Hamiltonian dynamics of classical spins

Slobodan Radošević, Sonja Gombar, Milica Rutonjski, Petar Mali, Milan Pantić, Milica Pavkov-Hrvojević · 2025

Read Hamiltonian dynamics of classical spins by Slobodan Radošević, Sonja Gombar, Milica Rutonjski, Petar Mali, Milan Pantić, Milica Pavkov-Hrvojević (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16308.txt.

Introduction

Slobodan Radošević and co-authors present a 2025 paper teaching the geometry behind the classical Heisenberg model of magnetism. The model treats each atom's spin as an arrow that neighbors try to align. Its equations are usually derived with differential geometry, which many physics students have not studied.

The authors rebuild the theory from plain algebra: vectors, dual vectors, and tensors, plus the simplest forms of Hamilton's equations and Poisson brackets. Starting from the geometry of a sphere, they derive the brackets for classical spins and the equations of motion that follow. The paper is pitched at third- or fourth-year students. It shows that the standard canonical procedure works cleanly for this classic model.

Catalog record

CREATORSlobodan Radošević, Sonja Gombar, Milica Rutonjski, Petar Mali, Milan Pantić, Milica Pavkov-Hrvojević
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16308

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hamiltonian dynamics of classical spins Slobodan Radošević, Sonja Gombar, Milica Rutonjski, Petar Mali, Milan Pantić, Milica Pavkov-Hrvojević Abstract We discuss the geometry behind classical Heisenberg model at the level suitable for third or fourth year students who did not have the opportunity to take a course on differential geometry. The arguments presented here rely solely on elementary algebraic concepts such as vectors, dual vectors and tensors, as well as Hamiltonian equations and Poisson brackets in their simplest form. We derive Poisson brackets for classical spins, along with the corresponding equations of motion for classical Heisenberg model, starting from the geometry of two-sphere, thereby demonstrating the relevance of standard canonical procedure in the case of Heisenberg model. I Introduction Before diving into the quantum world, students familiarize themselves with classical physics. This is certainly not because classical physics is more fundamental, but rather knowledge of classical physics can be helpful in understanding counterintuitive quantum phenomena. Indeed, the so-called process of quantization, both in Hamiltonian and Lagrangian formulations, relies on the corresponding classical physical system as a starting point in constructing quantum theory. Examples of this strategy are numerous: the harmonic oscillator is studied as a prime example in classical mechanics with the quantum version being of equal importance. Pauli’s solution to the quantum mechanical hydrogen atom is the direct analog of Kepler problem in classical mechanics [ 1 , 2 ] . Finally, the prerequisite for learning quantum electrodynamics is the knowledge of Maxwell’s classical theory [ 3 , 2 , 4 ] . An important exception to this rule of studying quantum system after the classical one is fully understood, is the (quantum) Heisenberg model which captures the physics of localized magnetism. In the simplest case of an isotropic ferromagnet with nearest-neighbor interaction, it is defined by the Hamiltonian operator \hat{H}=-\frac{J}{2}\sum_{\bm{n},\bm{\lambda}}\hat{\bm{S}}(\bm{n})\cdot\hat{\bm{S}}(\bm{n}+\bm{\lambda}) (1) where J>0 denotes the exchange integral, \bm{n} is the position vector of a site in the lattice, \{\bm{\lambda}\} is the set of vectors connecting each lattice site with its nearest neighbors, \hat{\bm{S}}(\bm{n}) is the spin operator corresponding to the lattice site \bm{n} and components of spin operators satisfy equal-time commutation relation (we are dropping temporal coordinate for clarity) \Big[\hat{S}_{\alpha}(\bm{n}),\hat{S}_{\beta}(\bm{m})\Big]=\mathrm{i}\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma}\Delta(\bm{n}-\bm{m})\hat{S}_{\gamma}(\bm{n}), (2) where \Delta(\bm{n}-\bm{m})=1 only for \bm{n}=\bm{m} and \Delta(\bm{n}-\bm{m})=0 in all other cases and \epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma} denotes the Levi-Civita symbol, which is completely antisymmetric tensor in three dimensions with \epsilon_{123}=1 . In essence, \{\hat{S}_{\alpha}(\bm{n})\} operators from different sites commute, while those on the same site satisfy standard \mathfrak{su}(2) commutation relations. The Hilbert space for this model consists of tensor products of spin states at all sites [ 5 ] . When introducing Heisenberg model in texts for