The Malleable Glyph (Challenge)

Adam Herout, Vojtěch Bartl, Martin Gaens, Oskar Tvrďoch · 2025

Read The Malleable Glyph (Challenge) by Adam Herout, Vojtěch Bartl, Martin Gaens, Oskar Tvrďoch (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-16135.txt.

Introduction

Adam Herout, Vojtech Bartl, Martin Gaens, and Oskar Tvrd'och pose a new visualization puzzle called the Malleable Glyph, in a 2025 challenge paper. The idea grew from user research on card sorting. The task is to pack as much information as possible into a fixed, flat, still shape.

A viewer comparing two glyphs must judge which shows more, or whether they are equal. The design must follow an illiteracy rule: viewers ask how much, not how many, so counting tricks are banned. Uses could span interfaces, games, and maps. The authors explain the rules and scoring protocol and invite the graphics community to enter the public challenge.

Catalog record

CREATORAdam Herout, Vojtěch Bartl, Martin Gaens, Oskar Tvrďoch
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-16135

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Malleable Glyph (Challenge) Adam Herout, Vojtěch Bartl, Martin Gaens, Oskar Tvrďoch Abstract Malleable Glyph is a new visualization problem and a public challenge. It originated from UX research (namely from research on card sorting UX), but its applications can be diverse (UI, gaming, information presentation, maps, and others). Its essence is: carrying as much information in a defined planar and static area as possible. The information should allow human observers to evaluate a pair of glyphs into three possible sortings: the first is “greater”, or the second is “greater”, or both are equal. The glyphs should adhere to the illiteracy rule , in other words, the observer should ask themselves the question “how much?” rather than “how many?”. This article motivates the technique, explains its details, and presents the public challenge, including the evaluation protocol. The article aims to call for ideas from other visualization and graphics researchers and practitioners and to invite everyone to participate in the challenge and, by doing so, move scientific knowledge forward. I Introduction — What is Malleable Glyph? Fig. 1: Illustration of the Q-methodology: subject sorts a deck of cards with subjective utterances into a predefined area typically shaped according to normal distribution. (illustration credit: Adriana Buchmei) The origin of this research lies in the development of a modern user interface for the Q-methodology [ 1 , 2 ] , which is a standard method for studying subjective opinions. Q-sorting was used long before the advent of computers and graphical interfaces, as shown in Figure 1 . The essence of Q-sorting is to sort a deck of cards (tens to somewhat over a hundred) on a given scale, for example, from “does not describe me at all” to “describes me exactly” , or from “completely disagree” to “fully agree” . The cards contain phrases or short utterances to which the research participant is asked to take a position and rate the cards accordingly. The responses of the participants are then analyzed using factor analysis. In developing a modern user interface and seeking an optimal user experience, it was appropriate to remove the subjectivity that Q-sorting usually explores – that is, to remove subjective statements from the sorted cards and replace them with objective content. This leaves only “the second subjectivity” – the usability of the user interface. A good candidate for a deck of cards without subjectivity seemed to be cards with numerals written in text. Working with these cards in sorting is at most similar to working with normal cards with subjective statements. The participant reads the short text on the cards and is able to make a comparison between two cards as well as determine which card will be ranked “very low”, which “very high” and which somewhere in the middle. The trap, as our testing showed, turns out to be that human beings rank the numbers the way they learned to in elementary school. First by the digit in the highest order, and then, within a group of cards with the same highest order value, by the next digit, and so on. The way of working with cards that contain digits turned out to be completely different from working with cards that contain values (statements) that have no orders or digits. The limitations of cards with numbers written in words led us to use a scaled geometric shape in the center of the card, as shown in Figure 2 . This solved the problem of numbers and ordering by discrete orders. However, it turned out that there are not many sizes that the human eye can distinguish on a card of about 2\times 1\,\mathrm{inch} , and when testing with larger numbers of cards (dozens to hundreds), there are no longer enough sufficiently distinguishable sizes of shapes on the cards. Fig. 2: Card decks for UX testing of the card sorting user interfaces: left: cards with textual cardinals, right: cards with a scaled symbol. We conducted preliminary testing that, while not meeting the standards to be taken seriously statistically, showed that different geometric shapes allow human subjects to recognize their size to varying degrees. The most basic shapes tested are shown in Figure 3 . Unsurprisingly, two-dimensional shapes offer more clues for size comparisons than a mere line segment. A circle offers better resolution capability than a square, proposing the hypothesis that a curved shape offers the eye more to lean on than a line segment. A star is comparable in resolution to a circle – it is only composed of lines, but it contains more of them and contains different angles. Of the simple test shapes shown in the figure, the scaled letter B seemed to behave best, as it was chosen to contain both segments and curves with different curvatures. Fig. 3: Preliminary testing showed that different scaled shapes (line, square, circle, star, character shape) have varying degrees to which a human subject recognizes their sizes. This experimentation led to the basic question of malleable glyphs : How best to graphically use a given area so that, at first glance, a human subject can compare two glyphs with each other or, for one or more glyphs, determine where approximately they lie on a scale from smallest possible to largest? For simplicity, we set the area to be a square of 1\times 1\,\mathrm{inch} , though other sizes may and will be studied. Malleable glyphs are inherently scalar because they are intended to allow unambiguous pair ordering and placement on a one-dimensional scale. We introduce the convention that a malleable glyph is controlled by a real number parameter x\in[0.0,100.0] (numbers between 0 and 1 would work just as well but tend to be less intuitive for humans). Fig. 4: Malleable Glyphs do not have to be limited to using simple geometric shapes and scaling them. They can use any visual elements: raster graphics, fractal geometry, colors and color scales, textures, clouds of simple discrete elements, as well as anything else. (image credit: snowflake , mandelbrot ) We originally wanted to call the glyphs we studied scalable glyphs, but that would imply that they should only be created by scaling vector geometric shapes (as they even originally were). However, such a suggestion would be misleading: glyphs can use any graphical and visual elements, provided they fit within the specified dimension and conform to other rules (in particular, the Illiteracy Rule described in Section III ). The originally intended use of glyphs is for printing on physical cards, so we do not allow the use of animations and temporally dynamic graphical elements. However, studying exactly such animated videoglyphs , as a modification or special category of malleable glyphs also makes sense. Of the static graphic and visualization elements, anything can be used; see Figure 4 . Of course, it is possible to use color – both to achieve aesthetic quality and as a means of expression of the glyph’s magnitude, perhaps through color gradients. The use of fractal geometry can be very promising, making it possible to vary the complexity , not just size, of geometric shapes, either continuously or in a high number of discrete steps. Malleable glyphs can also use a variety of textures and clouds or clusters of points or

Read the complete text