A Data-driven Investigation of Euphemistic Language: Comparing the usage of “slave” and “servant” in 19th century US newspapers
Jaihyun Park, Ryan Cordell · 2025
Read A Data-driven Investigation of Euphemistic Language: Comparing the usage of “slave” and “servant” in 19th century US newspapers by Jaihyun Park, Ryan Cordell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-15057.txt.
Introduction
Jaihyun Park and Ryan Cordell present a 2025 study on softening language in nineteenth-century American newspapers. Both the words slave and servant were used for enslaved African Americans, but they carried different freight. The authors compare the two across the Chronicling America newspaper corpus with computational methods.
They handled printing errors with embedding tools and removed reprinted texts, a common habit of the era's papers. Neighboring words told the story. Slave clustered with legal, economic, and administrative terms. In Northern papers, servant clustered with religious words, while Southern papers tied it to home and family life. Slave-linked words traveled across regions, but servant-linked words stayed local. The study shows how papers built different discourses around enslavement.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jaihyun Park, Ryan Cordell |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-15057
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Data-driven Investigation of Euphemistic Language: Comparing the usage of “slave” and “servant” in 19th century US newspapers Jaihyun Park, Ryan Cordell Abstract Warning: This paper contains examples of offensive language targeting marginalized populations. This study investigates the usage of “slave” and “servant” in the 19th century US newspapers using computational methods. While both terms were used to refer to enslaved African Americans, they were used in distinct ways. In the Chronicling America corpus, we included possible OCR errors by using FastText embedding and excluded text reprints to consider text reprint culture in the 19th century. Word2vec embedding was used to find semantically close words to “slave” and “servant” and log-odds ratio was calculated to identify over-represented discourse words in the Southern and Northern newspapers. We found that “slave” is associated with socio-economic, legal, and administrative words, however, “servant” is linked to religious words in the Northern newspapers while Southern newspapers associated “servant” with domestic and familial words. We further found that slave discourse words in Southern newspapers are more prevalent in Northern newspapers while servant discourse words from each side are prevalent in their own region. This study contributes to the understanding of how newspapers created different discourses around enslaved African Americans in the 19th century US. 1 Introduction In the United States before the Civil War, free Black Americans and white abolitionists challenged the moral grounds of slavery using a range of means and media, from newspapers that exposed the horrors that enslaved people were subjected to in the American South, to first-hand accounts of former slaves recounting their suffering and their struggle for freedom, to fictional narratives that sought to levy readers’ sympathies toward Black Americans into advocacy against slavery. Pro-slavery advocates used the same media to undermine abolitionists’ charges and to defend slavery, arguing not simply for its necessity but for its rectitude, even its sanctity. Pro-slavery rhetoric often relied on a domestic, sentimental account of slaves’ lives that sidestepped the brutal realities of forced labor by focusing instead on supposed familial bonds between “house slaves” and the white women and children who owned them, the religious devotion advocates claimed slavery inculcated in enslaved African Americans, or the reported gratitude of slaves for their condition. Such myths underlay everything from newspaper editorials to pro-slavery novels, such as the “Anti-Tom” genre that arose to counter the popularity of Harriet Beecher Stowe’s bestseller, Uncle Tom’s Cabin . In works such as Uncle Robin in His Cabin in Virginia, And Top Without One in Boston — the central premise of which is outlined in the title — pro-slavery writers sought to contrast an idyllic depiction of Southern slavery — what they euphemistically termed “our peculiar institution” — with industrial horrors in the North. This research investigates this euphemistic rhetoric through an investigation of two closely linked but rhetorically contrasting terms in Civil War-era US newspapers: slave and servant. Both terms were used to refer to enslaved Black Americans, but they were employed in distinct ways. While the word “slave” engaged with the slave system directly, marking discourse about legal and political debates around slavery, “servant” was more often used euphemistically to identify enslaved people who could be more easily cast into the domestic, sentimental narratives espoused by pro-slavery advocates. The latter term can refer to different forms of servitude, including both enslaved workers in the American South and paid domestic help in Northern states, and its use in pro-slavery newspapers to describe enslaved Black Americans deliberately blurred those lines. Our goal is not to make claims about the lived experience of Black Americans during this period, but to understand the rhetorical constructions that communicated ideas about enslaved Black Americans to white newspaper readers. In newspaper writing, “slave” is a more generic word that is used to discuss both enslaved Black Americans, as well as to reference legal and political debates around the institution of slavery itself. “Servant” is a more specific term most often used to describe slaves who filled domestic — and less obviously abusive — roles in Southern homes. Servants were described as better-dressed and well fed, and typically lived in the attic or basement of their master’s house ( Malcolm, 1990 ) , where they ostensibly enjoyed a better quality of life ( Gatewood, 2000 ) . Any type of text published through newspapers could shape the discourse in the public sphere for editors and readers as newspapers played a role in constituting imagined communities in the 19th century ( Anderson, 2006 ) . Whether newspapers supported abolition or defended slavery, they nonetheless filtered their understanding of Black Americans through stereotypical filters, while typically excluding Black Americans themselves from their discourse 1 1 1 For more on Black-owned- and -operated newspapers, see The Black Newspaper and the Chosen Nation ( Fagan, 2016a ) . In another article “Chronicling White America,” Fagan describes how the collection processes for the Library of Congress’s Chronicling America collection have often excluded Black newspapers ( Fagan, 2016b ) . In part due to this facet of our data, our analyses focus on the stereotypical discourses about Black Americans within white newspapers - to include newspapers that were abolitionist in stance, but run and operated by white editors . In this paper, we present a computational approach to studying the use of these two terms in a corpus of 19th century newspapers and seek to answer two primary research questions: • RQ 1. What are the words that are most similar to “slave” and “servant” in the corpus of Southern and Northern newspapers? – RQ 1.1. How do the words that are most similar to “slave” and “servant” differ among the Northern newspapers and among the Southern newspapers? (Within-newspaper analysis) – RQ 1.2. How do the words that are most similar to “slave” and “servant” differ between the Southern newspapers and Northern newspapers? (Cross-newspaper analysis) • RQ 2. How prevalent are the discourse words from the Southern and Northern newspapers in the entire corpus? To support open science and transparent data science, we publish the code used in this study at https://github.com/park-jay/slavery-discourse . 2 Related Works Scholars of American history, literature, and culture have argued persuasively that while newspapers were not new in the 19th century, they were newly prevalent. Drawing on data from the Library of Congress’s US Newspaper Directory, US newspapers grew “from a few hundred papers in 1800 to over 12,000 by the end of the century.” Cordell et al. (2020) Beyond the simple scale of this shift, the variety, price, style, and intended audiences for newspapers shifted dramatically during this same period, such that the term “newspaper” suddenly encompassed a much wider range of periodicals than existed at the beginning of the century, including merchant papers, penny papers, illustrated family papers, and much more. This rapidly-growing medium was at the time both highly partisan and strident, as editors debated politicians and each other about political and social issues. The voice of newspapers in the 19th century was strongly affiliated with parties and particular political action groups, as modern ideas of journalistic impartiality did not evolve until the early 20th century ( Pasley, 2002 ) . Similarly, Baldasty (1992) argued newspapers during the antebellum period formed close ties with