Efficient use of quantum computers for collider physics
Christian W. Bauer · 2025
Read Efficient use of quantum computers for collider physics by Christian W. Bauer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16602.txt.
Introduction
Particle collider measurements mix physics from many distance scales at once. Christian Bauer explains in 2025 how theory already splits those scales apart. Short-distance effects can be computed with standard tools. Long-distance effects resist those tools and are usually borrowed from one measurement to predict another. That borrowing works only when the long-distance part stays the same across measurements.
Bauer argues that quantum computers will change the picture. Once they can compute the stubborn long-distance pieces from first principles, physicists could predict measurements whose long-distance parts are not shared. That would widen the hunt for new physics, since more collider results could be compared cleanly against the standard theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christian W. Bauer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16602
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Efficient use of quantum computers for collider physics Christian W. Bauer Abstract Most observables at particle colliders involve physics at a wide variety of distance scales. Due to asymptotic freedom of the strong interaction, the physics at short distances can be calculated reliably using perturbative techniques, while long distance physics is non-perturbative in nature. Factorization theorems separate the contributions from different scales scales, allowing to identify the pieces that can be determined perturbatively from those that require non-perturbative information, and if the non-perturbative pieces can be reliably determined, one can use experimental measurements to extract the short distance effects, sensitive to possible new physics. Without the ability to compute the non-perturbative ingredients from first principles one typically identifies observables for which the non-perturbative information is universal in the sense that it can be extracted from some experimental observables and then used to predict other observables. In this paper we argue that the future ability to use quantum computers to calculate non-perturbative matrix elements from first principles will allow to make predictions for observables with non-universal non-perturbative long-distance physics. High energy physics (HEP) is concerned with testing physics at short distances and and therefore high energies. A commonly used experimental tool to test the most fundamental constituents of nature and the forces among them is to collide particles at high energies, allowing insights into the short distance interactions. Describing high-energy particle collisions requires understanding the effects originating from a wide variety of energy scales. For most observables, collisions at the LHC require to understand interactions ranging from the largest scale in the problem, namely the energy of the colliding protons E=7\,{\rm TeV} all the way to the lowest hadronic scales of order the mass mass of the pion E\sim 100\,{\rm MeV} or even lower. Asymptotic freedom implies that the strong coupling is small at large scales and large at small scales, with the transition point being the scale \Lambda_{\rm QCD}\sim{\cal O}(100) MeV. The short distance physics HEP is interested in testing can therefore be calculated reliably using perturbation theory. However, as mentioned, predictions of any relevant observable depend not only on the short distance, but also on long distance physics, and in particular those at or below \Lambda_{\rm QCD} require a non-perturbative treatment. Being able to predict these long distance effects is therefore of parmount importance to test short distance interactions and possibly discover deviations from the Standard Model. The most common way to make predictions for collider observables is to use parton shower algorithms [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , which combine a perturbative treatment of short distance physics with a probabilistic parton shower algorithm describing emissions at smaller, but still perturbative energies and a model [ 4 , 5 ] describing the long distance hadronization process. While the original parton shower algorithms included only perturbative information at the lowest order, there has been tremendous progress to combine higher perturbative fixed-order and resummed calculations with parton showers, and even combining high-order resummed calculations. The non-perturbative model contains a number of free parameters which are tuned to reproduce a wide set of experimental data. A more systematic approach go get control over long distance physics that works for many observables is the use of factorization theorems, which separate the short- and long-distance physics systematically. The derivation of factorization theorems has a long history [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] , and a modern way of deriving factorization theorems [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] is using effective field theories, in particular Soft-Collinear Effective Theory (SCET) [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] for the case of collider observables. The important aspect of factorization theorems is that it allows to characterize long-distance physics by matrix element of well-defined operators defined in SCET, and typically the number of such matrix elements is manageable for typical observables of interest. Observables are therefore predicted in terms of long distance matrix elements, combined with the short distance physics one is after. If these long distance matrix elements can be reliably determined, it allows to use the experimental data to extract the short distance physics one is after. Traditionally, factorization theorems have proven most useful when the non-perturbative ingredients are universal, in the sense that the same non-perturbative matrix element contributes to more than one experimentally accessible process. Besides hadron masses, the most well known universal non-perturbative objects are parton distribution functions, which describe non-perturbative effects from collinear radiation. Since parton distribution functions contribute to almost all observables at hadron colliders, they are extracted from a measurement of a range of observables and then used as inputs for other measurements of interest. A second example are so-called shape functions, which describe non-perturbative effects from soft radiation. For example, in the decays of B mesons to light particles, a single shape function describes both the shape of the photon spectrum in inclusive B\to X_{s}\gamma decays, as well as at the endpoint of the lepton spectrum in B\to X_{u}\ell\nu decays [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . However, many other observables of interest depend on non-perturbative information that is specific to the given observable. As an example, consider one of the simplest observables in collider physics, namely event shape distributions at lepton colliders [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] . Such event shape distributions are typically obtained by measuring the momenta of all final state particles in an e^{+}e^{-} collision, and then computing a certain function of these momenta. The most common event shape is thrust [ 23 , 24 ] , obtained by summing the inner product of all momenta p_{i} with a fixed axis \hat{t} , dividing by the sum of the absolute values of these inner products. One then finds the axis that maximizes the expression (resulting in the thrust axis) and this maximized result is value of the thrust event shape. This can be written as \displaystyle T={\rm max}_{\hat{t}}\frac{\sum_{i}\hat{t}\cdot p_{i}}{\sum_{i}|\hat{t}\cdot p_{i}|}\,. (1) Another commonly used event shape is the C parameter, defined as [ 28 ] \displaystyle C=\frac{3}{2}\frac{\sum_{ij}|p_{i}||p_{j}|\sin^{2}\theta_{ij}}{(\sum_{i}|p_{i}|)^{2}}\,, (2) where \theta_{ij} is the angle between the momenta p_{i} and p_{j} . Both of these event shapes approach 1 in the limit where all final state particles are contained in two back-to-back jets. In this limit one can derive the factorization theorem \displaystyle\frac{{\rm d}\sigma}{{\rm d}e}=\int\!{\rm d}k\,\frac{{\rm d}\sigma_{\rm pert}}{{\rm d}e}\left(e-\frac{k}{Q}\right)F(k)+{\cal O}\left(\frac{k}{Q}\right)\,, (3) where e\equiv 1-T or e\equiv 1-C , depending on which event shape is being studied. This factorization states that the differential thrust distribution is obtained through a convolution of a perturbatively calculable cross section {\rm d}\sigma_{\rm pert}/{\rm d}e , which describes the short distance physics above the soft scale \displaystyle\Lambda_{s}\sim Q\,e\,, (4) and a non-perturbative object called a soft- or shape-function F(k) describing the physics below that scale. As discussed before, in order for the event shape observables to be able to test the short-distance physics in {\rm d}\sigma_{\rm pert}/{\rm d}e requires knowledge of the soft function F(k) . One way to obtain information about the non-perturbative information F(k) is to measure it experimentally. This is possible if the same function F(k) contributes to more than one observable. Such a universal soft function