Mechanism of Shape Symmetry Breaking in Surfactant Mediated Crystal Growth

Sam Oaks-Leaf, David T. Limmer · 2025

Read Mechanism of Shape Symmetry Breaking in Surfactant Mediated Crystal Growth by Sam Oaks-Leaf, David T. Limmer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15419.txt.

Introduction

Sam Oaks-Leaf and David Limmer explain how symmetric seeds grow into lopsided crystals in a 2025 paper. Metal nanorods grow from round seeds in a uniform bath, yet one end often races ahead. Soap-like molecules coating the faces hold the key.

Their dynamical model shows a feedback loop: random thermal flickers unevenly coat the facets, the bare patches grow faster, and faster growth locks in the uneven coating. The asymmetry then persists on its own. Turning knobs like soap strength and concentration shifts the outcome in the model. The authors connect these knobs to real lab settings, suggesting recipes that raise the yield of rods over symmetric particles.

Catalog record

CREATORSam Oaks-Leaf, David T. Limmer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15419

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mechanism of Shape Symmetry Breaking in Surfactant Mediated Crystal Growth Sam Oaks-Leaf, David T. Limmer Abstract We present a dynamical model of crystal growth, in which it is possible to reliably achieve asymmetric products, beginning from symmetric initial conditions and growing within an isotropic environment. The asymmetric growth is the result of a positive feedback mechanism that amplifies the effect of thermal fluctuations in the coverage of surfactants on the growing crystalline facets. Within our simple model, we are able to understand the kinetic and thermodynamic factors involved in both the onset of symmetry breaking and the persistence of anisotropic growth. We demonstrate that the mechanism is general by studying models with increasing complexity. We argue that this mechanism of symmetry breaking underpins observations of colloidal, seed-mediated syntheses of single crystalline metal nanorods capped with strongly interacting surfactants. The parameters within our model are related to experimental observables such as the concentration, hydrophobicity, and binding strength of the surfactants, which suggests a potential route to optimize the yield of asymmetric products in colloidal nanoparticle syntheses. Preprint: APS/123-QED In crystal growth processes at the nanoscale, it has long been known that surfactants play a key role in determining the shape of the products by altering the growth rates and stability of crystalline facets [ 1 , 2 ] . However, it is only heuristically understood how surfactants can break the symmetry of an initial seed during a crystal growth process [ 3 , 4 ] . A prototypical example of a surfactant-mediated growth process that spontaneously breaks symmetry is the seed-based synthesis of colloidal metal nanorods in solution. Although such syntheses are well-studied experimentally [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] , there currently does not exist a general theory of crystal growth that can explain the onset of persistent anisotropic growth without asymmetry in the initial conditions or in the environment. This letter presents a simple and general positive feedback mechanism that amplifies thermal fluctuations in the coverage of surfactants and leads to persistent anisotropic growth from symmetric initial conditions. We show first that this mechanism can be understood within a deterministic model of crystal growth as a dynamical instability [ 13 ] in the equations of motion for the average positions of crystalline facets. Then, we demonstrate the necessary conditions on the kinetics of the system to guarantee persistent anisotropic growth in a stochastic system. Finally, within a detailed model, we connect the parameters of the model to experimental observables such as the concentration, hydrophobicity, and binding strength of the surfactants used in the synthetic protocol, opening the door for leveraging insights from the model to optimize the yield of asymmetric products in colloidal nanoparticle syntheses. The thermodynamically preferred shape of a crystal at any size is determined by the Wulff construction [ 14 ] and contains the same symmetry as the underlying lattice. Molecular simulations have demonstrated the stability of surfactant micelles on different crystalline facets [ 15 ] , and while this can alter the relative stabilities of facets it does not explain asymmetric growth. Kinetic generalizations of a Wulff construction that express the shape as ratios