Magnetic ground states and the conformal class of a surface
Bruno Colbois, Luigi Provenzano, Alessandro Savo · 2025
Read Magnetic ground states and the conformal class of a surface by Bruno Colbois, Luigi Provenzano, Alessandro Savo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16940.txt.
Introduction
Bruno Colbois, Luigi Provenzano, and Alessandro Savo studied magnetic Laplacians on curved surfaces in twenty twenty-five. On a closed surface, a magnetic field twists the usual Laplace operator, and its lowest eigenvalue gives the ground state energy of a charged particle. That energy is positive unless the magnetic potential sits in a special arithmetic class.
Collecting the ground state energies over all such potentials gives a countable set the authors call the ground state spectrum of the metric. Their main theorem: this spectrum determines the surface's volume and its conformal class, the shape up to local stretching. Hyperbolic metrics are singled out by their spectra. The authors also compute the spectrum for flat tori and define new conformal invariants tied to the surface's Jacobian torus.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bruno Colbois, Luigi Provenzano, Alessandro Savo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16940
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Magnetic ground states and the conformal class of a surface Bruno Colbois, Luigi Provenzano, Alessandro Savo Abstract Abstract. On a closed, orientable Riemannian surface \Sigma_{g} of arbitrary genus g\geq 1 and Riemannian metric h we study the magnetic Laplacian with magnetic potential given by a harmonic 1 -form A . Its lowest eigenvalue (magnetic ground state energy) is positive, unless A represents an integral cohomology class. We isolate a countable set of ground state energies which we call ground state spectrum of the metric h . The main result of the paper is to show that the ground state spectrum determines the volume and the conformal class of the metric h . In particular, hyperbolic metrics are distinguished by their ground state spectrum. We also compute the magnetic spectrum of flat tori and introduce some magnetic spectral invariants of (\Sigma_{g},h) which are conformal by definition and involve the geometry of what we call the Jacobian torus of (\Sigma_{g},h) (in Algebraic Geometry, the Jacobian variety of a Riemann surface). Keywords: Riemann surface, magnetic Laplacian, ground state energy 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification: 58J50, 58J53, 35P15, 53C18 1 Introduction In this paper we will study the ground state energy of the magnetic Laplacian with zero magnetic field on 2 -dimensional compact surfaces with empty boundary. In this short introduction we define the magnetic Laplacian and introduce some of its fundamental properties. The main results will be discussed in Section 2 . Let (M,h) be a compact Riemannian manifold without boundary; note that h denotes the metric (the notation g is reserved for the genus of a surface, considered below). A magnetic potential is by definition a smooth real 1 -form A on M . It defines a magnetic gradient \nabla^{A} acting on C^{\infty}(M,\mathbb{C}) by the formula \nabla^{A}u=\nabla u-iuA^{\sharp} where \nabla denotes the gradient in the metric h and A^{\sharp} is the dual vector field of A ( vector potential ). Dually, one can define the magnetic differential of u as the complex 1 -form d^{A}u=du-iuA. The magnetic Laplacian \Delta_{A} is given by (\nabla^{A})^{*}\nabla^{A} and may be written \Delta_{A}u=\Delta u+2i\langle A,du\rangle_{h}+(|A|_{h}^{2}-i\delta A)u (1) where \delta=d^{\star} denotes the codifferential and \Delta the usual Laplacian; our sign convention is that, on {\mathbb{R}}^{n} : \Delta u=-\sum_{k}\frac{\partial^{2}u}{\partial x_{k}^{2}} . Equivalently, \Delta_{A}=\delta^{A}d^{A} , where \delta^{A} is the magnetic codifferential, acting on the 1 -form \omega by \delta^{A}\omega=\delta\omega+i\langle{A},{\omega}\rangle_{h} . Since \Delta_{A} defines a compact self-adjoint operator with dense domain in L^{2}(M,dv_{h}) , we have a non-negative, discrete spectrum 0\leq\lambda_{1}(M,h,A)\leq\lambda_{2}(M,h,A)\leq\dots\leq\lambda_{k}(M,h,A)\leq\dots diverging to +\infty . The magnetic ground state energy is the first eigenvalue \lambda_{1}(M,h,A) of \Delta_{A} ; it has the usual variational characterization \lambda_{1}(M,h,A)=\min_{0\neq u\in C^{\infty}(M,\mathbb{C})}R_{A}(u) (2) where R_{A} is the Rayleigh quotient associated with \Delta_{A} : R_{A}(u)=\frac{\int_{M}|\nabla^{A}u|_{h}^{2}dv_{h}}{\int_{M}|u|^{2}dv_{h}}. One sees immediately that \Delta_{A} reduces to the usual Laplace-Beltrami operator when A=0 , giving rise to the same spectrum: \lambda_{k}(M,h,0)=\lambda_{k}(M,h) where