Surface quasigeostrophic turbulence: The refined study of an active scalar

Nicolas Valade \aff 1 \corresp, Jérémie Bec \aff 1,2 \corresp, and Simon Thalabard \aff 2 \corresp · 2025

Read Surface quasigeostrophic turbulence: The refined study of an active scalar by Nicolas Valade \aff 1 \corresp, Jérémie Bec \aff 1,2 \corresp, and Simon Thalabard \aff 2 \corresp (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16294.txt.

Introduction

Nicolas Valade, Jérémie Bec, and Simon Thalabard refine the picture of a special kind of turbulence in this 2025 paper. Their model, called surface quasigeostrophic flow, moves a surface measure such as temperature, and the moving field and the flow share the same units. That likeness once suggested the flow should mimic three-dimensional turbulence, with clean scaling laws.

Running vast simulations, the team found a split story. Mixed measures, linking flow jumps with powers of the surface measure's changes, scale cleanly and reveal odd flows of every moment. Single-field measures, though, follow no clean power law at any scale. The authors argue the two fields are so tightly bound that splitting them breaks the usual scaling, and they use broader forms of self-similarity to recover the pattern.

Catalog record

CREATORNicolas Valade \aff 1 \corresp, Jérémie Bec \aff 1,2 \corresp, and Simon Thalabard \aff 2 \corresp
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16294