undergraduate students, authors usually start from the exchange interaction and the Dirac Hamiltonian [ 6 , 7 ] , while graduate-level books discuss the Hubbard model and derive the Heisenberg Hamiltonian as an effective model which describes the physics of spin exchange and superexchange [ 5 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . This kind of presentation is, of course, completely reasonable from the point of view of atomic physics. After all, quantum-mechanical properties of electrons are key to our understanding of magnetism. However, it serves an injustice to the corresponding model of classical spins since spin waves (or magnons), as emergent degrees of freedom in a quantum model, are the quantized version of small collective oscillations of classical spins. Likewise, a direct confrontation with quantum many-body Hamiltonian ( 1 ) may leave students wondering what happened to the canonical prescription of replacing Poisson brackets with commutators, or how the spin operators suddenly became dynamical degrees of freedom. It turns out that all these issues arise because the underlying phase space for a single classical spin fails to be a Euclidean space – it is the two-sphere {\rm S}^{2} and a full understanding of the classical Heisenberg model requires certain knowledge of tensor analysis on {\rm S}^{2} . The problem is that most undergraduates do not take courses on differential geometry. Still, some elements of differential geometry are used in physics courses. For example, introductory texts on quantum field theory describe gauge field strength as curvature [ 3 , 11 ] , while modern introductory texts to general relativity cover many important geometric concepts [ 12 , 13 ] . It is unfortunate that the classical Heisenberg model does not get the same treatment, giving the fact that students usually possess needed tools acquired on linear algebra and vector calculus courses and that the symplectic form and associate Poisson tensor, which we shall be discussing here, are no more abstract than the curvature or parallel transport along a curve on a manifold. As far as standard textbook treatments are concerned, the classical Heisenberg model remains somewhat mysterious of an object and students are missing a nice opportunity of connecting classical and quantum Heisenberg models in a compelling way. The paper is not intended as an introduction to symplectic geometry, nor to the theories of classical and quantum Heisenberg models; standard references cover these topics in depth [ 14 , 15 , 5 ] . Instead, it points to frequently omitted geometry of classical Heisenberg spins and its connection and relevance to the quantum model. In the second section we review vectors, dual vectors and tensors, as well as tensor fields, while the symplectic form and the Poison tensor on \mathbb{R}^{2} are introduced in Section III . Generalization of these objects to the case when phase space is two-sphere is given in Section IV , which also contains an example of a simple system defined on the phase space {\rm S^{2}} . Finally, the application of these ideas to the case of classical Heisenberg model is given in Section V and an alternative definition of Poisson brackets in terms of the symplectic form is presented in Section VI . Some technical details and notation on symplectic manifolds are collected in Section VII , while the summary of our presentation is given in Section VIII . We set \hbar=1 throughout the paper. II Vectors, dual vectors and tensors We shall start by recapitulating some basic facts from the theory of vector spaces just to set up notation. Standard references are [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . We consider only real vector spaces here. II.1 Vectors and dual vectors Let V be a vector space of dimension N . Each element X\in V can be uniquely represented as X=X^{i}e_{i} , where \{e_{i}\} is the set of basis vectors and X^{i} are components of X with respect to this basis. Here, and throughout the paper, we employ the Einstein summation convention so that in all expressions which contain the same letter as a lower and as an upper index, the summation is carried over all the values of index: 1,2,3,...,N . Real N dimensional vector space is isomorphic to \mathbb{R}^{N} , the space of N- tuplets of real numbers. By convention, we write these elements as columns. For example, when N=2 , to each vector X=X^{1}e_{1}+X^{2}e_{2} we ascribe the column \begin{bmatrix}X^{1}\\ X^{2}\\ \end{bmatrix}, (3) which we denote by the same symbol, X . Dual vectors are linear maps from V to real numbers and, as it turns out, they form a vector space

Read the complete text