of crystal growth rates also predict isotropic crystals in isotropic environments provided symmetric seeds. If surfactants modify the growth rates of all equivalent facets in the same way, the symmetry of the initial seed will be preserved [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . Therefore, a theory that can explain spontaneous symmetry breaking in a crystal growth process must include thermal fluctuations as well as a mechanism for these fluctuations to persist. The simplest model capable of exhibiting symmetry breaking during growth is one in which two equivalent facets grow in perpendicular directions. We initially consider growth in two dimensions on a square lattice, with the average position of each facet, h_{x} and h_{y} ( Fig. 1 ). We suppose growth is driven by a constant chemical potential difference, \Delta\mu_{g} , between monomers in a fluid and the crystal, and that the temperature is much lower than the binding strength between monomers such that growth on a given crystalline facet proceeds only via the nucleation of complete layers. The simplest possible equations of motion that are thermodynamically consistent with such a process are \frac{\mathrm{d}h_{i}}{\mathrm{d}t}=K_{g}^{+}(1-e^{-\beta(\Delta\mu_{g}h_{j}-\epsilon_{g})}) (1) where i and j represent x and y symmetrically, \beta is the inverse temperature times Boltzmann’s constant, \epsilon_{g} is the energetic cost of breaking one bond between a pair of metal atoms, and K_{g}^{+} is the average growth rate of a new facet. We note that in principle K_{g}^{+} could depend on h_{j} , but it is not necessary to consider this additional detail at present. Importantly, just from thermodynamic considerations, the evolution of h_{x} and h_{y} are coupled and in such a way that could never lead to asymmetric growth. If h_{x}>h_{y} , then clearly \mathrm{d}h_{x}/\mathrm{d}t\leq\mathrm{d}h_{y}/\mathrm{d}t . Figure 1: Surfactants dynamically stabilize anisotropic growth. a , Schematic of the mechanism of symmetry breaking in a square lattice with red being the surfactant and yellow the metal nanocrystal. b , Parametric plot of average facet positions, h_{x} and h_{y} , evolving under Eq. 2 , with \epsilon_{g}=\epsilon_{b}=0 and \beta\Delta\mu_{g}=1.0 The label, \beta\Delta\mu_{b}>0.0 , corresponds to \beta\Delta\mu_{b}=0.1 . Trajectories begin from initial condition h_{x}=h_{y}=5.0 , \rho_{x}=0.0 , and \rho_{y}=0.5 . K_{b}^{+} is equal to K_{g}^{+} and t_{f}K_{g}^{+}=10^{4} . c , The same trajectories as in ( b ) but showing the average difference in surfactant densities between the y and x facets as a function of time. Circular markers correspond to the same points in time as the corresponding markers in ( b ). d , Trajectories sampled from stochastic coarse-grained model with KMC. The initial condition is totally symmetric, with h_{x}=h_{y}=5 and \rho_{x}=\rho_{y}=1 . All other parameters are the same as in ( b ) and ( c ). In practice, the growth of nanocrystals from solution occurs in the presence of passivating, surface-active ligands. To include such an effect, we introduce \rho_{i} which varies between 0 and 1, as the average surfactant density on the i th facet. We ignore the spatial dependence of the surfactant density, assuming that the surfactant molecules interact strongly enough that the only thermodynamically favorable states are a fully covered or an empty facet. We first assume that a covered facet cannot grow, so that the evolution equations become \displaystyle\frac{\mathrm{d}h_{i}}{\mathrm{d}t} \displaystyle=(1-\rho_{i})K_{g}^{+}(1-e^{-\beta(\Delta\mu_{g}h_{j}-\epsilon_{g})}) \displaystyle\frac{\mathrm{d}\rho_{i}}{\mathrm{d}t} \displaystyle=K_{b}^{+}\big(1-\rho_{i}(1+e^{-\beta(\Delta\mu_{b}h_{j}-\epsilon_{b})})\big) (2) where we have introduced the subscript, b , for each parameter associated with the ligand species as they “block” crystal growth. If growth is thermodynamically preferred for facet i , \Delta\mu_{g}h_{j}>\epsilon , then its growth rate will be greater than or equal to zero. A rate of zero growth is only achieved if \rho_{i}=1 . From Eq. 2 , provided some initial infinitesimal asymmetry and \beta\Delta\mu_{b}>0 , this model predicts persistent asymmetric growth via a positive reinforcement mechanism. The mechanism is illustrated schematically in Fig. 1a and an example of asymmetric growth is shown in Fig. 1b and c . A system initialized as a perfect square with symmetric surfactant coverage will grow as a square indefinitely. However, if the surfactant coverage is perturbed away from this symmetry point, such that for

Read the complete text