on the right we have the k -th eigenvalue of the Laplace-Beltrami operator. Note that we number the eigenvalues so that \lambda_{1}(M,h)=0 , hence, in this paper, the lowest positive eigenvalue of the Laplace-Beltrami operator is \lambda_{2}(M,h) . A fundamental feature of the magnetic Laplacian is gauge invariance , expressed in the following lemma. Recall that the flux of a 1 -form A on the closed curve c is defined as \frac{1}{2\pi}\oint_{c}A . \bullet\quad We say that the closed 1 -form A is integral if the flux of A around every loop in M is an integer. Note that exact 1 -forms have zero flux around any loop, hence they are trivially integral. Lemma 1 . Assume that A and A^{\prime} are closed potential 1 -forms such that A-A^{\prime} is integral. Then \lambda_{k}(M,h,A)=\lambda_{k}(M,h,A^{\prime}) for all k\in\mathbb{N} . In fact, if A-A^{\prime} is exact: A-A^{\prime}=d\phi , the operators \Delta_{A} and \Delta_{A}^{\prime} are unitarily equivalent because of the formula \Delta_{A}e^{i\phi}=e^{i\phi}\Delta_{A^{\prime}} and then have the same spectrum. If more generally A-A^{\prime} is integral the above holds with \phi(x)=\int_{x_{0}}^{x}(A-A^{\prime})\doteq\int_{\gamma}(A-A^{\prime}) , where x_{0} is any fixed point and the integral is taken along any curve \gamma joining x_{0} and x . Note that \phi(x) is multi-valued: if \gamma and \tilde{\gamma} are curves joining x_{0} and x then \int_{\gamma}(A-A^{\prime})-\int_{\tilde{\gamma}}(A-A^{\prime})\in 2\pi\mathbb{Z} by the integrality assumption, hence the function e^{i\phi} is well-defined and smooth. Our main attention is given to \lambda_{1}(M,h,A) , the ground state energy of (M,h) for the potential A : it is important to know when it is strictly positive. The following fact is due to Shigekawa (for a proof, see [ 10 , Appendix 5] ). Theorem 2 . One has \lambda_{1}(M,h,A)=0 if and only if A is closed and integral (that is, A has integral flux around every loop in M ). In this paper we will consider closed potentials A , so that the magnetic field B vanishes: B\doteq dA=0 . According to Theorem 2 , the ground state energy could be strictly positive, precisely when the potential A has non-integral flux around some loop in M . In the literature, this corresponds to a phenomenon in quantum mechanics called Aharonov-Bohm effect , observed in experimental physics: hence the condition dA=0 is far from being trivial. This condition is very interesting also from the spectral geometric point of view, as we shall see very soon. Let {\rm Har}(M,h) be the vector space of h -harmonic 1 -forms on (M,h) ; by the Hodge-de Rham theorem, it is isomorphic to the first de Rham cohomology space H^{1}(M,\mathbb{R}) . Observe that, if A is closed, we have by gauge invariance that \lambda_{1}(M,h,A)=\lambda_{1}(M,h,\tilde{A}) , where \tilde{A} is the unique harmonic representative of A . Hence, we can restrict our attention to harmonic potential forms, and so we can view the ground state energy as a function \lambda_{1}(M,h,\cdot):{\rm Har}(M,h)\to[0,\infty) taking A to \lambda_{1}(M,h,A) . A simple but important result of this paper is the computation of the Hessian of this function at A=0 (see Theorem 3 ). Next, let \mathcal{L}^{*} be the lattice in {\rm Har}(M,h) formed by the integral 1 -forms; as an abelian group, it is isomorphic to H^{1}(M,\mathbb{Z}) . Note that Theorem 2 says precisely that \bullet\quad \lambda_{1}(M,h,A)=0 if and only if A\in\mathcal{L}^{\star} . By gauge invariance, we conclude that the ground state energy is really a function on the quotient: \lambda_{1}(M,h,\cdot):{\rm Har}(M,h)/{\mathcal{L}^{\star}}\to[0,\infty). \bullet\quad Suitably renormalized, the quotient torus {\rm Har}(M,h)/{\mathcal{L}^{\star}} will be called the Jacobian torus of (M,h) (see Subsection 2.4 ). When M is a Riemannian surface, it is a conformal invariant, known in Algebraic Geometry as the Jacobian variety of (M,h) . We now recall a result from [ 10 ] which partly inspired the present paper. We endow {\rm Har}(M,h) with the L^{2} -inner product of forms, and define the distance of A\in{\rm Har}(M,h) to the lattice \mathcal{L}^{*} as follows: d_{h}(A,\mathcal{L}^{*})^{2}=\min\{\|\omega-A\|^{2}_{L^{2}(h)};\ \omega\in\mathcal{L}^{*}\}. (3) Then we have the upper bound [ 10 , Theorem 3] : \lambda_{1}(M,h,A)\leq\frac{1}{{\rm vol}(M,h)}d_{h}(A,\mathcal{L}^{*})^{2}. (4) It also follows from [ 10 , Theorem 5] that when M is a two-dimensional torus, we have equality in ( 4 ) if and only if M is flat. 1.1 Preliminary comments The spectrum of the magnetic Laplacian has received great attention lately, also from the purely mathematical point of view, on which we focus here. In the paper [ 10 ] a series of upper bounds have been proved, some