The Four-Point Correlator of Planar sYM at Twelve Loops
Jacob L. Bourjaily, Song He (何颂), Canxin Shi (施灿欣), Yichao Tang (唐一朝) · 2025
Read The Four-Point Correlator of Planar sYM at Twelve Loops by Jacob L. Bourjaily, Song He (何颂), Canxin Shi (施灿欣), Yichao Tang (唐一朝) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15593.txt.
Introduction
In a stripped-down quantum field theory beloved by theorists, a basic quantity called the four-point correlator can be built loop by loop, and each loop multiplies the work. Four authors push the calculation to twelve loops. A recently found shortcut, the double-triangle rule, turns out to contain two older rules inside it, and applying it settles the full eleven-loop answer.
At twelve loops it fixes all but three of more than twenty-two million coefficients, and a second, older rule settles those as well. Along the way the team confirms a guessed pattern for one family of graphs and finds evidence for a far broader version covering all polygon-framed fishnet graphs. All contributions through twelve loops are released as data files with the work, giving other theorists a reference point for testing new methods.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jacob L. Bourjaily, Song He (何颂), Canxin Shi (施灿欣), Yichao Tang (唐一朝) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15593
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Four-Point Correlator of Planar sYM at Twelve Loops Jacob L. Bourjaily, Song He (何颂), Canxin Shi (施灿欣), Yichao Tang (唐一朝) Abstract We determine the 4-point correlation function and amplitude in planar, maximally supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory to 12 loops. We find that the recently-introduced ‘double-triangle’ rule in fact implies the previously described square and pentagon rules; and when applied to 12 loops, it fully determines the 11-loop correlator and fixes all but 3 of the ( 22,024,902 22,\!024,\!902 ) 12-loop coefficients; these remaining coefficients can be subsequently fixed using the ‘(single-)triangle’ rule. Not only do we confirm the Catalan conjecture for anti-prism graphs, but we discover evidence for a greatly generalized Catalan conjecture for the coefficients of all polygon-framed fishnet graphs. We provide all contributions through 12 loops as ancillary files to this work. gbsn IIntroduction Much of the recent progress in our understanding of perturbative Quantum Field Theory has resulted from the discovery of remarkable new structures within the ‘theoretical data’ resulting from hard computations; such discoveries have led to many deep insights and fueled the development of powerful new tools for computation—extending our theoretical reach to further discovery. The four-point amplitude in the planar limit of maximally supersymmetric ( \mathcal{N}\!=\!4 ) Yang-Mills theory (sYM) has long served as an important benchmark (among many) in our perturbative reach. This amplitude was first determined at the integrand level via generalized unitarity through six loops Bern:1997nh ; Anastasiou:2003kj ; Bern:2005iz ; Bern:2006ew ; Bern:2007ct ; Bern:2012di , to eight loops using the ‘soft-collinear bootstrap’ in Bourjaily:2011hi ; Bourjaily:2015bpz . In Bourjaily:2016evz a set of graphical rules (exploiting the correspondence between this amplitude and correlation functions) was described and used to determine the amplitude through ten loops; more recently, a new graphical rule was described by He:2024cej which brought this benchmark to eleven loops! Although the only ‘observable’ associated with this amplitude is the cusp anomalous dimension (well known to high orders and at strong coupling via integrability Gromov:2009tv ; Beisert:2010jr ), studying this object at the integrand -level has led directly to developments of generalized unitarity Mangano:1990by ; Bern:1994zx ; Bern:1994cg ; Dixon:1996wi ; Cachazo:2005ga ; Bern:2007dw ; Feng:2011np , on-shell recursion relations BCF ; BCFW ; ArkaniHamed:2010kv , the discovery of dual conformal invariance Drummond:2007cf ; Alday:2007hr ; Drummond:2008vq ; Brandhuber:2008pf ; Drummond:2009fd and Yangian invariance Drummond:2010km of sYM, along with much more. Moreover, by taking higher-point light-like limits, it is known that this one particular function captures complete perturbative information about all n -point scattering amplitudes in sYM Brandhuber:2007yx ; Caron-Huot:2010ryg ; Alday:2010zy ; Eden:2010zz ; Eden:2010ce ; Eden:2011ku ; Eden:2011yp ; Eden:2011we ; Eden:2012tu ; Heslop:2022xgp (see also Gonzalez-Rey:1998wyj ; Eden:1998hh ; Eden:1999kh ; Eden:2000mv ; Bianchi:2000hn ). In this work, we argue that the double-triangle rule of He:2024cej in fact implies the ‘square’ and ‘pentagon’ rules described in Bourjaily:2016evz , and we use this together with the ‘triangle’ rule of Bourjaily:2016evz to determine the integrand of correlator/amplitude to 12 loops. This new graphical rule relates \ell -loop contributions to those at (\ell{-}1) loops, fixing all contributions at (\ell{-}1) loops completely as we confirm at \ell=12 . A byproduct is an independent confirmation of the so-called Catalan conjecture for the anti-prism graphs which have the largest coefficients, -42 in the 12 -loop case. Moreover, our results provide evidence for a much more general conjecture, which predicts coefficients of certain infinite families of graphs as common generalizations of anti-prism graphs and f -graphs for the so-called fishnet integrals Basso:2017jwq . Without such high-loop empirical ‘data’, it is hard to imagine such structure being anticipated or discovered. IISummary of the Double-Triangle Rule Consider the connected four-point correlation function \mathcal{G}\text{\makebox[14.5pt][c]{$\hskip-150.0pt\displaystyle\hskip 0.0pt\text{\makebox[0.0pt][r]{$\raisebox{0.47pt}{\hskip 1.25pt:\hskip-4.0pt}$}}=\text{\makebox[0.0pt][l]{$$}}\hskip-150.0pt$}}\langle\mathcal{O}(x_{1})\,\bar{\mathcal{O}}(x_{2})\,\mathcal{O}(x_{3})\,\bar{\mathcal{O}}(x_{4})\rangle of the lightest half-BPS operators \mathcal{O}(x)\text{\makebox[14.5pt][c]{$\hskip-150.0pt\displaystyle\hskip 0.0pt\text{\makebox[0.0pt][r]{$\raisebox{0.47pt}{\hskip 1.25pt:\hskip-4.0pt}$}}=\text{\makebox[0.0pt][l]{$$}}\hskip-150.0pt$}}\mathrm{tr}(\varphi(x)^{2}) in sYM. Perturbatively, loop corrections of \mathcal{G} can be computed using Lagrangian insertions Eden:2011yp : the \ell -loop integrand is given by the Born-level correlator with \ell chiral Lagrangian insertions x_{i=5,\ldots,4{+}\ell} . Normalized with an overall \ell -independent factor, the resulting integrand is a rational function \mathcal{F}^{(\ell)}(x_{1},\ldots,x_{4{+}\ell}) with uniform conformal weight {-}4 in all (4{+}\ell) points enjoying complete \mathfrak{S}_{4{+}\ell} permutation symmetry among its arguments Eden:2011we . Permutation invariance suggests that we describe this function in terms of unlabeled graphs, and expand \mathcal{F}^{(\ell)} into a basis of \ell -loop ‘ f -graphs’ constructed as rational products of edge-factors. The space of inequivalent f -graphs can be easily constructed, allowing us to express \mathcal{F}^{(\ell)}\text{\makebox[14.5pt][c]{$\hskip-150.0pt\displaystyle\text{\makebox[0.0pt][r]{$$}}=\text{\makebox[0.0pt][l]{$\raisebox{0.47pt}{\hskip-4.0pt:\hskip 1.25pt}$}}\hskip-150.0pt$}}\sum_{i}c_{i}^{\ell}f_{i}^{(\ell)} . Each f -graph corresponds to a permutation-invariant rational function constructed from a graph \Gamma(f) involving (4{+}\ell) vertices, with uniform conformal weight {-}4 in each. Letting \Gamma_{\!\!\!\mathfrak{n},\mathfrak{d}}(f) denote the subgraphs associated with the numerator and denominator, respectively, we define f\text{\makebox[14.5pt][c]{$\hskip-150.0pt\displaystyle\hskip 0.0pt\text{\makebox[0.0pt][r]{$\raisebox{0.47pt}{\hskip 1.25pt:\hskip-4.0pt}$}}=\text{\makebox[0.0pt][l]{$$}}\hskip-150.0pt$}}\frac{\prod_{i\bullet\!\!-\!\!\bullet j\in\Gamma_{\!\!\!\mathfrak{n}}(f)}x_{i\,j}^{2}}{\prod_{i\bullet\!\!-\!\!\bullet j\in\Gamma_{\!\!\!\mathfrak{d}}(f)}x_{i\,j}^{2}}{+}\left(\begin{subarray}{c}\displaystyle\text{permutations }\mathfrak{S}_{4+\ell}\\ \displaystyle\text{mod }\mathrm{Aut}(\Gamma(f))\end{subarray}\right).