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Surface quasigeostrophic turbulence: The refined study of an active scalar Nicolas Valade \aff 1 \corresp, Jérémie Bec \aff 1,2 \corresp, and Simon Thalabard \aff 2 \corresp Abstract SQG describes the two-dimensional active transport of a scalar field, such as temperature, which—when properly rescaled—shares the same physical dimension of length/time as the advecting velocity field. This duality has motivated analogies with fully developed three-dimensional turbulence. In particular, the Kraichnan-Leith-Batchelor similarity theory predicts a Kolmogorov-type inertial range scaling ∝ ( ε ​ ℓ ) 1 / 3 \propto(\varepsilon\ell)^{1/3} for both scalar and velocity fields, and the presence of intermittency through multifractal scaling was pointed out by Sukhatme & Pierrehumbert ( Chaos 12 , 439, 2002) in unforced settings. In this work, we refine the discussion of these statistical analogies, using numerical simulations with up to 16,384 2 16,384^{2} collocation points in a steady-state regime dominated by the direct cascade of scalar variance. We show that mixed structure functions, coupling velocity increments with scalar differences, develop well-defined scaling ranges, highlighting the role of anomalous fluxes of all the scalar moments. However, the clean multiscaling properties of SQG transport are blurred when considering velocity and scalar fields separately. In particular, the usual (unmixed) structure functions do no follow any power-law scaling in any range of scales, neither for the velocity nor for the scalar increments. This specific form of the intermittency phenomenon reflects the specific kinematic properties of SQG turbulence, involving the interplay between long-range interactions, structures and geometry. Revealing the multiscaling in single-field statistics requires to resort to generalised notions of scale invariance, such as extended self-similarity and specific form of refined self-similarity. Our findings emphasise the fundamental entanglement of scalar and velocity fields in SQG turbulence: They evolve hand in hand and any attempt to isolate them destroys scaling in its usual sense. This perspective sheds new lights on the discrepancies in spectra and structure functions, that have been repeatedly observed in SQG numerics for the past 20 years. keywords Turbulence, Surface Quasi-Geostrophy, Direct Numerical Simulations, Intermittency 1 Introduction The surface quasi-geostrophic (SQG) theory describes the dynamics of rapidly rotating and stably stratified flows near flat horizontal boundaries through the two-dimensional (2D) transport equation \begin{split}&\partial_{t}\theta+\left({\boldsymbol{u}}\bcdot\bnabla\right)\theta=\nu\Delta\theta+F,\quad{\boldsymbol{u}}:=-\boldsymbol{\nabla}^{\perp}\psi,\quad\psi:=(-\rmDelta)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\theta,\end{split} (1) where \theta({\boldsymbol{x}},t) represents a scalar field (such as surface temperature or buoyancy) advected in a planar domain \rmOmega\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} under the influence of forcing F(\theta,{\boldsymbol{x}},t) and viscous damping. Here, \bnabla^{\perp}=(-\partial_{2},\partial_{1})^{\top} denotes the perpendicular gradient operator. Initially proposed by Blumen (1978) , the SQG model has emerged as a minimal yet insightful framework for studying the dynamics of upper-oceanic and lower-tropospheric flows. It is particularly relevant to the problems involving potential vorticity inversion and frontogenesis (see, for example, Juckes, 1995 ; Held et al., 1995 ; Lapeyre & Klein, 2006 , and the comprehensive review by Lapeyre 2017 ) . At a more fundamental level, the SQG system ( 1 ) has also gathered significant interest in physical and mathematical turbulence research due to its phenomenological and structural analogies to various prototypical fluid systems. These include the 2D Navier–Stokes equations ( Held et al., 1995 ; Bernard et al., 2007 ) , passive scalar turbulence ( Celani et al., 2004 ; Llewellyn & Taylor, 2016 ) , Burgers turbulence ( Valade et al., 2024 ) , and the 3D Navier-Stokes equations ( Constantin et al., 1994 ; Sukhatme & Pierrehumbert, 2002 ) . Equation ( 1 ) describes the transport of an active scalar , where the velocity field {\boldsymbol{u}} depends nonlocally on the advected scalar \theta , analogous to the velocity–vorticity relationship in the 2D Euler equations. In SQG, though, long-range interactions are mediated by the Green function (-\Delta)^{-1/2} associated to the half-Laplacian rather than to the Laplacian. In the full plane, this yields \psi({\boldsymbol{x}})=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{2}}\frac{\theta({\boldsymbol{x}}^{\prime})}{|{\boldsymbol{x}}-{\boldsymbol{x}}^{\prime}|}\,\mathrm{d}^{2}{\boldsymbol{x}}^{\prime}\quad\text{ and }\quad{\boldsymbol{u}}({\boldsymbol{x}})=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{2}}\frac{({\boldsymbol{x}}-{\boldsymbol{x}}^{\prime})^{\perp}}{|{\boldsymbol{x}}-{\boldsymbol{x}}^{\prime}|^{3}}\theta({\boldsymbol{x}}^{\prime})\,\mathrm{d}^{2}{\boldsymbol{x}}^{\prime}, (2) where {\boldsymbol{x}}^{\perp}=(-x_{2},x_{1}) . These relations imply, somewhat surprisingly, that \theta and {\boldsymbol{u}} share the same physical dimension. This makes \theta comparable to both a coarse-grained vorticity and a scalar analog of the velocity field (see Fig. 1 ). In the absence of forcing and dissipation, smooth solutions of the SQG equation conserve two quadratic invariants: the Hamiltonian \mathcal{H}={\frac{1}{2}\int_{\Omega}\psi\,\theta} akin to the energy in 2D Euler flows, and the scalar variance, which also corresponds to the kinetic energy, \mathcal{E}=\frac{1}{2}\int_{\Omega}\theta^{2}=\frac{1}{2}\int_{\Omega}|{\boldsymbol{u}}|^{2} akin to the enstrophy. In the presence of forcing and dissipation, these invariants lead to a dual cascade scenario, featuring an inverse cascade of the Hamiltonian and a direct cascade of scalar variance ( Burgess et al., 2015 ; Smith et al., 2002 ) . The direct transfer of scalar variance—and equivalently of kinetic energy—is known to differ fundamentally from the enstrophy cascade in 2D turbulence, as it sustains more energetic small scales. In short, SQG turbulence is rough. Similar to 3D turbulence, dimensional arguments tie the direct SQG cascade to a Kolmogorov energy spectrum \propto k^{-5/3} . However, previous numerical studies have reported both steeper spectral slopes ( Sukhatme & Pierrehumbert, 2002 ; Celani et al., 2004 ; Capet et al., 2008 ) and shallower ones ( Watanabe & Iwayama, 2007 ) . These observations point toward the presence of significant corrections due to intermittency ( Kolmogorov, 1962 ; Frisch, 1995 ; Benzi & Toschi, 2023 ) . One could also question the extent to which SQG scaling laws (if any) are universal. In particular, the recent work of Valadão et al. (2024) provided evidence that large-scale fluctuations can obscure a k^{-5/3} scaling, with steeper subleading terms appearing in the spectrum. Figure 1: SQG snapshots of squared vorticity \omega=\bnabla^{\perp}\bcdot{\boldsymbol{u}} , temperature \theta and velocity {\boldsymbol{u}} at a typical time. The zoomed-in regions display (1/32)^{2} of the computational domain. Taken from Run VI (see Tab. 1 ). In this work, we aim to examine in greater detail the Kolmogorovian features of steady-state SQG turbulence through a series of highly resolved direct numerical simulations, employing up to 16,384^{2} collocation points. These simulations incorporate small-scale dissipation and a statistically homogeneous large-scale forcing scheme to sustain turbulence. Classical 3D turbulence theory relies on the phenomenological assumptions that the steady-state velocity fields have finite variance and that the kinetic energy dissipation rate remains nonzero in the limit of vanishing viscosity—a property referred to as anomalous dissipation. For SQG turbulence, these conditions translate into the requirements: \lim_{\nu\to 0}\left\langle{\theta^{2}}\right\rangle<\infty\quad\text{and }\quad\lim_{\nu\to 0}\left\langle{\nu|\bnabla\theta|^{2}}\right\rangle>0, (3) where \left\langle{\cdot}\right\rangle denotes a suitable space-time averaging. We propose a numerical setup designed to check whether these conditions are satisfied. We point out that their realisation in SQG turbulence is not straightforward: The presence of Hamiltonian inverse transfers requires large-scale damping to establish a statistically steady state. Since interactions between scales in SQG might be nonlocal ( Watanabe & Iwayama, 2007 ; Foussard et al., 2017 , see, e.g.) , this damping could influence the statistics of the direct cascade. Our numerical simulations enable a refined analysis of the multiscaling properties of SQG. In 3D turbulence, multiscaling is well captured by Kolmogorov 1962 refined similarity hypothesis, which links the non-Gaussianity of velocity increments to fluctuations in the dissipation field ( Chevillard et al., 2019 ; Dubrulle, 2019 ) . While evidence of intermittency in SQG turbulence has been reported in unforced settings ( Sukhatme & Pierrehumbert, 2002 ; Valade et al., 2024 ) , its phenomenology remains poorly understood. Qualitatively, coherent structures play a pivotal

Read the complete text