The value of hedging against energy storage uncertainties when designing energy parks Journal: Energy
Max Langtry, Ruchi Choudhary · 2025
Read The value of hedging against energy storage uncertainties when designing energy parks Journal: Energy by Max Langtry, Ruchi Choudhary (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15416.txt.
Introduction
Max Langtry and Ruchi Choudhary ask whether keeping design flexibility is worth its cost when planning renewable energy parks, in a 2025 paper. Storage is needed to match wind and solar output to factory demand, but future storage performance is deeply uncertain. Parks must be designed now anyway.
Using a model based on a real proposal near Rotterdam, they applied value-of-information analysis to wind, solar, and storage sizing. Resizing the park once storage facts improved cut total costs by about a fifth on average. Keeping the option to switch storage type saved more than the option cost. Pairing two storage types also saved money, though then the switch option stopped paying.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Max Langtry, Ruchi Choudhary |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15416
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The value of hedging against energy storage uncertainties when designing energy parks Journal: Energy Max Langtry, Ruchi Choudhary Abstract Energy storage is needed to match renewable generation to industrial loads in energy parks. However, the future performance of bulk storage technologies is currently highly uncertain. Due to the urgency of decarbonization targets, energy park projects must be designed and begun now. But, as uncertainty in storage performance reduces, a different technology than identified during initial design may turn out cheaper. Enabling flexibility so that designs can be updated as better information becomes available would lower the cost of decarbonizing industry. But having this flexibility is itself costly. This raises the question, “Is it worth it?” This study quantifies the benefit of retaining flexibility to adapt energy park designs and optionality over storage technology choice as uncertainty reduces, to determine whether it is economically worthwhile. It applies the Value of Information analysis framework to the sizing of wind, solar, and storage in an illustrative energy park model based on a real-world proposal near Rotterdam, considering uncertainty in storage efficiency, lifetime, and capital cost. Updating asset sizings after storage uncertainty reduced is found to reduce total costs by 18% on average. Having the option to switch storage technology choice as well reduces costs by a further 13%, which is substantially greater than the cost of providing storage optionality. Using two storage technologies in the energy park reduces costs by 14%, and in this case storage optionality is not worthwhile. These results are robust to the level of uncertainty reduction in storage performance, and the risk aversion of the system designer. † † highlights: Sizing of wind, solar, and storage in energy park using stochastic programming Impact of reducing uncertainty in storage efficiency, lifetime, and cost on design Updating sizings after storage uncertainty reduced lowers cost by 18% on average Option to switch storage choice reduces costs by extra 13%, more than cost of option Using two storage techs reduces costs by 14%, and optionality no longer worthwhile 1 Introduction Decarbonizing electricity generation is critical to achieving 2050 net-zero carbon emissions targets [ 1 ] . Currently 40% of electricity in the UK is generated from carbon intensive sources [ 2 ] , and electricity demand is expect to increase by a factor 3 to 4 as heating and transport energy usage are decarbonized via electrification [ 3 ] . As a result, around 100 GW of wind and 60 GW of solar generation need to be constructed by 2050 [ 3 ] . However, managing the variability of electricity generation from these renewable sources to maintain security of supply presents a significant challenge [ 4 ] , and the required adaptation of the energy system will be costly. Grid-scale energy storage is expected to be the main mechanism for matching renewable electricity supply with demand. Co-locating bulk energy storage with renewable generation and industrial loads, referred to as an energy park, has been proposed as a way of both improving the profitability of grid-scale storage (reducing the cost of its services), and reducing the grid impact of variable renewable generation [ 5 ] . The design of energy parks, including the selection and sizing of renewable generation and energy storage technologies, has been extensively studied in the literature. For example, Arévalo & Jurado [ 6 ] investigates the combination of energy storage technology and control scheme that provides the lowest net present cost for supporting an autonomous grid with solar, wind, hydro, and diesel generation. Sizing optimization is performed for each system configuration, and it is found that due to the different performance characteristics of the storage technologies, they are best suited to supporting substantially different generation mixes. This indicates that the technical performance of energy storage has a significant impact on how the energy system should be sized. Hu et al. [ 7 ] considers a district energy system with local renewable generation providing both electricity and heat. It demonstrates that optimizing the sizing and location of battery storage, hydrogen storage, and CHP units in the system can reduce the net load fluctuation by 25%. Similar benefits of using energy storage to manage variability in both renewable generation and load are shown by Phu et al. [ 8 ] , which studies an energy park producing green hydrogen from biomass using electricity from wind and solar generation. Optimizing battery and hydrogen energy storage within the system is shown to substantially reduce the operating cost, carbon emissions, and grid reliance of the energy park. Further this optimized configuration is demonstrated to be robust against uncertainties in hydrogen demand, grid electricity price, and renewable generation. Many different energy storage technologies have been considered for supporting energy parks , such as Lead-acid batteries, Lithium-ion batteries, compressed-air storage, and redox flow batteries [ 9 ] . However the future performance of these technologies, i.e. how they will perform when implemented in the grid from around 2030 onwards, is still highly uncertain. Across the literature, estimates of technical parameters (e.g. round-trip efficiency and self-discharge rate) and economic parameters (e.g. cost per energy capacity and service lifetime) vary over wide ranges [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . For example, a literature review, [ 10 ] , found estimates for Sodium-Sulphur high-temperature batteries ranging from 70–90% for round-trip efficiency, and 0–20% for self-discharge rate. An IRENA report, [ 9 ] , estimated the annualized energy capacity cost of compressed-air storage to be between 2 and 355 cents/kWh/yr. These highly uncertain technical and economic performance parameters have a significant impact on the cost of developing and operating grid-scale storage in energy parks. Crucially, it also causes uncertainty in which storage technology will provide the lowest cost pathway to supporting variable renewable generation. As research and development of storage technologies progresses, uncertainty in their performance will decrease, and the best technology will emerge. However, to meet 2030 and 2040 carbon emissions reductions targets, energy parks must be designed and begin development in the near future. This raises the following question, “When designing an energy park, can the best energy storage technology be identified with the current level of uncertainty in performance? Or should developers keep their options open to potentially make a better choice when uncertainty has reduced?” No existing studies have considered the impact of reduction in storage performance uncertainty on the design of energy parks and the selection of storage technologies. In fact, very few consider storage uncertainties during energy park design. 1.1 Storage technology performance uncertainty in energy park design The impact of uncertainty on the operation of energy parks, and so the cost of arbitraging energy to match variable generation with demand, has been widely studied [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] . Many previous articles have investigated the optimal sizing of generation and storage assets to maximize total profit in the presence of various uncertainties. For example, Kim et al. [ 18 ] consider the sizing of wind generation, battery storage, and electrolyser capacity in a micro-grid with local demands for both electricity and hydrogen. A bi-level optimization method is used to minimize the average cost of meeting the local energy demands, accounting for uncertainty in