Supercell environments using GridRad-Severe and the HRRR: Addressing discrepancies between prior tornado datasets
Brice E. Coffer \aff a, Matthew D. Parker \aff a, Michael C. Coniglio \aff b \aff c, Cameron R. Homeyer \aff c · 2025
Read Supercell environments using GridRad-Severe and the HRRR: Addressing discrepancies between prior tornado datasets by Brice E. Coffer \aff a, Matthew D. Parker \aff a, Michael C. Coniglio \aff b \aff c, Cameron R. Homeyer \aff c (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15466.txt.
Introduction
Brice Coffer and co-authors present a 2025 atmospheric science paper on supercell storm environments. Storm-relative helicity measures how spinning the inflow air is. It feeds supercell growth and tornado potential. Studies disagreed on whether shallow or deep layers of it predict tornadoes better. Suspects for the mismatch include model versus observed soundings and guessed versus measured storm motion. The team builds a fresh data set of objectively identified supercells. Observed storm motions pair with high-resolution model analyses of the air around them.
With cleaner inputs, the layer question can be settled on evidence. Forecasters get guidance on which helicity depth deserves weight in warnings. Tornado warning skill is a life-safety metric, so resolving a methods dispute has public value. The data set itself, built from radar archives and a rapid weather model, is a reusable asset for storm research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Brice E. Coffer \aff a, Matthew D. Parker \aff a, Michael C. Coniglio \aff b \aff c, Cameron R. Homeyer \aff c |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15466
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Supercell environments using GridRad-Severe and the HRRR: Addressing discrepancies between prior tornado datasets Brice E. Coffer \aff a, Matthew D. Parker \aff a, Michael C. Coniglio \aff b \aff c, Cameron R. Homeyer \aff c Abstract Storm-relative helicity (SRH) is an important ingredient in supercell development, as well as mesocyclone intensity, and is linked to tornadogenesis and tornado potential. Derived from the storm-relative wind profile, SRH is composed of both the vertical wind shear and storm-relative flow. Recent studies have come to conflicting findings regarding whether shallower or deeper layers of SRH have more skill in tornado forecasting. Possible causes of this discrepancy include the use of observed versus model-based proximity soundings, as well as whether the storm-relative wind profile is determined via observed versus estimated storm motions. This study uses a new dataset of objectively identified supercells, with observed storm motions, paired with high-resolution model analyses to address the discrepancies among prior studies. Unlike in previous model-based tornado environmental datasets, the present approach reveals substantive differences in storm-relative flow, vertical wind shear, and SRH within the low-to-mid-levels between nontornadic and tornadic supercells. Using observed storm motions for storm-relative variables further magnifies differences in the low-to-mid-level storm-relative winds between nontornadic and tornadic supercells, ultimately leading to deeper layers of SRH having more forecast skill than near-ground SRH. Thus, the combination of a higher-resolution model analysis, which better represents the near-storm environment, with observed storm motions appears to explain why many past tornado climatologies using model-based environmental analyses have failed to find significant differences in the storm-relative wind profile. These results help bridge the gap between previous studies that employed coarser model-based analyses and those that aggregated observed soundings from field projects. 1 Introduction Our understanding of environmental characteristics that favor severe convective weather, including why some supercell thunderstorms produce tornadoes and others do not, has improved considerably in recent decades ( Markowski and Richardson, 2009 ; Davies-Jones, 2015 ; Fischer et al., 2024 ) and continues to undergo refinements based on new datasets and field observations (e.g., Coffer et al., 2019 ; Coniglio and Parker, 2020 , hereafter 18 and 22 , respectively) . When combined with improvements in numerical weather prediction, especially in the mesoscale regime ( James et al., 2022 , e.g.,) , as well as the widespread adoption of convection allowing models and ensembles ( Roberts et al., 2022 , e.g.,) , regional forecasts for severe weather show a continuous rate of improvement ( Hitchens and Brooks, 2014 ; Herman et al., 2018 ) . The climatological studies of environmental tornado proxies that have been used to