Modelling the Climate Change Debate in Italy through Information Supply and Demand

Irene Scalco, Giulia Colafrancesco, Matteo Cinelli · 2025

Read Modelling the Climate Change Debate in Italy through Information Supply and Demand by Irene Scalco, Giulia Colafrancesco, Matteo Cinelli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-17026.txt.

Introduction

Irene Scalco, Giulia Colafrancesco, and Matteo Cinelli wrote this research paper, published in 2025. It models Italy's climate change debate as a market of information, where media supply content and the public's curiosity creates demand.

Supply was measured from posts on Facebook and Instagram plus an online news database. Demand came from Google search volumes. The two sides proved responsive to each other, moving together especially when outside events, like extreme weather or policy moments, spiked attention. The ecosystem adapted quickly to those surges. Yet persistent voids appeared, topics the public wanted but supply ignored, or the reverse. The authors warn that such gaps can stall understanding and delay engagement with the climate transition. The model offers officials a way to spot voids before they harden.

Catalog record

CREATORIrene Scalco, Giulia Colafrancesco, Matteo Cinelli
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-17026

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modelling the Climate Change Debate in Italy through Information Supply and Demand Irene Scalco, Giulia Colafrancesco, Matteo Cinelli Abstract Climate change is one of the most critical challenges of the twenty-first century. Public understanding of climate issues and of the goals regarding the climate transition is essential to translate awareness into concrete actions. Social media platforms play a crucial role in disseminating information about climate change and climate policy. In this context, we propose a model that analyses the Supply and Demand of information to better understand information circulation and information voids within the Italian climate-transition discourse. We conceptualise information supply as the production of content on Facebook and Instagram while leveraging Google searches to capture information demand. Our findings highlight the persistence of information voids, which can hinder informed decision-making and collective action. Furthermore, we observe that the dynamics of information supply and demand on climate-related topics tend to intensify in response to significant external events, shaping public attention and social media discourse. keywords Climate Change, Public Opinion, Social Media, Information Void 1 Introduction Anthropogenic climate change is an unprecedented challenge for humanity IPCC 2021 , and the past decade has been the warmest in the last 125,000 years IPCC 2022 with far-reaching consequences that influence both the natural environment and social systems Schmidt et al. 2013 . Climate change is a central topic in public debate David 2022 , environmental policy Change 2001 ; Fekete et al. 2021 , and public discourse. Tackling its catastrophic impacts within the time frame dictated by science it’s of paramount importance IPCC 2018 . However, the process of transitioning away from fossil fuels, the main contributing factor to climate change is hampered by an increasing polarised political debate Birch 2020 ; Falkenberg et al. 2022 . Therefore, understanding how the public perceives climate change and how this influences their actions is crucial for the effectiveness of climate policies. Given its magnitude and the interdependence of the actors involved, climate change represents a multidimensional challenge: while it requires collective action and global coordination IPCC 2014 ; Change et al. 2014 , the process of transitioning away from fossil fuel falls heavily on sectors within people’s private sphere of action (i.e. building and transports Winkler et al. 2023 ). In this context, improving public understanding of the phenomena, as well as the role that different social groups should play within the transition process, is crucial to transform the debate into concrete actions Torricelli et al. 2023 and achieving climate targets at regional and global levels. Social media platforms play a crucial role in the dissemination of information related to climate change and climate policy. Previous research has explored the relationship between major events such as extreme climate events Torricelli et al. 2023 ; Mumenthaler et al. 2021 ; Kirilenko et al. 2015 , international conferences Falkenberg et al. 2022 , and climate protests Lochner et al. 2024 , and public interest in climate-related issues. These studies have generally found that public engagement with climate change increases when significant events occur, drawing widespread attention and prompting discussions. The topic of climate change is closely linked to the spread of conspiracy theories and misinformation Treen et al. 2020 ; Van der Linden et al. 2017 ; Candellone et al. 2024 , highlighting the need for effective countermeasures. These include fact-checking and corrections but should also extend beyond them by prioritizing the timely production of high-quality information Cinelli et al. 2022 . Ideally, this should occur before the emergence of so-called information voids, which serve as hotspots for misinformation Golebiewski and danah boyd 2019 ; Aslett et al. 2024 due to the scarcity of relevant data and the lack of reliable information on topics of interest to online users Purnat et al. 2021 . In this paper, we tackle the relationship between information supply and demand and the emergence of information voids through a case study including relevant topics for climate change in Italy. The considered topics were selected after consultation with experts working for an independent Italian non-profit think tank dedicated to climate change. The research examines the supply and demand dynamics of climate change-related information on two major social media platforms, Facebook and Instagram. To date, the role of social media as an information source and a forum for public debate AlDayel and Magdy 2021 ; Avalle et al. 2024 ; Tucker et al. 2018 ; Cinelli et al. 2021 is well documented in the literature, including studies on climate change communication Schäfer 2012 ; Pearce et al. 2019 ; Cody et al. 2015 . Specifically, information supply is defined as the production of content on these platforms, with the analysis focusing on the Italian information ecosystem from December 2022 to August 2024. Information demand is modelled for the same geographical area and topics, using Google Trends data. Google Trends is a tool that provides reports on the popularity of specific searches conducted on the Google search engine. We find that the demand of information (searches on Google Trends) almost always exceeds the supply of information (posts on social media). Although the volume of demand is generally higher, the considered variables display fluctuating trends over time often in correspondence with related real-world events. However, despite this variability, demand and supply curves tend to follow similar patterns across most of the analysed topics. The cross-correlation analysis confirms that information supply responds promptly to changes in demand. To gain a deeper understanding of information voids, we study the time series emerging from the difference between supply and demand obtaining a dynamic characterization of excess and lack of information. Finally, we analyse the relationship between information voids (demand greater than supply) and information excess (supply greater than demand) with social media engagement. The findings suggest that, within the context of climate transition, information voids are particularly pronounced but, perhaps due to the close coupling of supply and demand curves, users engagement do not show clear correlation patterns with the lack and excess of information. 2 Results 2.1 Trends of production and demand We study the information ecosystem as a market driven by two forces: Supply and Demand. Since these two quantities are likely to evolve over time and respond to both external events and mutual interactions, we begin by visualizing their trends over the period from December 2022 to August 2024, as shown in Fig. 1 . The figure displays weekly time series for all the considered topics, one per each panel, on one of the two platforms - namely Facebook. The results for the other platform (Instagram) are reported in the Supplementary Information (SI) and show consistent findings. We notice that demand (Google Trends) almost always exceeds supply (Facebook posts in this case) and that the curves display similar shapes, suggesting a dynamic interaction between them. To ensure comparability in terms of volume and time scale, we transformed Facebook and Instagram data separately, aligning them with the scale and granularity of Google Trends (see Methods for details). Furthermore, the curves appear to be sensitive with respect to external events, as observed particularly in the demand and supply curves for the topics Cycle Lanes and Pedestrian Areas . Notably, an increase in both demand and supply is evident

Read the complete text