Towards a definition of a meteor cluster

A. Ashimbekova, J. Vaubaillon, P. Koten · 2025

Read Towards a definition of a meteor cluster by A. Ashimbekova, J. Vaubaillon, P. Koten (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16157.txt.

Introduction

Ashimbekova, Vaubaillon, and Koten hunt this 2025 gap in meteor science: nobody has officially defined a meteor cluster. Observers take it as many meteors from the same point at near the same speed within seconds, and only eight cases were on record. The team searched international meteor orbit databases with a clustering algorithm for more.

Sixteen statistically strong candidate clusters surfaced, holding four to seven fragments each. Their shared profile: durations up to about eight seconds, speed spreads near two kilometers per second, and radiant spreads near four degrees. The authors suspect clusters are commoner than the record shows. They also urge databases to log each camera's surveyed sky area, without which cluster statistics stay shaky.

Catalog record

CREATORA. Ashimbekova, J. Vaubaillon, P. Koten
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16157

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Towards a definition of a meteor cluster A. Ashimbekova, J. Vaubaillon, P. Koten Abstract Context. As of today, there is no official definition of a meteor cluster. It is usually identified as a large number of meteors sharing a similar radiant and velocity, all occurring within a few seconds. Only eight clusters have been reported so far, from single-camera or camera network observations. However, a cluster may be observed by several distant networks and remain unnoticed simply because each network is recording a small portion of the cluster. Aims. We aim to provide an overview of meteor clusters to help define what constitutes a cluster by potentially adding more to the already identified ones and determining their common parameters. Methods. A search for new clusters is performed in publicly available International Astronomical Union (IAU) meteor databases with the DBSCAN algorithm. Then, a statistical significance method is applied to derive the most promising cluster candidates. However, the method still lacks a way to debias the atmospheric area surveyed by the cameras due to a lack of publicly available data. Results. A set of 16 statistically significant potential clusters is identified, involving 4 to 7 fragments. The 90th percentile includes a duration of 8 seconds, a velocity difference of 2.2 km/s, and a radiant spread of nearly 4 degrees. The velocity difference may arise from the method used for orbit computation. Conclusions. Meteor clusters might be more frequent than currently reported. However, we recommend that future meteor orbit databases also include a way to estimate the surveyed area by the cameras involved in the detection. This would strengthen the veracity of the 16 identified cluster candidates and ultimately allow scientists to fully debias the number of clusters, and hence derive the physical lifetime expectancy of meteoroids, which is often overlooked due to the focus on collisional lifetime estimates only. We also recommend that any future cluster observation report include the expected number of random occurrences and consider the event to be real if this value is below 0.1. Detection of meteor clusters from meteor orbit databases 1 Introduction Meteor showers are characterized by a relatively high number of meteors sharing a similar radiant and occurring over a time span ranging from a few hours to a few weeks ( Koten et al., 2019 ; Williams et al., 2019 ) . During such showers, meteor clusters are rarely seen. A meteor cluster is characterized by a relatively high number of meteors sharing similar radiant and velocity, occurring within a time interval of a few seconds. Until today, only 8 clusters were reported ( Hapgood & Rothwell, 1981 ; Piers & Hawkes, 1993 ; Kinoshita et al., 1999 ; Watanabe et al., 2002 ; Watanabe et al., 2003 ; Koten et al., 2017 ; Vaubaillon et al., 2023 ; Koten et al., 2024 ) . However, the recognition of clusters is impaired by the lack of an official definition, caused by the scarce frequency of the phenomenon. Another cause of the absence of further detection of meteor clusters is the meteor detection software, not explicitly designed for this purpose ( Bednář et al., 2023 ) . Yet, the existence of meteor clusters is an indicator of meteoroid fragmentation in interplanetary space. The most likely physical origin is the thermal stress endured by the meteoroid ( Čapek et al., 2022 ) . Determining the frequency of such self-fragmentation directly impacts estimates of meteoroid physical lifetimes in interplanetary space. In particular, if the frequency is found to be higher than already suspected, this could explain, e.g., the absence of the 2006 Leonids outburst ( Jenniskens et al., 2008 ) . This physical lifetime expectancy is often overlooked, in favor of collisional lifetime expectancy ( Koschny et al., 2017 ; Soja et al., 2019 ) . Thus, determining the frequency of meteoroid self-fragmentation by the detection of meteor clusters has implications for the interpretation of meteor shower observations in general. The scientific question this paper seeks to address is whether there are more meteor clusters hidden in the meteor orbit databases than are currently known. Recent search for additional meteor pairs among the Geminids recorded by the Ondřejov observatory video meteor database ( Koten et al., 2021 ) was performed by Ďurišová et al. (2023) . The results show that no cluster was detected, given the data and the statistical significance of the pair candidates. This statistical analysis is crucial, since, as pointed out by the authors, a simple Poisson distribution underestimates the expected number of clusters in a given database of meteor orbits. However, all currently known clusters and search for clusters focus on detection with a limited number of cameras (often restricted to just one). The interpretation ( Čapek et al., 2022 ) is that a meteoroid self-fragments in space, and the subsequent non-gravitational forces (highly dependent on the size) cause a slow increase of the physical distance between the different fragments. The measured maximal physical distance between the fragments constrain the maximum time duration between the self-fragmentation of the observation in the Earth’s atmosphere. It is found that, for the analyzed clusters, the maximal physical distance was estimated at a few hundred km, and the corresponding duration since self-fragmentation does not exceed a few days at most ( Koten et al., 2017 ; Koten et al., 2024 ) . However, the studied clusters were detected either by a single camera or by a network of cameras, surveying a rather small portion of the atmosphere. Now let us suppose a simple scenario of a meteoroid self-fragmentation into two pieces (i.e., the most basic cluster possible). Suppose the self-fragmentation happens a few months before the fragments enter the Earth’s atmosphere and the physical distance is 3000 km at the time of the observation. Such a distance would make it impossible for this cluster to be detected by a two-camera-network (since cameras of a given network are usually separated by \sim 100\;km ). Even a network of 100 cameras covering 10^{6}\ km^{2} cannot detect such a cluster. However, the two meteors can be detected by two meteor observation networks a few thousand km apart. In this case, the two meteors associated with the atmospheric entry of the two fragments will be detected, but the link between these two meteors cannot be performed, unless the data are available. The goal of this paper is to dig into the current publicly available databases, find potential meteor clusters, and perform a statistical analysis to evaluate their respective relevance. Since there is no current definition of a meteor cluster, it may be tempting to define constraints to help identify future clusters. However, such a procedure might unintentionally set too strong limits, preventing future works to provide scientifically sound results. Instead, we aim to provide preliminary statistics of the cluster candidates. It is worth mentioning that the consequences regarding the physical lifetime expectancy are out of the scope of this preliminary study, since this is the topic of thorough research. The paper first describes the method in section 2 (including the description of the databases and the algorithm). Then, the cluster candidates are characterized in section 3 and a general discussion on future considerations regarding the definition of a meteor cluster is

Read the complete text