\vskip-0.5pt (1) That is, we may consider f -graph corresponds to an unlabeled graph \Gamma(f) with (4{+}\ell) vertices, and solid (resp., dashed) edges representing denominators \Gamma_{\!\!\!\mathfrak{d}}(f) (resp., numerators \Gamma_{\!\!\!\mathfrak{n}}(f) ). For example, the onlt planar (referring to the denominator’s subgraph) f -graph at \ell=3 is \hskip-150.0pt\displaystyle\hskip-10.0pt\raisebox{-20.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{7pt}}\raisebox{-0.95pt}{\scalebox{1.25}{$\hskip-5.0pt\Leftrightarrow\;$}}\underbrace{\frac{x_{12}^{2}}{\prod_{i=3}^{7}x_{1i}^{2}x_{2i}^{2}x_{i,i+1}^{2}}\hskip-2.0pt+\hskip-2.0pt\left(\begin{subarray}{c}\displaystyle\text{inequivalent}\\ \displaystyle\text{perms.}\end{subarray}\right)}_{\text{252 distinct terms}},\hskip-150.0pt (2) which has |\mathrm{Aut}(\Gamma(f))|=20 . We are interested in the planar limit of sYM, where only planar f -graphs contribute. Universal divergences of the correlator under physical limits impose constraints which relate \mathcal{F}^{(\ell)} and \mathcal{F}^{(\ell-1)} ; they translate nicely into graphical rules which we use to bootstrap the f -graph coefficients. The most familiar example is the triangle rule Bourjaily:2016evz from the \log x_{12}^{2} divergence in the OPE limit x_{2}\to x_{1} Eden:2012tu . A more powerful constraint was discovered in He:2024cej arising from the Sudakov \log x_{12}^{2}\log x_{23}^{2} divergence in the double light-like limit x_{12}^{2},x_{23}^{2}\to 0 , which leads to the double-triangle rule , \mathcal{P}({\cal F}^{(\ell)})={\cal F}^{(\ell-1)} with the pinching operation \mathcal{P} acting on all double-triangle structures: \mathcal{P}\!\!:\raisebox{-19.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{pinch_before}}\raisebox{-0.95pt}{\scalebox{1.25}{$\;\Rightarrow\;$}}\raisebox{-19.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{pinch_after}}\,.\vskip-0.5pt (3) II.1 Square and Pentagon Rules are Implied by the Double-Triangle Rule The ‘square rule’ of Bourjaily:2016evz generalizes the ‘rung rule’ of Bern:1997nh and can be derived from the consistency of the term \mathcal{A}_{1}\mathcal{A}_{\ell{-}1}\subset{\mathcal{A}^{2}}_{\ell} arising from the perturbative expansion of the square of the amplitude (as determined from the correlator). As described in Bourjaily:2016evz , it dictates equality between the coefficients of f -graphs that are related via \raisebox{-19.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{square_top}}\raisebox{-0.95pt}{\scalebox{1.25}{$\;\Leftrightarrow\;$}}\raisebox{-19.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{square_bottom}}\,.\vskip-0.5pt (4) It is easy to see this as a special case of the double-triangle rule, as the left-hand side is the unique pre-image of the resulting lower-loop graph under \mathcal{P} ( 3 ), resulting in the necessary equality between the two coefficients. While powerful, there are many graphs not susceptible to the square rule. Taking inspiration from the square rule, but taking a five-point light-like limit resulted in the somewhat peculiar ‘pentagon’ rule described in Bourjaily:2016evz (to which we refer the reader for details). Essentially, the pentagon rule dictated that the sum of coefficients of a collection of f -graphs sharing a peculiar sub-topology must vanish. In light of the double-triangle rule, it is easy to now see that the pentagon rule also follows as a special case of the double-triangle rule: \left\{\raisebox{-24.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{pentagon_rule_top_seed}}\,,\,\raisebox{-24.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{pentagon_rule_top_others}}\right\}\raisebox{-0.95pt}{\scalebox{1.25}{$\;\Rightarrow\;$}}\raisebox{-24.0pt}{\includegraphics[scale]{pentagon_rule_bottom}}\,.\vskip-0.5pt (5) The collection of terms appearing on the left-hand side of ( 5 ) are precisely those appearing as pre-images under \mathcal{P} ( 3 ) of the non-planar graph on the right-hand-side. Because the image is non-planar, the double-triangle rule dictates that the sum of coefficients must vanish. Table 1: Numbers of terms