improve these severe weather forecasts generally fall into two categories: those that use observed soundings ( Fawbush and Miller, 1952 ; Beebe, 1958 ; Maddox, 1976 ; Johns and Doswell, 1992 ; Brooks et al., 1994b ; Rasmussen and Blanchard, 1998 ; Rasmussen, 2003 ; Craven et al., 2004 ; Parker, 2014 ; Wade et al., 2018 , e.g.,) and those that use model-based analyses ( Thompson, 1998 ; Thompson et al., 2003 ; Thompson et al., 2007 ; Thompson et al., 2012 ; Markowski et al., 2003 ; Togstad et al., 2011 ; Nowotarski and Jensen, 2013 ; Anderson-Frey et al., 2016 , e.g.,) to represent the near-storm environment. Each category has its pros and cons. Observed soundings have the benefit of being direct measurements of the current state of the atmosphere, but historically have had to compromise on temporal and spatial proximity to populate a large sample size ( Potvin et al., 2010 ) . The presence of strong spatial gradients, combined with rapid temporal evolution and storm-scale feedbacks ( Markowski et al., 1998 ; Nowotarski et al., 2014 ; Parker, 2014 ; Davenport and Parker, 2015 ; Wade et al., 2018 , e.g.,) , make it challenging for the operational upper-air network to adequately represent supercell near-storm environments. Using multiple decades of observed soundings from field projects, 22 addressed many of these limitations. However, field project operations are most often undertaken during the spring months, in the central region of the United States, and tend to focus on robust, high-end supercells ( 22 ) ; thus, they may not represent the full supercell spectrum ( Coniglio and Thompson, 2024 , hereafter 23 ) . On the other hand, the primary benefit of model-based analyses is their superior temporal and spatial coverage compared to field projects and the operational upper-air sounding network. With a greater number of cases available for analysis comes the drawback of relying on the model’s representation of the environment, which is known to have biases ( Coniglio, 2012 ; Coniglio and Jewell, 2022 , hereafter 21 ) , especially in the planetary boundary layer. Recent research, using both observed ( Parker, 2014 ; Coffer and Parker, 2017 ; Coffer and Parker, 2018 ) and model-based analyses ( Coffer et al., 2020 ; Nixon and Allen, 2022 ; Goldacker and Parker, 2021 ; Goldacker and Parker, 2023 , 18 ,) , has focused on how characteristics of the near-ground wind profile influence the organization and intensity of the low-level 1 1 1 We define low-levels as approximately 1000 m above ground level (AGL), typically at or below the level of free convection. This is in contrast to near-ground ( < 500 m AGL) and mid-levels ( \sim 3–6 km AGL). Accordingly, low-to-mid-levels is defined as 1–3 km AGL. mesocyclone in supercells. Near-ground environmental streamwise horizontal vorticity, and its storm-relative flux into an updraft (storm-relative helicity; SRH), has been found to be skillful at distinguishing between nontornadic and significantly tornadic supercells that produce EF2+ tornadoes (e.g., Parker, 2014 , 18 , 23 ) . In numerical cloud modeling focused on the lower tropospheric wind profile, highly streamwise near-ground wind profiles yield organized, steady low-level mesocyclones, increasing the likelihood of tornadogenesis ( Markowski and Richardson, 2014 ; Coffer et al., 2017 ; Peters et al., 2023 , e.g.,) . Air ingested into the low-level mesocyclone almost exclusively comes from near the ground ( Coffer et al., 2023 ) , crucially providing the dynamic lifting needed for tornadogenesis below the level of free convection where buoyancy cannot contribute (distinguishing supercells from ordinary thunderstorms). While the influence of the near-ground wind profile on the low-level mesocyclone is clear, the specific claim that the near-ground SRH (e.g., 0–500 m SRH, SRH500) is statistically more skillful than SRH computed over deeper layers ( Thompson et al., 2007 , e.g., 0–3 km SRH, SRH3; or SRH within the effective inflow layer, ESRH;) has since been questioned. Using observed, field project soundings, 22 found substantial differences in the low- to mid-level wind profile from 1–3 km AGL, both in the vertical wind shear and storm-relative winds. The combination of these components yields larger SRH when integrated over deeper layers and more forecast skill distinguishing tornadic/significantly tornadic supercells from their nontornadic counterparts. These differences have not been noted in any model-based tornado environment studies to date ( Markowski et al., 2003 ; Thompson et al., 2003 ; Thompson et al., 2012 , C19) , which have all been based on analyses from of the Rapid Update Cycle ( Benjamin et al., 2004 , RUC;) and the Rapid Refresh ( Benjamin et al., 2016 ,