Electron-Impact Excitation of Zirconium i - iii in support of Neutron Star Merger Diagnostics
M. McCann, C. P. Ballance, F. McNeill, S. A. Sim, C. A. Ramsbottom · 2025
Read Electron-Impact Excitation of Zirconium i - iii in support of Neutron Star Merger Diagnostics by M. McCann, C. P. Ballance, F. McNeill, S. A. Sim, C. A. Ramsbottom (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16359.txt.
Introduction
McCann and co-authors wrote a paper in two thousand twenty-five computing atomic data for zirconium in support of neutron star merger studies. When two neutron stars collide, the blast, called a kilonova, glows with light from heavy elements. Reading that light needs accurate data on how atoms absorb and emit energy.
The team modeled the first three ion stages of zirconium, an element expected to be common in the debris. They built precise atomic structures, then computed how electrons striking the ions excite them across a wide range of temperatures. The resulting rates feed models that produce synthetic spectra. Those spectra can be compared with telescope observations to reveal what the merger debris contains.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. McCann, C. P. Ballance, F. McNeill, S. A. Sim, C. A. Ramsbottom |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16359
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Electron-Impact Excitation of Zirconium i - iii in support of Neutron Star Merger Diagnostics M. McCann, C. P. Ballance, F. McNeill, S. A. Sim, C. A. Ramsbottom Abstract Recent observation and analysis of kilonovae (KNe) spectra as a result of neutron star mergers require accurate and complete atomic structure and collisional data for interpretation. Ideally, the atomic datasets for elements predicted to be abundant in the ejecta should be experimentally calibrated. For near-neutral ion stages of Zirconium in particular, the A-values and the associated excitation/de-excitation rates are required from collision calculations built upon accurate structure models. The atomic orbitals required to perform the structure calculations may be calculated using a Multi-Configuration-Dirac-Fock (MCDF) approximation implemented within the General Relativistic Atomic Structure Package ( grasp0 ). Optimized sets of relativistic atomic orbitals are then imported into electron-impact excitation collision calculations. A relativistic R R -matrix formulation within the Dirac Atomic R-matrix Code ( darc ) is employed to compute collision strengths, which are subsequently Maxwellian convolved to produce excitation/de-excitation rates for a wide range of electron temperatures. These atomic datasets subsequently provide the foundations for non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) collisional-radiative models. In this work all these computations have been carried out for the first three ion stages of Zirconium (Zr i - iii ) with the data further interfaced with collisional-radiative and radiative transfer codes to produce synthetic spectra which can be compared with observation. 2023 Electron-Impact Excitation of Zirconium i - iii in support of Neutron Star Merger Diagnostics – References 1 Introduction Binary neutron star mergers (NSM) have been proposed as one possible origin of heavy elements with atomic number greater than iron. In the conditions of NSM these elements are expected to be formed through the process of rapid neutron capture (r-process) ( Kajino et al., 2019 ) , a process which occurs when the timescale for neutron capture is shorter than the timescale for \beta decay. In NSM the comparatively large neutron flux drives the neutron capture time down. The r-process produces a large amount of unstable nuclei which can subsequently decay to form elements that may account for observed abundances in the universe. There has been a significant increase in activity surrounding these topics since the detection of gravitational waves from a NSM event in 2017 and subsequent observations of the produced kilonova (KNe) AT2017gfo ( Pian et al., 2017 ; Smartt et al., 2017 ) . To determine if heavy species are produced in a NSM it is important to analyse the observed spectra for lines associated with high Z elements. However, disentangling these lines in the observed KNe spectra is a difficult endeavour. To accomplish this we require accurate synthetic spectra to compare against the KNe spectra so that we may distinguish the features, emerging from multiple ion stages, that belong to the elements of interest. This is further complicated as the KNe plasma rapidly enters a Non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (NLTE) regime at the temperatures and densities of interest, as discussed in Pognan et al. (2023) . To generate a synthetic spectra for a species in a NLTE environment, accurate and complete atomic data sets are necessary, data sets which include energy levels, transition rates and excitation/de-excitation rates for all transitions among the levels of interest. In Vieira et al. (2023) Zr is suggested as one of the elements contributing to the ejecta spectrum and in Gillanders et al. (2024) one of the proposed species of interest is Zr ii . This prediction was based on 1D radiative transfer simulations using the tardis modelling code ( Kerzendorf & Sim, 2014 ) . To aid in the continued analysis of NSM this work will introduce new atomic data for the first three ion stages Zr i , Zr ii and Zr iii into such radiative transfer simulations. Recent papers by Ljung et al. (2006) and Lawler et al. (2022) have reported experimental energy levels for Zr i and Zr ii and oscillator strengths for transitions among these levels for Zr ii . Additional calculations by Biémont et al. (1981) determined oscillator strengths for transitions in Zr i and Zr ii . These works are supplemented by data listed in the National Institute of Science and Technology Atomic Spectra Database (NIST ASD) ( Kramida et al., 2024 ) , where atomic energy level data for Zr i and Zr ii from Moore (1971) are reported. Experimental energy levels and oscillator strengths for Zr iii are found in the early work of Reader & Acquista (1997) . The experimental data from these publications will be used to benchmark the atomic data computed in this work. Our primary goal is comprehensive coverage of the first three ion stages of Zr that provides a reasonable representation of the atomic structure and electron-impact excitation rates to model plasmas at KNe densities and temperatures. It should be noted that there are no collisional excitation data currently available in the literature for any of the three Zr species under consideration. Additionally it is considered that excitation and dielectronic recombination may be the most relevant processes that effect the observed spectra, therefore generating the excitation data will be useful in understanding the KNe. The generation of the atomic data is split into two sections, first an atomic structure model is constructed and secondly this model is incorporated into a collision calculation to compute the electron-impact excitation cross sections and associated parameters. The atomic structure calculation generates energy levels, oscillator strengths and spontaneous transition probabilities, from a set of orthogonal electron orbitals. The general-purpose relativistic atomic structure program ( grasp0 ) ( Parpia et al., 1996 ) , which uses the Multi-Configurational Dirac Fock method, is employed in the generation of the electron orbitals. These electron orbitals are then used as the starting point in the second phase, an electron-impact excitation calculation, which generates Maxwellian averaged collision rates over a wide range of electron temperatures which can be used in LTE and NLTE plasma modelling. In this second phase the fully relativistic Dirac Atomic R-matrix Codes ( darc ) ( Ballance, 2024 ; Norrington & Grant, 1987 ) are used to compute the collision cross sections, these codes are well-suited to atomic species with high Z where relativistic effects are important. The underlying theory of electron-impact excitation R-matrix calculations is discussed in greater detail within Burke (2011) and will not be reproduced here. The remainder of the paper is structured as follows. In Sec. 2 the atomic structure models describing the Zr i , ii and iii targets are discussed. The computed energy levels and transition probabilities for transitions among these levels are compared with known experimental values and other theoretical predictions from the literature. In Sec. 3 results from the corresponding electron-impact excitation calculations are reported, and some examples of both the resulting collision strengths and Maxwellian averaged effective collision strengths for selected allowed and forbidden lines are shown. In Sec. 4 the new atomic data that have been generated are incorporated into the collisional radiative modelling code ColRadPy ( Johnson et al., 2019 ) , to produce synthetic spectra. Analysing these spectra allows us to test the accuracy of the data and probe LTE and NLTE assumptions via the level populations. In Sec.