Open String Axiverse
Rudin Petrossian-Byrne, and Giovanni Villadoro · 2025
Read Open String Axiverse by Rudin Petrossian-Byrne, and Giovanni Villadoro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16387.txt.
Introduction
Rudin Petrossian-Byrne and Giovanni Villadoro describe an open string axiverse arising in string compactifications. Charged fields that stay in one place are a general feature of such builds. A charged field is tied to a fixed spot in these builds, not spread through all of it. In four dimensions they can produce many perturbatively exact global symmetries. When those symmetries break on their own, they make a new axiverse. This picture fits the growth of the cosmos after inflation, and is of note for axion physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rudin Petrossian-Byrne, and Giovanni Villadoro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16387
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Open String Axiverse Rudin Petrossian-Byrne, and Giovanni Villadoro Abstract Localized charged fields are a general feature of many realistic string compactifications. In four dimensions they can lead to a multitude of perturbatively-exact global symmetries. If spontaneously broken, they generate a new axiverse compatible with post-inflationary evolutions. 1 Introduction The QCD axion Weinberg:1977ma ; Wilczek:1977pj is a hypothetical pseudo Nambu-Goldstone boson (NGB) associated to the spontaneous breaking of the ‘Peccei-Quinn’ (PQ) U(1) symmetry Peccei:1977hh ; Peccei:1977ur , anomalous with respect to QCD. It provides arguably the most elegant solution to the Strong CP problem Jackiw:1976pf . Its mass and couplings to the Standard Model (SM) are largely determined by a single parameter, e.g. the axion decay constant f_{a} , whose current allowed range gives a clear (though challenging) target for detection (see e.g. refs. ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk ; Adams:2022pbo ). Expected to contribute to the current energy density of the Universe it could also account naturally for the whole dark matter abundance observed today Preskill:1982cy ; Abbott:1982af ; Dine:1982ah . The relation between its abundance and its mass strongly depends on the cosmological history of the axion field, in particular whether after inflation the PQ phase was ever restored. In this latter case, a.k.a. ‘post-inflationary’ scenario, the axion decay constant could be predicted. The calculation is challenging, with the most recent estimates clustering (within an order of magnitude) around f_{a}\sim 10^{10} GeV Gorghetto:2020qws ; Saikawa:2024bta ; Kim:2024wku ; Benabou:2024msj for the minimal UV model implementation. Present bounds on the neutron EDM Abel:2020pzs put severe constraints on the size of extra breakings to U(1)_{\rm PQ} beyond the one from the QCD anomaly Crewther:1979pi . Indeed, in order not to spoil the solution to the strong CP problem, extra breakings at the scale f_{a} should be smaller than \theta_{\rm QCD}m_{u}\Lambda_{\rm QCD}^{3}/f_{a}^{4}\sim 10^{-54} (for f_{a}\sim 10^{10} GeV). A natural question is how such a high-quality symmetry is compatible with the common lore that quantum gravity does not admit exact global symmetries (a concern sometimes dubbed as the PQ quality problem). Aside for the short answer “quantum gravity already breaks PQ via QCD”, a closer inspection to the arguments behind the lore betrays that the true irreducible breaking of global symmetries are non-perturbative in nature. Hence, weakly coupled UV completions of quantum gravity could allow for the presence of global symmetries with exponentially high quality at low energies. From this point of view, the PQ quality problem is more a constraint on the possible UV completions of quantum gravity, rather than an obstruction to low energy physics. Explicit examples can easily be found in perturbative string theory compactifications Svrcek:2006yi , which are calculable UV completions of quantum gravity. There, the zero modes of higher rank gauge fields generically lead to light axion-like particles in four dimensions. The associated axion shift symmetries (the analogue of our non-linearly realized PQ symmetry) are protected by the higher-dimensional gauge invariance, receiving masses only from exponentially suppressed contributions by heavy charged objects extending in the compact dimensions. Such constructions not only lead to viable QCD axion solutions, but can also easily accommodate the presence of multiple exponentially light axion-like