Study of event and particle selection effects on elliptic flow background at the isobar experiments based on AMPT model

Yu Wang, Hua Pei · 2025

Read Study of event and particle selection effects on elliptic flow background at the isobar experiments based on AMPT model by Yu Wang, Hua Pei (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14815.txt.

Introduction

Yu Wang and Hua Pei present a nuclear physics paper, published in 2025, on a subtle effect that can cloud a major experiment. The experiment hunts for the chiral magnetic effect in collisions of atomic nuclei, using pairs of charged particles. A background tied to elliptic flow, the oval pattern of particles flying out, can mimic the signal being sought.

Using a simulation model called AMPT, which has no magnetic field built in, the authors compare two collision systems used by the STAR experiment. They vary how events and particles are selected and how flow is defined, then watch how the background shifts. The goal is a cleaner way to separate a real signal from selection effects in the real data.

Catalog record

CREATORYu Wang, Hua Pei
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14815

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Study of event and particle selection effects on elliptic flow background at the isobar experiments based on AMPT model Yu Wang, Hua Pei Abstract Measurement of the Chiral Magnetic Effect (CME) has been a popular topic of high-energy nuclear physics in the last decade. The flow correlation γ \gamma between charged hadron pairs of the same and opposite charges and their difference Δ ​ γ \Delta\gamma were measured to separate the CME-driven signal from the collective flow background especially second-order elliptic v 2 v_{2} . The STAR experiment have stepped further to the isobar experiment to compare γ \gamma and Δ ​ γ \Delta\gamma between Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr [ 1 ] , which were theoretically expected to produce the same elliptic flow background but different CME signals. However, the measured flow backgrounds also differ between Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr , indicating more fine-tuning of RP and centrality definition necessary. This analysis applied the AMPT model [ 2 ] to simulate the same collision system and energy as the STAR isobar experiment. Since the AMPT model does not include magnetic field effects, we expect comparing its output between Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr collision systems can provide an insight of the possible bias of flow background definition, and help improve the measurement of CME signal in real experiments. Multiple combinations of centrality and flow definition were chosen to study how the v 2 v_{2} and their difference would be affected, especially by varying the particles selection of charge versus neutral properties and broadening (pseudo-)rapidity regions, while STAR CME work relied on charged-only particles at central rapidity. 1 Introduction For each high-energy nuclear collision, the magnetic field introduced by the original beam spectators will cause P and CP destruction of the left-handed particles in the QGP [ 3 ] via the electroweak interactions, and fluctuate event-by-event caused by fluctuation about proton positions [ 4 ] , leading to an imbalance in the number of right- and left-handed ( anti ) particles. If the magnetic field was sufficiently strong, a significant charge separation along the direction of the magnetic field happens – the CME [ 5 ] . To separate the CME-driven signal from the collective flow background especially second-order elliptic flow ( v_{2} ), one can measure the flow correlation \gamma between charged hadron pairs of the same and opposite charges, then evaluate their difference \Delta\gamma . Because the magnetic field was expected to be initially perpendicular to the reaction plane (RP) defined by beam axis and impact parameter, the " \gamma correlation [ 6 ] " was defined as \gamma_{\alpha\beta}=<cos(\phi_{\alpha}+\phi_{\beta}-2\Psi_{RP})> (1) \phi_{\alpha} and \phi_{\beta} are the azimuthal angles of particles pairs of interest, and the averaging <...