Data-Driven Perspectives on Knot Invariants
Paweł Dłotko, Davide Gurnari, Radmila Sazdanovic · 2025
Read Data-Driven Perspectives on Knot Invariants by Paweł Dłotko, Davide Gurnari, Radmila Sazdanovic (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15103.txt.
Introduction
Paweł Dłotko, Davide Gurnari, and Radmila Sazdanovic bring data science tools to knot theory. The head title frames the work as data-driven perspectives on knot theory, close to the catalog title on knot invariants. Their 2025 paper uses topological data analysis to study knots and their invariants in bulk. That bulk view can show how invariants relate across many knots at once.
Worked examples show how the method lights up structure and links between invariants. The authors state new hypotheses from the patterns they find. They also gain fresh insight into long-standing conjectures in the field. The paper argues that a statistical, cumulative view adds to the classic one-knot-at-a-time study of knot theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paweł Dłotko, Davide Gurnari, Radmila Sazdanovic |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15103
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Data-Driven Perspectives on Knot Invariants Thanks: PD and DG acknowledges support by Dioscuri program initiated by the Max Planck Society, jointly managed with the National Science Centre (Poland), and mutually funded by the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education and the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research Thanks: RS was partially supported by NSF grant DMS-185470. Paweł Dłotko, Davide Gurnari, Radmila Sazdanovic Abstract . Data science offers a powerful tool to understand objects in multiple sciences. In this paper we utilize concept of data science, most notably topological data analysis, to extend our understanding of knot theory. This approach provides a way to extend mathematical exposition of various invariants of knots towards understanding their relations in statistical and cumulative way. Paper included examples illustrating how topological data analysis can illuminate structure and relations between knot invariants, state new hypothesis, and gain new insides into long standing conjectures. 1. Introduction Throughout the 20th century, and notably accelerating over the past four decades, knot theory has undergone rapid development, catalyzed by milestones such as the invention of the Jones polynomial [ 37 , 38 , 39 ] , its generalizations such as the HOMFLYPT [ 19 , 54 ] polynomial, and later its categorification, Khovanov link homology [ 42 , 4 ] . Theoretical advancements, combined with progress in algorithms and technology, have enabled computation of these invariants for numerous knots, leading to the classification of prime knots with up to 20 crossings [ 9 , 33 , 32 , 6 , 7 , 59 ] yielding a total of 1, 847, 318, 507 prime hyperbolic knots. Despite the vast availability of data and the ability to generate more on demand, data science methods applied to knots and their invariants have encountered significant challenges in attempt to unknot hard knots [ 1 , 25 ] , predict knot invariants [ 34 , 10 ] , find relations between them and addressing longstanding open problems [ 13 , 36 , 46 , 11 , 45 ] , or use for knot identification [ 58 ] . However, the theorem of Ernst and Summers [ 17 ] proves that the number of knots grows exponentially with the number of crossings making it impossible to obtain general answers using purely computational tools. In this project, we largely move away from black-box data science methods and instead utilize explainable tools from standard statistics and topological data visualization, such as Mapper [ 57 ] and Ball Mapper [ 53 ] [ 14 ] .These approaches, rather than providing answers that are valid only for the specific collections of knots considered, allow us to formulate hypotheses that can be explored theoretically and potentially extended for infinite collection of knots. In this way, we bridge data science-seeking inspiration-with mathematical tools capable of handling an infinite amount of data, which grows exponentially with the number of crossings. The paper is organized as follows: In Section 2 , we provide a brief introduction to the datasets considered and the methods used in the subsequent analysis. Section 3 explores the trends in the discriminative power of various knot invariants as the number of crossings increases. Section 5 presents topological visualization tools applied to knot data. Section 6 compares topological visualization with standard principal component analysis. Section 7 discusses data science insights into the relationship between the knot signature and Rasmussen s-invariant and provides interpretations of Ball Mapper graphs. Finally, Section 8 provides a small example of data consisting of the Jones polynomials of random knots, to complement the data analysis on knots filtered by the crossing number. 2. Data and methods 2.1. Knot invariants as data In this work we step away from considering knot as a geometric object and analyze its numerical characteristics and polynomials being the invariants of the knot. The invariants considered here were computed by J.S. Levitt, D. Shuetz, and D. Gurnari and include Khovanov homology, the Jones, Alexander, and HOMFLYPT polynomials, the minimal crossing number, the alternating property, the signature, and the Rasmussen invariant. For further details, references, as well as access to the datasets, please refer to [ 15 ] . To utilize data science tools, the knot polynomials are converted into point clouds. To achieve this, knot polynomials are represented as vectors of their coefficients, as detailed in [ 46 , 14 ] . When large collection of polynomials are considered, the obtained vectors are padded with zeros to ensure that all of them have the same length, which is determined by the overall minimum and maximum exponents of the specific polynomial over the considered collection of knots. Additionally, we ensure that the coefficients corresponding to a specific power will occupy the same position in the vector for all the considered knots. In case of a two-variable polynomial, such as the HOMFLYPT or Khovanov homology polynomial, the same procedure is used to obtain a coefficient matrix, which is subsequently flattened. The resulting coefficient vectors have 17 entries for Alexander, 51 for Jones, 152 for HOMFLYPT and 726 for the Khovanov homology polynomial. Knots are labeled using the knot ids from the Regina software [ 6 ] . 2.2. Random knot data In addition to organizing these datasets by crossing number, we augment with a collection of approximately 10,000 random knots, referred to in the rest of the paper as random data set. They are generated from random polygons of chain length 500, as introduced in [ 8 ] . These knots were simplified using REAPR: Fast Knot Diagram Simplification and Analysis by Jason Cantarella, Henrik Schumacher, and Clayton Shonkwiler, with Jones polynomials computed via Regina [ 6 ] . Approximately 1% of the knots had to be discarded due to aborted Jones polynomial computations. 2.3. Mapper-like algorithms Mapper and ball mapper are topological data analysis techniques used to visualize high dimensional complicated data. Since detailed description is provided in [ 14 ] we provide just a brief introduction to the tools focusing on ball mapper and its extensions. Given a collection of points X\subset\mathbb{R}^{n} and an \epsilon>0 , an epsilon net of X is a subset Y\subset X having the property that for every x\in X there exist y\in Y in a distance no greater than \epsilon form x . As a consequence, X\subset\bigcup_{y\in Y}B(y,\epsilon) , where B(y,\epsilon) denotes a ball of a radius \epsilon centered in y . Ball mapper is then defined as an abstract graph whose vertices correspond to points in Y . With a little abuse of notation, we will set V=Y , even though the ball mapper is not an embedded graph. The edges of ball mapper graph are placed between vertices y_{1},y_{2}\in Y if there exist a point x\in X with the property that d(x,y_{1})\leq\epsilon and d(x,y_{2})\leq\epsilon . In this case, point x is covered mutually by balls centered in y_{1} and y_{2} . Such a graph can be visualized using common libraries for graph visualization. When the points of X are additionally equipped with a function f:X\rightarrow\mathbb{R} , the values of the function can be lifted to vertices of the ball mapper. More precisely, the value of the vertex y\in Y is set to an aggregation, typically an average, of values of f for all points