Incorporating Sustainability in Electronics Design: Obstacles and Opportunities

Zachary Englhardt, Felix Hähnlein, Yuxuan Mei, Tong Lin, Connor Masahiro Sun, Zhihan Zhang, Shwetak Patel, Adriana Schulz, Vikram Iyer · 2025

Read Incorporating Sustainability in Electronics Design: Obstacles and Opportunities by Zachary Englhardt, Felix Hähnlein, Yuxuan Mei, Tong Lin, Connor Masahiro Sun, Zhihan Zhang, Shwetak Patel, Adriana Schulz, Vikram Iyer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14893.txt.

Introduction

Zachary Englhardt and co-authors published this interview study in 2025. Life cycle assessment can tally a gadget's environmental cost from factory to landfill. Whether those tallies actually shape how electronics get designed was unclear. The team interviewed seventeen industry professionals who work with such assessments or with electronics design. They coded the conversations systematically and drew out shared themes about how sustainability information flows, or stalls, inside companies.

Collecting the underlying data proved a central headache. Responsibility for greener choices was scattered across teams, and who pays for them was often ambiguous. Designers therefore made decisions with partial, late, or missing impact figures. The authors see room for computing tools that compute assessments faster and plug them directly into design software. Their analysis, though centered on electronics hardware, aims at any industry where impact data and design decisions live in separate rooms.

Catalog record

CREATORZachary Englhardt, Felix Hähnlein, Yuxuan Mei, Tong Lin, Connor Masahiro Sun, Zhihan Zhang, Shwetak Patel, Adriana Schulz, Vikram Iyer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14893