particles (ALPs) besides: a string ‘axiverse’ Arvanitaki:2009fg . It is worth noting that the mechanism behind the axiverse can be fully understood within field theory, the only ingredients being gauge fields and extra dimensions. The simplest prototype is a U(1) gauge field A compactified on a circle S^{1} in an extra (5th) dimension Choi:2003wr . The Wilson loop \mathcal{W}_{S^{1}}=\exp{\bigl(ig\int_{S^{1}}\hskip-2.0ptA\bigr)} is identified with a massless axion field in 4D ( \exp{(ia/v)}\equiv\mathcal{W}_{S^{1}} ). The typical axion couplings to topological charge density operators ( G\tilde{G} ) in 4D naturally arise from 5D Chern-Simons terms \varepsilon^{MNRST}A_{M}G_{NR}G_{ST} . The shift symmetry of the axion 1 1 1 Descending from the 1-form symmetry A_{M}\rightarrow A_{M}+C_{M} in 5D. See Craig:2024dnl for a recent discussion. is broken in the presence of 5D fields with U(1) charge but, given the non-local nature of the axion in the extra dimension, the breaking is exponentially suppressed ( e^{-ML} ) if the mass M of the lightest charged field is larger than the inverse size L of the extra dimension. While in field theory this is only a plausible accident, in string theory constructions it is a generic feature. From the phenomenological point of view, a potential shortcoming of the string axiverse lies in the challenges to implement the more predictive post-inflationary scenario. The latter would require a mechanism to produce axion strings, which in the string axiverse would correspond to (possibly a bound state of) D and/or NS branes. The efficient production of such objects poses a theoretical, if not phenomenological, challenge, since an explicit computation would require entering non-perturbative string regimes in a cosmological setup (see, e.g., ref. March-Russell:2021zfq ; Benabou:2023npn ; Reece:2024wrn for recent discussions about the topic). In this work, we discuss a different way to realize light axions in higher-dimensional/string-theory compactifications. The mechanism just requires the presence of multiple charged fields localized in different positions of the compact manifold; the axion then emerges from extended gauge-invariant non-local operators in the extra dimension, as sketched in fig. 1 . Unlike the previous case, the axions are mostly associated to the open string sector of the theory, and therefore decoupled from the gravitational sector and the string scale. This mechanism is consistent with a full four dimensional restoration of the PQ phase, allowing the post-inflationary QCD axion to enjoy the same amount of PQ protection as its closed string cousins. In fact, we will show that this mechanism could also be generic in a large class of string compactifications, suggesting the presence of multiple light ALPs beyond the QCD axion, possibly also experiencing post-inflationary evolution — an open string axiverse . While sharing similar properties, the open string axiverse may present some phenomenologically new opportunities, given the calculability of the axion abundance, potential gravitational signals deriving from the topological defects produced from the PQ phase transition, as well as dark matter substructures such as mini-halos and Bose stars. As for the string axiverse, the mechanism behind the open string axiverse can be fully understood within field theory. It can naturally be extended to protect any U(1) global symmetry with exponentially high quality and it requires adding only a small extra dimension. An important point is that the high-quality global symmetry does not manifest itself in the effective 4D theory as an accidental symmetry, rather as a genuine global symmetry: symmetry breaking operators of low dimensionality are not forbidden, but their coefficient is exponentially suppressed. This reconciles the ancient QFT practice of imposing global symmetries by hand in low-energy effective field theories (EFTs) with the modern lore about the absence of exact global symmetries in a full theory of quantum gravity. It is worth mentioning that some of the ideas discussed in the present work have already been used in the past. In particular the importance of sequestering to generate approximate symmetries in extra dimensions was realized long ago in ref. Arkani-Hamed:1998lzu and applied in a specific model of QCD axion to protect the PQ symmetry in ref. Cheng:2001ys . A similar idea in string theory for generating high-quality global U(1) symmetries was introduced in ref. Ibanez:1999it and applied to generate open string