Bridging Classical and Modern Approaches to Thales’ Theorem
Piotr Błaszczyk, Anna Petiurenko · 2025
Read Bridging Classical and Modern Approaches to Thales’ Theorem by Piotr Błaszczyk, Anna Petiurenko (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16684.txt.
Introduction
Piotr Błaszczyk and Anna Petiurenko revisit a classic geometry theorem in a 2025 paper. Thales' theorem links parallel lines and proportional segments in triangles. It anchors Euclid's theory of similar triangles in Book Six of the Elements. Over the twentieth century, several axiomatic systems rebuilt geometry on new foundations. Each had to choose its own starting point in place of Euclid's ancient notion of proportion.
The authors reconstruct Euclid's theory and its modern counterparts side by side. In the final sections they turn to newer ground: geometry over non Archimedean number fields, and proofs checked by machine. They prove the theorem over the hyperreal numbers without the Archimedean axiom. They also present a system that keeps Euclid's deductive order while meeting modern rigor, and that extends to automated proofs of Book Six.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Piotr Błaszczyk, Anna Petiurenko |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16684
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Bridging Classical and Modern Approaches to Thales’ Theorem Piotr Błaszczyk, Anna Petiurenko Abstract . In this paper, we reconstruct Euclid’s theory of similar triangles, as developed in Book VI of the Elements , along with its 20th-century counterparts, formulated within the systems of Hilbert, Birkhoff, Borsuk and Szmielew, Millman and Parker, as well as Hartshorne. In the final sections, we present recent developments concerning non-Archimedean fields and mechanized proofs. Thales’ theorem (VI.2) serves as the reference point in our comparisons. It forms the basis of Euclid’s system and follows from VI.1—the only proposition within the theory of similar triangles that explicitly applies the definition of proportion. Instead of the ancient proportion, modern systems adopt the arithmetic of line segments or real numbers. Accordingly, they adopt other propositions from Euclid’s Book VI, such as VI.4, VI.6, or VI.9, as a basis. In § 10, we present a system that, while meeting modern criteria of rigor, reconstructs Euclid’s theory and mimics its deductive structure, beginning with VI.1. This system extends to automated proofs of Euclid’s propositions from Book VI. Systems relying on real numbers provide the foundation for trigonometry as applied in modern mathematics. In § 9, we prove Thales’ theorem in geometry over the hyperreal numbers. Just as Hilbert managed to prove Thales’ theorem without referencing the Archimedean axiom, so do we by applying the arithmetic of the non-Archimedean field of hyperreal numbers. Keywords: Thales’ theorem, 20th-century foundations of geometry, the Elements , mechanical proofs 1. Interpretating Thales’ Theorem and Euclidean Proportion 1. Thales’ theorem, also known as the intercept theorem or the fundamental theorem of proportionality, plays a central role in Euclid’s theory of similar figures, as developed in Book VI of the Elements [ fitz2008 ] . The first proposition of this book, VI.1, states that triangles with the same height are to each other as their bases. Proposition VI.2 is what has been referred to as Thales’ theorem since the 19th century. Propositions VI.4–7 outline the criteria for similar triangles, with VI.4 stating that in equiangular triangles, corresponding sides are proportional. In modern reconstructions of Euclid’s theory of similar figures, Proposition VI.4 is crucial because it forms the foundation of trigonometry. However, for the reasons explained below, modern geometry has abandoned the ancient concept of proportion. Therefore, the general objective is to reestablish VI.4 on grounds independent of Euclidean proportion as defined in Book V of the Elements . 2. Euclidean proportion is the most significant ancient Greek theory transmitted to early modern mathematics. In contrast to Euclidean rigor, early modern mathematicians applied it in unorthodox ways. Although governed by the Archimedean axiom, the theory was applied to both standard and infinitesimal triangles. It laid the foundations for early modern optics, mechanics, and the advancements of 17th-century calculus. Viewed from the perspective of mathematical techniques, Newton’s Principia represents a synthesis of Euclidean proportion and infinitesimals. In contemporary mathematics, trigonometry encodes the Euclidean theory of similar triangles. Contrary to the widespread view advanced by 20th-century structuralism in the philosophy of mathematics, trigonometry is a part of modern calculus that does not derive solely from the axioms of real numbers. 