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Incorporating Sustainability in Electronics Design: Obstacles and Opportunities Zachary Englhardt, Felix Hähnlein, Yuxuan Mei, Tong Lin, Connor Masahiro Sun, Zhihan Zhang, Shwetak Patel, Adriana Schulz, Vikram Iyer Abstract . Life cycle assessment (LCA) is a methodology for holistically measuring the environmental impact of a product from initial manufacturing to end-of-life disposal. However, the extent to which LCA informs the design of computing devices remains unclear. To understand how this information is collected and applied, we interviewed 17 industry professionals with experience in LCA or electronics design, systematically coded the interviews, and investigated common themes. These themes highlight the challenge of LCA data collection and reveal distributed decision-making processes where responsibility for sustainable design choices—and their associated costs—is often ambiguous. Our analysis identifies opportunities for HCI technologies to support LCA computation and its integration into the design process to facilitate sustainability-oriented decision-making. While this work provides a nuanced discussion about sustainable design in the information and communication technologies (ICT) hardware industry, we hope our insights will also be valuable to other sectors. CCS: Applied computing Enterprise modeling CCS: Applied computing Industry and manufacturing CCS: Hardware Impact on the environment 1. Introduction The proliferation of computing into almost every aspect of modern life has led to substantial growth in its environmental impact (EI). Estimates show that the impact of computing is on par with the airline industry, accounting for up to 2.1-3.9% of global climate warming emissions today ( Freitag et al., 2021 ) and this impact is projected to double within the next decade ( Andrae and Edler, 2015 ) . While transitioning to clean energy sources is critical, this alone will not address the 50-80% of computing’s carbon emissions that come from their resource intensive manufacturing ( Gupta et al., 2022a ; Gupta et al., 2022b ; Lyu et al., 2023 ; Apple, 2023 ) . It will also not address the annual 62 million metric tons of electronic waste (e-waste) they produce at end of life ( for Training and Research, UNITAR ) . Considering many computing devices have lifetimes of a few years, it is imperative that we begin designing the next generation of sustainable devices now to achieve environmental goals such as net zero emissions set by many organizations for 2030 and beyond. Addressing sustainability in product development presents two interlinked challenges: accurately assessing environmental impact throughout a product’s life cycle and effectively incorporating these insights into the design process itself. This impact assessment is typically done through a comprehensive LCA. This process is both expensive and time-consuming. A sustainability expert traces each of the subcomponents in a device back to its raw materials and manufacturing energy inputs. The expert also assesses the device’s energy consumption during use and the impacts of its end-of-life disposal. While complete LCAs provide important, detailed insights, in electronics they are often used as reporting tools for retrospective analysis rather than informing actionable decisions during the design process. This area is ripe for exploration as a new avenue for the HCI community to advance sustainability by building systems that bridge the gap between complex LCA data and design decision-making. In this paper, we seek to understand the interplay between current LCA and product development practices, arming researchers with the necessary background to drive meaningful change. We conducted a series of semi-structured interviews with professionals who have hands-on experience in producing LCAs or in designing electronics, giving the CHI research community a window into how LCAs are currently conducted and are (or are not) used to inform design decisions, where the key challenges lie, and what opportunities exist for future work. In total, we interviewed 17 experts, including LCA engineers, chief scientists, CEOs of LCA firms, semiconductor manufacturers, consortium managers, firmware and electrical engineers, and program managers. Our analysis revealed several key themes, which we grouped into four categories: (1) the current LCA practices in the ICT sector; (2) the intersection of sustainability and product development; (3) navigating the product design and LCA ecosystem (4) incentive structures between stakeholders. We found that the design process is distributed across various domains of expertise, with environmental impact reporting often treated as a separate, external process that struggles to influence the core of product development. Moreover, it remains unclear who within the design and manufacturing pipeline should be responsible for making sustainable design decisions. We envision a future ecosystem of computational tools that addresses these challenges by accelerating the LCA process and presenting information about the environmental impact of computing devices in a format that is actionable for designers and other decision-makers . We observe that the CHI community is particularly well-positioned to study and develop innovative tools that support sustainable design practices, since both the LCA process and product development involve coordinating across a diverse range of stakeholders, including engineers, designers, sustainability analysts, fabrication experts, and a global supply chain. Developing new interaction paradigms for decision-makers and designers raises critical framing questions, such as identifying the users and their ecological context ( Bardzell and Bardzell, 2011 ) , examining power dynamics within the product development decision-making process, and bridging information gaps to produce and utilize insights gained from LCAs. In this work, we contribute (1) a series of interviews with LCA practitioners and engineers to provide insight into how LCAs are conducted in the ICT sector and the ways product designers interact with these reports, and (2) opportunities for future research into developing new methods and computational tools for both LCA practitioners and engineers. These opportunities could significantly enhance the integration of sustainability into the electronics design process, providing practical pathways for making informed, environmentally conscious decisions. We hope this paper will spark new research efforts and support the development of impactful systems that contribute to reducing the environmental footprint of electronics. 2. Related Work and Background This paper analyzes the challenges and opportunities associated with incorporating LCA methodologies into the electronics design process, taking inspiration from prior HCI works focusing on understanding the workflows of professional groups ( Khurana et al., 2021 ; Sterman et al., 2022 ; Laka et al., 2022 ) and electronics manufacturing ( Khurana and Hodges, 2020 ; Zhu and Kao, 2022 ) . We review relevant literature on sustainable HCI and electronic design tools for electronics. We then give a brief primer on LCA, an overview of the landscape of tools to support LCA in electronics, and situate our work in this context. 2.1. Sustainable HCI Sustainability has been a growing focus in HCI for over a decade ( Mencarini et al., 2024 ; Yan et al., 2023 ; Hansson et al., 2021 ) , with significant attention given to developing persuasive technologies to encourage sustainable behaviors and choices. These technologies generally seek to act as decision support tools or lifestyle intervention systems. A substantial body of work has explored creating tools to support sustainable choices by providing actionable environmental impact information in specific domains ( Ericsson, 2024 ) . Notable examples include climate conscious travel planners that highlight lower-emission routes ( Google, 2024 ) , sustainable shopping assistants ( Busheska and Busheska, 2024 ) , and carbon footprint calculators for food choices ( Emissions, 2024 ) . While these tools cannot replace comprehensive LCA studies, they seek to

Read the complete text