> was performed over the pairs of particles and over events. Then the difference between the opposite-sign(OS) and same-sign(SS) \gamma correlation called \Delta\gamma was studied for the CME signal: \Delta\gamma=\gamma_{OS}-\gamma_{SS} (2) since it was sensitive to the preferential emission of positively and negatively charged particles at the opposite sides of the RP. In real experiments, \Psi_{RP} was measured via either the spectator plane (SP) or participant plane(PP), defined by particles at most forward or central rapidity respectively. Because the CME signal was usually weak relative to the collective flow background, the latter needs to be measured independently and accurately in relativistic heavy ion collisions, and various approaches have been applied to deal with the background [ 7 , 8 ] . The \gamma correlation from background was defined usually as the equation below [ 6 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] : \Delta\gamma_{bkgd}=\frac{4N_{res}}{\langle N_{trk}\rangle^{2}}<cos(\phi_{\alpha}-\phi_{\beta}-2\phi_{res})>v_{2,res} (3) The RHIC-STAR experiment proposed isobar run in 2018 with two collision systems: {}_{44}^{96}Ru+_{44}^{96}Ru and {}_{40}^{96}Zr+_{40}^{96}Zr . The strategy of two isobar species was to produce different signal but idential background, because Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr have the same number of nucleons but different numbers of protons. Ideally, those charged+neutral quantities such as multiplicity and elliptic flow influence in \Delta\gamma background, should be the same in the two systems. On the other hand, the difference of Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr systems in the number of initial charges carried by protons within approximately equal volume can propagate to the initial magnetic fields generated, and measurable via the normalized charge separation correlation – \Delta\gamma/v_{2} , removing those background due to resonance decay and local charge conservation. However, the STAR CME paper [ 1 ] showed the isobar ratio (Ru+Ru/Zr+Zr) of \Delta\gamma/v_{2} below unity, seemingly opposite to the initial expectation of larger CME in Ru+Ru for stronger magnetic field. It was then important to cross-check the flow background especially v_{2} for any possible bias, before applying their difference into the \Delta\gamma/v_{2} observable. Since v_{2} strongly dependent on the centrality and flow, and the measurements of latter both rely on their methods and particle selection, it became necessary to study in details the effect of different electrical properties, (pseudo-)rapidity acceptance, and p_{\mathrm{T}} thresholds on particles. Therefore, we proposed the following analysis in AMPT for such test, since it was more convenient to expand and vary all these selections in the model, without constraints in real detectors performance. The dependence found in AMPT, if any, could help removing possible bias in CME-signal searching at real experiments. The next sections were organized as following: Sec. 2 explains the AMPT setup, Sec. 3 lists the selection of particles generated by AMPT, and how the centrality and v_{2} were reconstructed to compare with STAR results, then Sec. 4 discusses how this analysis could help to expand the phase space in real experiments. 2 Methods 2.1 AMPT, A multi-phase transport model We used AMPT [ 2 , 13 ] model to generate about 2 million events for each Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr collision systems. Owing to no magnetic field effect in AMPT model, it was expected to produce pure flow-background induced \Delta\gamma\{\Psi_{SP}\} and \Delta\gamma\{\Psi_{PP}\} . The AMPT model in its string-melting scenario was setup, including four stages: initial condition, partial scattering, hadronization, and hadronic interactions. (1) The initial condition was the process in which two nuclei moving in opposite directions colliding and producing partons. It determines which nucleons will collide based on the positions of the nuclei and the size of the scattering cross section. These nucleons called participants generate partons and excitation strings, being simulated using Heavy-Ion Jet Interaction Generator (HIJING) [ 14 , 15 ] ), giving the parton phase space distribution via excited strings and mini-jet partons mechanism. (2) Then at the process of partial scattering, the generated partons and excitation strings continue to move and collide thus evolving the parton phase space distribution. Such evolution equations were simulated by the ZPC [ 16 ] model till freeze out, where the parton interactions include only two-body elastic scattering. (3) At the process of hadronization, the partons freeze into new hadrons through quark coalescence. (4) Finally, after hadronization, the hadrons undergo elastic and inelastic scattering again. AMPT simulates the inter-hadron transport processes by using the ART (A Relativistic Transport) model [ 17 , 18 ] . Those nucleons previously excluded from scattering participants, called spectators on the other hand, also join this hadron cascade process. The collision conditions of AMPT in this analysis were set up at \sqrt{s_{\mathrm{NN}}} = 200 GeV same as the STAR isobar runs Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr systems,

Read the complete text