Vacuum Axisymmetric Gravitational Collapse revisited: preliminary investigation
Andrzej Rostworowski · 2025
Read Vacuum Axisymmetric Gravitational Collapse revisited: preliminary investigation by Andrzej Rostworowski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-17549.txt.
Introduction
Andrzej Rostworowski goes back to a classic numerical relativity test: whether ripples in empty spacetime can focus and collapse into a black hole. The result from the early 1990s by Abrahams and Evans has led to decades of attempts to verify it. The threshold behavior is a trap for numeric work. The work reports first steps toward a check of his own.
Rostworowski sets up Einstein's equations for a vacuum, axisymmetric spacetime with vanishing twist in spherical-polar coordinates. A linear version of the system is derived alongside the full one. The author finds concrete blocks to stable evolution exactly at the collapse threshold, where the key physics lives. The work is openly a first step, aimed at a setup that can survive the critical regime.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andrzej Rostworowski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-17549
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Vacuum Axisymmetric Gravitational Collapse revisited: preliminary investigation Andrzej Rostworowski Abstract Validating the results of [A.M. Abrahams and C.R. Evans, Phys. Rev. Lett. , 70:2980–2983] poses a numerical challenge and has been inspiring a lot of research. We join these efforts and present our first steps to achieve this goal: we discuss a formulation of the Einstein equations for a vacuum axisymmetric spacetime with vanishing twist in spherical-polar coordinates, its linearised approximation, and identify some problems in achieving numerically stable evolution at the threshold of a black hole formation. I Introduction Soon after Choptuik’s seminal discovery of critical phenomena in spherically symmetric gravitational collapse of a massless scalar field [ 7 ] , Abrahams and Evans (hereafter AE) reported analogous results, suggesting the universality of a black hole (BH) mass scaling at the threshold of BH formation and existence of the universal discretly self-similar critical solution in axisymmetric gravitational collapse of polar gravitational waves (GW) [ 3 , 4 ] . Although over 30 years has passed since the publication of [ 3 ] , witnessing enormous progress in computational power and a lot of research inspired by AE findings, no one, to the best of our knowledge, was able to reproduce AE results in their original settings. Thus two questions do arise: first, are AE results reproducible and second (in case of the positive answer), is the behaviour at the BH formation threshold in axisymmetric collapse of genuine gravitational waves qualitatively the same as in the spherically symmetric model with a scalar field? The most up-to-date answer to the second question is ”probably not” as a recent comparison of the results of three independent codes from three independent groups shows [ 5 ] . In particular, as the authors of [ 5 ] show, the behaviour at the threshold seems to be initial data dependent casting doubts on universality suggested by [ 3 , 4 ] and making the criticality beyond spherical symmetry far more complicated than initially expected (for a nice summary of earlier attempts on validating AE results see [ 11 ] ). Still, the first question about reproducing AE numerical results remains valid, and worth answering. Moreover, in spite of strong evidence presented in [ 5 ] against universality at the threshold of BH formation, it cannot be completely ruled out, as one can always argue that the lack of observing universality is due to insufficiently precise fine tuning to the critical solution. Also, it seems that the careful use and distinction between extrinsic curvatures and extrinsic curvatures scaled by a proper power of a conformal factor ( hatted extrinsic curvatures in AE notation), present in [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] has been forgotten in later works [ 10 , 8 ] , then rediscovered and carefully commented on by Rinne [ 18 ] and then surprisingly forgotten again in [ 12 , 13 ] . Therefore, in our opinion, going back to AE formulation may pay off. Also, the original AE setting seems to be well suited to implement higher order metric perturbations [ 19 ] , thus offering some theoretical advantages. We should also stress a long history behind [ 3 , 4 ] that started with the Evans’ PhD thesis [ 9 ] and then continued through linearised approximation [ 1 ] , and finally the evolution given by the Einstein equations, with dispersion for small initial data and gravitational collapse for large initial data [ 2 ] . Thus AE were well equipped to study this problem and the results presented in [ 3 ] were based on solid grounds. On the other hand it is impossible to reproduce the AE results from the paper [ 4 ] , simply because, as was pointed out in [ 12 ] , their formula for the seed function generating initial data profiles (Eq.(6) in [ 4 ] ) does not agree with what is present on their Fig. 1. Moreover this formula with its numerical constant and the value of the amplitude a\approx 1 seems to be an order of magnitude above the threshold of BH formation, see below. With all this in mind, we have constructed a fully constrained pseudospectral code based on AE set of equations. It performs well for small initial data that disperse, and large initial data that collapse promptly, but it is still facing some problems for the initial data close to the collapse threshold that require relatively long stable evolution in the nonlinear regime. We hope to overcome these problems in the future, with a proper filtering techniques or a better numerical treatment of the most disturbing terms in the equations, but in this paper we make a step back and focus mostly on the linearised problem that admits exact solutions. We present the evidence that in this case, the code that solves the system of linearised equations, but otherwise is based on exactly the same numerical principles as a fully nonlinear code, performs very well. The linearised solution to the AE system of equations was constructed in [ 1 ] , but we find this paper rather cumbersome and present an independent derivation based on our approach [ 19 ] that is quite straightforward and moreover is perfectly well suited to extend linearised approximation to higher orders - the problem that we postpone for a future work. The paper is organised as follows. In Sec. II we carefully discuss the AE ansatz for the line element and the resulting system of the Einstein equations. In Sec. III we present in detail our derivation of the linearised approximation for the quadrupole ( \ell=2 ) gravitational waves and we comment on what we believe was AE treatment of the initial data since that problem seemed to cause some confusion in the past [ 12 , 13 ] . In Sec. IV we describe the numerical techniques that we use to solve both the full system of the Einstein equations and its linearised version and present the performance of the code in solving the set of linearised equations by computing the L^{2} -norms of differences between numerical and analytical solutions. Finally, we conclude in Sec. V and give an outlook for future work. II Setting of the problem The original AE setting is based on quasi-isotropic spherical-polar coordinates with a simplifying assumption of the Killing vector (generating axial symmetry) being hypersurface-orthogonal (the so called twist-free ansatz), resulting in the line element of the form ds^{2}=-\alpha^{2}dt^{2}+\phi^{4}\left[\left(e^{2\eta/3}\left(dr+\beta^{r}dt\right)^{2}\right)+e^{2\eta/3}r^{2}\left(\frac{du}{\sqrt{1+u^{2}}}+\beta^{u}dt\right)^{2}+e^{-4\eta/3}r^{2}\left(1-u^{2}\right)d\varphi^{2}\right]\,, (1) where 0\leq r<\infty is the radial coordinate and 1\geq u=\cos\theta\geq-1 is the angular coordinate (that we use instead of the polar angle \theta ). All five metric functions ( \eta , \phi , \alpha , \beta^{r} , \beta^{u} ) are functions of (t,r,u) coordinates. In particular, this ansatz encompasses the Schwarzschild BH (in isotropic coordinates): ds^{2}=-\left(\frac{1-M/(2r)}{1+M/(2r)}\right)^{2}dt^{2}+\left(1+M/(2r)\right)^{4}\left(dr^{2}+r^{2}\frac{du^{2}}{1+u^{2}}+r^{2}\left(1-u^{2}\right)d\varphi^{2}\right)\,, (2) but it does not encompass the Kerr BH, which is due to the twist-free property. In other words, referring to the jargon of metric perturbations, the line element ( 1 ) is a consistent truncation to the polar sector of perturbations, with \eta being the only one (polar) gravitational degree of freedom (instead of two gravitational degrees of freedom present in the general ansatz). Although polar