3. Euclidean proportion and calculus converge in determining the derivative of \sin x . To this end, the following trigonometric identity is essential: \sin(x+h)-\sin x=2\sin\frac{h}{2}\cos(x+\frac{h}{2}), which rests on Euclidean principles of similar triangles. Furthermore, evaluating the limit \lim\limits_{h\rightarrow 0}\frac{\sin h}{h} also necessitates reference to Euclidean geometry. Moreover, trigonometry, as applied in calculus, requires the radian measure of angles, which, in turn, relies on the final proposition of Euclid’s Book VI. Based on these foundations, calculus techniques, such as derivatives and power series, are applied to trigonometric functions [ blaszczyk2025 ] . 4. Nowadays, Euclidean proportion, in a more accessible form, is commonly encountered in school mathematics or historical contexts. It is typically expressed using fractions rather than its original formulation. In fact, the foundational achievement of Descartes’ La Géométrie (1637) [ descartes1637 ] was the transformation of proportion into the arithmetic of line segments through the implicit rule [ blaszczyk2024 ] : a:b::c:d\Rightarrow a=b\cdot{\frac{c}{d}}. In a definition of sorts, Descartes introduced the product and division of line segments on the very first pages of his essay through a diagram: given AB=1 , the line EB is the product of DB and CB ; similarly, CB is the result of dividing EB by DB ; see Fig. 1 . Obviously, these definitions are not rigorous by modern standards. Rather, they can be interpreted as an application of Thales’ theorem: instead of the proportion DB:1::EB:CB , Descartes introduces a novel operations, namely EB=DB\cdot CD and BC=\frac{EB}{DB} . Throughout La Géométrie , these operations, along with the addition of line segments, satisfy the laws of an ordered field. These rules were applied in mathematics implicitly until the end of the 19th century when Hilbert introduced the axioms of an ordered field [ ref_DH99 , hilbert1900 ] . Thus, alongside trigonometry – presented either in elementary form or as power series – Euclidean proportion resonates in modern calculus through the laws of an ordered field. Figure 1 . La Géom étrie, p. 298 (left). An interpretation of Descartes’ definition (right) 4. Moritz Pasch’s Vorlesungen über Neuere Geometrie (1882) [ pasch1882 ] initiated the process of establishing Euclidean geometry on new foundations. Hilbert’s Grundlagen der Geometrie and other 20th-century systems that followed also sought to reconstruct the Euclidean theory of similar figures within these new frameworks. The ancient concept of proportion was abandoned, giving rise to two general strategies: one based on the arithmetic of line segments and the other on the properties of real numbers, understood as an ordered field with completeness. The arithmetic of line segments is inspired by Descartes’ arithmetic. Indeed, instead of Descartes’ arbitrary angle \angle DBE , one can use a right angle while adopting Descartes’ definitions; see Fig. 10 or 13 . In this formulation, the rules of an ordered field can be justified within Euclidean proportion; see § 3 below. However, while Descartes introduced ordered field arithmetic based on the ancient concept of proportion, namely, a\cdot d=c\cdot b\Leftrightarrow_{df}a:b::c:d, modern geometry seeks to replicate ancient proportions through the laws of an ordered field. In contemporary frameworks, Euclidean proportion is recovered as the product of line segments: a:b=c:d\Leftrightarrow_{df}a\cdot d=c\cdot b, or within the arithmetic of real numbers: a:b=c:d\Leftrightarrow_{df}\frac{a}{b}=\frac{c}{d}. Below, we examine variations of the first approach by discussing the systems of Hilbert and Hartshorne in §§ 4 and 5, respectively. In this approach, as in Euclid and Descartes, a,b,c,d stand for line segments. The second strategy relies on real numbers and considers relationships between the lengths of line segments, that is, real numbers assigned to line segments based on axioms or sophisticated arguments. Geometry developed in mainstream mathematics interprets Euclidean geometry within the so-called Euclidean spaces \mathbb{R}^{n} , with \mathbb{R}^{2} serving as the model example of the Euclidean plane. This approach either incorporates a form of completeness for real numbers into the axioms of geometry or assumes a bijection between a geometric line and the real numbers. To be clear, this approach seeks to justify, through foundational studies, what really happened when 20th-century mathematics established its foundations on real numbers. Below, we address real-numbers approaches by discussing the systems of