Loophole-free argument for physicality of electromagnetic potential from causal structure of flux quantization

Konrad Schlichtholz, Marcin Markiewicz · 2025

Read Loophole-free argument for physicality of electromagnetic potential from causal structure of flux quantization by Konrad Schlichtholz, Marcin Markiewicz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15410.txt.

Introduction

Konrad Schlichtholz and Marcin Markiewicz argue that the electromagnetic potential is physically real, under a locality assumption, in this 2025 paper. Potentials were long treated as mere math helpers for fields. The Aharonov-Bohm effect hints they act where fields are zero. A noted critique showed that effect can still be told with local fields alone. The new argument uses flux quantization's causal structure instead. That setup dodges the critique's loophole, they claim.

If locality holds, the potential's reality follows. The debate is foundational for quantum theory. What counts as real guides how effects are explained. The paper is a physics foundations argument. It picks its test case to close old escape routes.

Catalog record

CREATORKonrad Schlichtholz, Marcin Markiewicz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15410

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Loophole-free argument for physicality of electromagnetic potential from causal structure of flux quantization Konrad Schlichtholz, Marcin Markiewicz Abstract Recent work by Vaidman [Phys. Rev. A 86, 040101 (2012)] showed that Aharonov-Bohm effect can be explained in terms of local fields, thus effectively restating an old problem of physicality of potentials. In this work, we propose an argument demonstrating the physicality of electromagnetic potential (upon the assumption of locality) based on the causal structure in flux quantization setup. Crucially, we discuss the fundamental difference between the considered setup and the Aharonov-Bohm experiment that allows for avoiding Vaidman’s loophole in our scenario. keywords electromagnetic potential, flux quantization, Aharonov-Bohm effect, superconductivity 1 Introduction 1.1 The nature of electromagnetic potential – theoretical perspective The dispute about whether electromagnetic potentials should be considered physical after decades still has not reached its end. This problem originates in the strong opinion of a part of the scientific community that objects treated as physical entities should be assigned values that are in principle uniquely determined through measurements. In classical electrodynamics, this opinion is only a preference and does not pose any problems. This is because Maxwell equations can be fully stated using unique vector fields \vec{E} and \vec{H} or non-unique potentials \vec{A} and \phi that yield all the same predictions. Potentials corresponding to given fields are defined up to gauge transformations and thus rather define an abstraction class yielding a given prediction of theory and are often treated simply as a mathematical tool only. Although one may prefer to avoid more involved mathematical structures in the fundamental formulation of the theory keeping it as simple as possible, one should not forget that it is only a mathematical construction that tries to mimic our observations. If all predictions of two structures are the same, one is unable to falsify the hypothesis that one is more fundamental than another (one is physical and another is not). Here, more fundamental should be interpreted as more resembling physical reality, which we try to model, as in the end it could turn out to be different from both those structures. However, this discussion could not be hopeless as we go from classical to quantum theory. In quantum electrodynamics, charged particles are coupled with an electric field through minimal coupling. This coupling involves potentials instead of fields in order to retrieve the classical equations of motion for charged particles. The typical argument for that is that if Hamiltonian (or equivalently Lagrangian), which is the starting point for quantum theory, were to contain fields directly, the Hamiltonian or Lagrangian densities corresponding to interactions would contain the derivatives of the fields. This would imply that the interactions would be of shorter range than the inverse-square-type ones, which is not the case for the electromagnetic field. (see Weinberg 1995 , Chapter 5.9). Nevertheless, the status of electromagnetic potentials in the logical structure of constructing quantum field theory (QFT) remains unclear for another reason. In this construction, on the one hand, we have single-particle states corresponding to irreducible representations of the Poincare group (Wigner’s classification); on the other hand, we have fields with well-defined Lorentz-transformation properties, the quanta of which should correspond to the particles. Now, photons in the Wigner classification have helicities equal to \pm 1 , which gives rise to their transversal two-dimensional polarization. There should exist corresponding spin- 1 field of which they are excitations. Natural choice for such field seems to be the quantized electromagnetic four-potential A_{\mu}=(\tfrac{1}{c}\phi,\vec{A}) , however such straightforward identification is impossible for two reasons Weinberg 1995 ; Białynicki-Birula and Białynicka-Birula 1975 : (i) the quantized four-potential should have A_{0}=0 in all Lorentzian frames due to non-existence of time-like photons, which is clearly impossible for any four vector field, (ii) the commutation properties of A_{\mu} are inconsistent with the commutation properties of the fields, if fields are directly canonically quantized, and the standard relation between potentials and fields is assumed. What is important both the above difficulties hold independently of the choice of the gauge (even if the gauge is Lorentz covariant) Białynicki-Birula and Białynicka-Birula 1975 . Therefore, the quantized electromagnetic potential within quantum field theory must be treated in a non-covariant frame-dependent way, which somehow spoils the mere logic of the construction. On the other hand, as mentioned earlier, it seems necessary to be involved in describing interactions between fields and sources. This necessity is supported by the gauge-theoretical description of fundamental interactions, in which electromagnetism arises as a factor restoring invariance of the Dirac field representing electrons and positrons with respect to local U(1) transformations. In this approach electromagnetic potential plays the role of a connection field, which enables defining covariant derivative for the Dirac field. This connection is specified up to gauge transformations, nevertheless its presence and coupling with the four-current is a necessary element of restoring gauge invariance of the theory (at the same time justifying necessity of the minimal coupling description of interaction between fields and charges). At the same time the electromagnetic field tensor also naturally appears in this framework and plays the role of a curvature tensor. To sum up, the status of the electromagnetic potential within the quantum field theory is also ambiguous, and one has to search for more operational arguments to resolve the issue of its ”physicality”. 1.2 The nature of electromagnetic potential – operational perspective Since electromagnetic potential can be non trivial in the region where the field is zero, one might find that a charged particle could be in some way influenced in the absence of fields. With the assumption of locality of interactions, this would indicate that particles interacted with the potential, thus casting it as physical and more fundamental than fields. Such a reasoning has led to the discovery of the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect first described in Ehrenberg and Siday 1949 and then rediscovered by Aharonov and Bohm Aharonov and Bohm 1959 in the context of showing the physicality of the potentials. This famous effect describes the phase difference gained by the two beams of charged particles going around an infinite solenoid with some magnetic field flux \Phi present inside. As the field is confined to the solenoid, the phase difference is associated with the interaction with the potential \vec{A} . Although the existence of the effect was long debated, see e.g. the following works suggesting its non-existence via introducing non-standard forms of a vector potential Bocchieri and Loinger 1978 ; Bocchieri et al. 1980 ; Roy 1980 1 1 1 Such potentials, which on the one hand assure constant field inside the solenoid, on the other hand do not lead to the AB effect, contain singularities and violate Stokes theorem. As suggested by some authors, such potentials should not be allowed in description of physical reality, see e.g. Klein 1979 ; Greenberger 1981 . , it finally found multiple experimental confirmations Chambers 1960 ; Tonomura et al. 1986 ; Osakabe et al. 1986 ; Webb et al. 1985 . It is worth mentioning, that there exists a different approach to understanding the AB effect which emphasizes that the effect has purely topological origin, and therefore it goes beyond the ”fields vs. potentials“ dispute. Namely it states that the effect can be explained by noting that the vacuum

Read the complete text