides an answer to this puzzle, modeling an agency friction that can cause a particularly useful innovation to precipitate a downturn in production. The model is simple, and cannot capture all the subtlety of model selection and evaluation, let alone the myriad other factors contributing to the financial crisis. Nonetheless, it cleanly illuminates an important tension: a technology’s popularity can belie its unsoundness. 2. Generative artificial intelligence This friction is also useful in understanding risk in the adoption of generative artificial intelligence (AI). In response to a user prompt written in plain language, generative AI such as large language models (LLMs) can quickly produce responses that read as though written by a human, accomplishing tasks such as summarizing documents ( Zhang et al. 2024a ) and generating computer code ( Idrisov & Schlippe 2024a ) . Designed to mimic human intelligence, the range of industries and activities this technology may improve is vast, if still limited currently ( McElheran et al. 2024a ) , and informal adoption is growing rapidly ( Bick et al. 2024a ) . 4 4 4 While this paper focuses on AI as