The transition to phenomenological behaviour of static solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system for an increasing number of fermions
Håkan Andréasson · 2025
Read The transition to phenomenological behaviour of static solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system for an increasing number of fermions by Håkan Andréasson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15995.txt.
Introduction
Håkan Andréasson and Joakim Blomqvist compare two models of matter held together by its own gravity, as the particle count grows. Their 2025 paper studies the Einstein-Dirac system, a semiclassical model where fermions obey quantum rules inside curved spacetime. Solutions for a handful of fermions were built in the last century and later extended to as many as ninety; this work pushes to one hundred eighty.
The comparison target is the fully classical Einstein-Vlasov system. Even at modest particle counts, the two families of solutions look strikingly alike, with the same multi-peak shapes in highly relativistic cases. Both share the same ceiling on compactness and obey the same known bound. One quantum signature fades with size: regions of negative radial pressure appear for few fermions and vanish as the count rises. The authors read this as a transition from quantum to classical behavior.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Håkan Andréasson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15995
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The transition to phenomenological behaviour of static solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system for an increasing number of fermions Håkan Andréasson Abstract Static spherically symmetric solutions to the Einstein-Dirac system were constructed numerically for the first time in 1999 by Finster, Smoller and Yau [ 18 ] in the case of two fermions. In 2020 this result was generalized by Leith, Hooley, Horne and Dritschel [ 25 ] to a system consisting of an even number κ \kappa of fermions. They constructed solutions for 2 ≤ κ ≤ 90 2\leq\kappa\leq 90 . The purpose of the present investigation is to compare the properties of static solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system with static solutions of the Einstein,-Vlasov system as the number of fermions increases, that is, for 2 ≤ κ ≤ 180 2\leq\kappa\leq 180 . Since the Einstein -Vlasov system is a fully classical physical model, whereas the Einstein-Dirac system is semiclassical and thus has a quantum signature, this framework provides an excellent opportunity to study the transition from quantum to classical behaviour. It turns out that even for a comparatively small number of particles, the features of the solutions are remarkably similar. For both systems, we find highly relativistic solutions having a multi-peak structure with strikingly similar characteristics. We also investigate the maximum compactness ratio sup 2 m / r \sup 2m/r of the solutions. The solutions of both systems share the fundamental properties regarding the maximum compactness ratio and obey the inequality derived in [ 8 ] . Furthermore, we investigate the sign of the pressure components of solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system. For small values of κ \kappa , there are regions where the radial pressure is negative. These regions disappear as κ \kappa increases. This supports the interpretation we make as a transition from quantum to classical behaviour as the number of fermions increases. 1 Introduction In 1999 Finster, Smoller and Yau [ 18 ] constructed, by numerical methods, spherically symmetric static solutions to the Einstein-Dirac system. These gravitationally localized solutions are often referred to as Einstein-Dirac solitons, with all metric and fermion fields regular at the origin and the resulting spacetime being asymptotically flat. This class of solutions was already considered by Lee and Pang [ 24 ] in 1987 but their analysis was based on approximations. The Dirac equation gives a quantum mechanical description of fermions, whereas the Einstein equations belong to classical physics. The Einstein-Dirac system thus constitutes a semiclassical model for the gravitational interaction of fermions. To obtain spherically symmetric solutions, Finster et al. considered two neutral fermions with opposite spin so that the total angular momentum vanishes; a necessary property of a spherical symmetric solution. In 2020 this idea was generalized by Leith et al. [ 25 ] to a system consisting of many particles or, more precisely, to an even number \kappa of neutral fermions. Their study focuses on the case where \kappa is large compared to the case with two neutral fermions, and values of \kappa up to 90 were considered. Leith et al. find solutions in which strong gravitational effects are in evidence, i.e., exceedingly compact solutions characterized by a very high redshift. Their solutions are soliton-like wave functions which they interpret in terms of a form of self-trapping, where the fermions become localized on shells, which are separated by regions where the energy density almost vanishes. Accordingly, the graph of the energy density, as a function of the radius, becomes multi-peaked. This multi-peak structure of high-redshift solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system was thought to be a phenomenon [ 25 ] that had previously not been observed for other specific physical systems (though it had been observed in models with a given equation of state [ 22 ] ). However, a very similar type of solutions was obtained by the first author and Gerhard Rein in 2007 in a study of static solutions of the Einstein -Vlasov system [ 15 ] . The purpose of the present work is to make a careful comparison of the static solutions of these two systems as the number of particles \kappa of the Einstein-Dirac system increases. We find that even for a small number of particles the properties of the solutions are notably similar despite the fact that the matter models are so different. Since the Einstein -Vlasov system is a fully classical physical model, whereas the Einstein-Dirac system is semiclassical and has a quantum signature, this framework provides an excellent opportunity to study the transition from quantum to classical behaviour. A useful quantity for studying the transition to classical behaviour, is the pressure. For phenomenological matter models, such as fluids or Vlasov matter, the pressure is non-negative everywhere, whereas solutions of field-theoretical matter models may have regions where the pressure is negative. In this work, we find indeed that there are negative pressure regions for solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system when \kappa is small. When \kappa increases these regions disappear (for finite \kappa ) and the pressure becomes non-negative everywhere and we interpret this as a transition to classical behaviour. We find it remarkable that this transition occurs for a comparatively small number of fermions. Another aspect of negative pressure is that in the literature about the Einstein equations, it is common that the pressure is chosen to be negative. A common choice is that the pressure p=-\rho for an isotropic model where \rho is the energy density, cf. e.g. [ 27 ] . For a genuine coupled Einstein-matter system such as the Einstein-Dirac system or the Einstein -Vlasov system, choosing an equation of state such as p=-\rho cannot be made freely. The relation between pressure and energy density is implicit and is only known once a solution has been obtained. The amplitude of the modulus of the pressure in the negative regions is very small for solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system. A similar observation is made in the case of \ell -boson stars [ 2 ] . The pressure in these cases is thus far from fulfilling p=-\rho . Hence, making an arbitrary choice of the equation of state may lead to highly unrealistic physical systems. The overall aim in the present work is to compare several characterizing properties of highly relativistic solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system and the Einstein -Vlasov system. In addition to the multi-peak structure and the negative pressure-regions as discussed above, we also compare results on the maximum compactness ratio \Gamma:=\sup\frac{2m(r)}{r}, (1.1) which determines the maximum gravitational red-shift. We investigate how well the energy condition p_{r}+2p_{\perp}\leq\rho, (1.2) which always holds for solutions of the Einstein -Vlasov system, is satisfied for solutions of the Einstein-Dirac system. Here, p_{r},p_{\perp} and \rho are the radial pressure, the tangential pressure and the energy density, respectively. The connection between \Gamma and the energy condition p_{r}+2p_{\perp}\leq\rho was investigated in [ 8 ] , where it was shown that \Gamma\leq\frac{8}{9}, (1.3) for any solution to the Einstein-matter system for which ( 1.2 ) holds and for which the radial pressure is non-negative. Note that ( 1.3 ) is not the standard Buchdahl bound, which requires that the energy density is non-increasing and that the pressure is isotropic, two assumptions which are violated in our case. It will be seen that the solutions of