Superconducting diode effect in Ising superconductors

Itai Bankier ∗, Lotan Attias ∗, Alex Levchenko, Maxim Khodas · 2025

Read Superconducting diode effect in Ising superconductors by Itai Bankier ∗, Lotan Attias ∗, Alex Levchenko, Maxim Khodas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15115.txt.

Introduction

Itai Bankier and co-authors study a diode-like effect in a special class of superconductors, in work published in 2025. In such a diode, current flows more easily one way than the other. The team looks at Ising superconductors with broken mirror symmetry, placed in a field that runs along the plane.

They show that strong Ising spin-orbit coupling can greatly raise how well the diode works, when a small Rashba split is also present. Without the Ising term, the effect is weak at both small and large Rashba values, for two unlike reasons. The Ising term removes both blocks. The result helps explain when this one-way current should be strong and when it should fade.

Catalog record

CREATORItai Bankier ∗, Lotan Attias ∗, Alex Levchenko, Maxim Khodas
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15115

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Superconducting diode effect in Ising superconductors Itai Bankier ∗, Lotan Attias ∗, Alex Levchenko, Maxim Khodas Abstract We study the superconducting diode effect (SDE) in an Ising superconductor with broken basal mirror symmetry in a parallel magnetic field. We show that in the presence of a small Rashba spin splitting, Δ R \Delta_{\text{R}} , the dominant Ising spin-orbit coupling ( Δ I ≫ Δ R \Delta_{\text{I}}\gg\Delta_{\text{R}} ) dramatically enhances the SDE efficiency compared to a Rashba superconductor with Δ I = 0 \Delta_{\text{I}}=0 and the same Δ R \Delta_{\text{R}} . The suppression of the SDE for Δ I = 0 \Delta_{\text{I}}=0 at Δ R \Delta_{\text{R}} much larger than the critical temperature ( T c T_{\text{c}} ) is accidental. At Δ R ≪ T c \Delta_{\text{R}}\ll T_{\text{c}} , the SDE efficiency is small because, to linear order, Δ R \Delta_{\text{R}} can be removed by a gauge transformation. These two factors – the accidental suppression of the SDE at large Δ R \Delta_{\text{R}} and the systematic suppression at small Δ R \Delta_{\text{R}} – are eliminated by Ising spin-orbit coupling. As a result, SDE efficiency is substantially enhanced for Δ I ≫ Δ R ≠ 0 \Delta_{\text{I}}\gg\Delta_{\text{R}}\neq 0 . * * footnotetext: I. B. and L. A. contributed equally to this work. I Introduction The superconducting diode effect (SDE) signifies the nonreciprocity of the critical current [ 1 , 2 ] . The SDE appears when all the unitary and anti-unitary symmetries that reverse the current ( \mathbf{J} ) are broken [ 3 ] . The most common of these are the time reversal ( \mathcal{T} ) and spatial inversion ( \mathcal{P} ) symmetries. In fact, the SDE was initially considered theoretically in noncentrosymmetric superconductors under an applied magnetic field [ 4 , 5 ] . Interest in the SDE was renewed following its observation in [Nb/V/Ta] n superlattices [ 6 ] . In subsequent years, the SDE has been reported in Josephson junctions [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] and hybrid multilayer geometries [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] . Furthermore, supercurrent rectification due to the anisotropy of the vortex pinning potential – such as the vortex ratchet effect – has been observed [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . The SDE is commonly quantified by the difference in critical currents for opposite current polarities, J_{\text{c}\pm} , using the efficiency parameter \eta_{\mathrm{SDE}}=(J_{\text{c}+}+J_{\text{c}-})/(J_{\text{c}+}-J_{\text{c}-}) . A key objective of current research is to identify setups that allow optimal control over SDE efficiency. A paradigmatic example of a system exhibiting the SDE is the Rashba superconductor [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 ] . This system describes a two-dimensional superconductor confined to the xy -plane, where basal plane mirror symmetry ( m_{\hat{z}} ) is broken, and a parallel magnetic field \mathbf{B}\perp\hat{z} is applied. Here, m_{\hat{n}} denotes mirror reflection in the plane perpendicular to a vector \mathbf{n} . The broken m_{\hat{z}} symmetry leads to a finite band spin splitting of 2\Delta_{\text{R}} due to Rashba spin-orbit coupling (SOC) [ 30 ] . As a consequence of the remaining m_{\hat{B}} symmetry, the SDE efficiency \eta_{\mathrm{SDE}} vanishes when the current flows parallel to the magnetic field ( \mathbf{J}\parallel\mathbf{B} ) and reaches its maximum when the current is perpendicular to the field ( \mathbf{J}\perp\mathbf{B} ). In this work, we propose the Ising superconductor on a substrate subject to an in-plane magnetic field as a viable alternative to Rashba superconductors (see Fig. 1 ). In a pristine Ising superconductor, the Ising SOC polarizes spins out-of-plane (Fig. 2 b) and coexists with superconductivity [ 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 ] . The substrate breaks the m_{\hat{z}} symmetry, leading to a finite Rashba spin splitting (Fig. 2 c) in addition to the Ising SOC. Our main finding is that for a given \Delta_{\text{R}}\neq 0 , the introduction of Ising SOC significantly enhances the SDE efficiency compared to a Rashba superconductor. In transition metal (M) dichalcogenide (X) monolayers, MX 2 , this amplification can realistically reach two orders of magnitude. The enhancement of the SDE in Ising superconductors is somewhat counterintuitive because (1) Ising SOC strongly counteracts the in-plane field, and (2) it tends to restore the m_{\hat{z}} symmetry, which ordinarily prohibits the SDE. To understand why, contrary to these expectations, Ising SOC strongly enhances the SDE, we revisit the dependence of the SDE on SOC in the Rashba model. We analyze this separately in the limits of strong ( \kappa_{\text{R}}\gg 1 ) and weak ( \kappa_{\text{R}}\ll 1 ) Rashba SOC, where \kappa_{\text{R}}=\Delta_{\text{R}}/\pi T_{\text{c}} , and T_{\text{c}} is the superconducting transition temperature. In what follows, we restrict ourselves to the Ginzburg-Landau (GL) regime of temperatures ( T ) close to T_{\text{c}} . Generally, in the GL formalism, the SDE scales as \eta\sim B\sqrt{T_{\text{c}}-T} [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] . At strong Rashba SOC, \kappa_{\text{R}}\gg 1 , the two-band quasi-classical approach [ 36 ] predicts a finite SDE [ 29 ] . However, in the GL regime, it yields a vanishing result at leading order in B\sqrt{T_{\text{c}}-T} . This vanishing SDE arises because of an accidental cancellation of various contributions to the critical current. Figure 1: Ising superconductor confined to the xy -plane on a substrate. Top and side view of a hexagonal lattice of a \text{MX}_{2} monolayer, where M large circles (green) is a transition metal and X small circles (red) is a chalcogen. The substrate breaks m_{\hat{z}} symmetry introducing the Rashba SOC. Current \mathbf{I} flows in the xy -plane, and an external magnetic field \mathbf{B} is applied to the system. Figure 2: First Brillouin zone of a transition-metal dichalcogenide MX 2 monolayer. (a) Fermi pockets in K ( K^{\prime} )-model of an Ising superconductor at finite trigonal warping, Eq. ( 2 ). Cooper pairs at the outer or inner Fermi pockets are intraband (dark red circles). When one of the electrons comprising a pair is at the outer (inner) pocket, while the other is at the inner (outer) pocket the Cooper pair is interband (light green circles). The interband pairing is induced by the interaction Eq. ( 3 ) at finite supercurrent and magnetic field. These perturbations also affect the intraband pairing. (b) Ising SOC \gamma^{\text{I}} (arbitrary units). (c) Streamlines of the Rashba SOC, \boldsymbol{\gamma}^{\text{R}}(\mathbf{k}\eta) . The SOC presented is based on [ 37 ] . In the opposite limit, \kappa_{\text{R}}\ll 1 , the SDE vanishes to linear order in Rashba SOC [ 38 ] . Unlike the suppression in the strong Rashba limit, this vanishing SDE is not accidental but follows directly from gauge invariance. To see this, recall that Rashba SOC can be interpreted as a coupling to a spin-dependent gauge field [ 39 , 40 ] . In one-dimensional systems, this gauge field can be eliminated via a spin-dependent gauge transformation [ 41 ] , resulting in an Aharonov-Casher phase [ 42 ] . However, in two dimensions, this transformation is generally not possible, as the spin-orbit gauge field is non-Abelian [ 43 ] , except in special cases [ 44 ] . Nevertheless, to first order in \Delta_{\text{R}} , the Rashba SOC can be eliminated using a specific

Read the complete text