Forcing, genericity, and CBERS
Filippo Calderoni, Dima Sinapova · 2025
Read Forcing, genericity, and CBERS by Filippo Calderoni, Dima Sinapova (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14811.txt.
Introduction
Filippo Calderoni and Dima Sinapova sort when two forced worlds count as the same kind of same, in a study from 2025. Forcing grows new sets by fair picks, filters that meet each dense ask. Two such growths can be set side by side; the ask is when that side-by-side is smooth, tame in the scale of same-kinds.
A pure shape trait, condensation, gives the full call: the growths whose same-kind is smooth are just those with it. That call then shows wild growths whose same-kind is not smooth. For Prikry growths, the same-kind proves fine in a strong sense, hyperfinite. Cohen growths get part calls in that dir. Shape, the pair shows, rules same.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Filippo Calderoni, Dima Sinapova |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14811
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Forcing, genericity, and CBERS Filippo Calderoni, Dima Sinapova Abstract . In this paper we continue the study of equivalence of generics filters started by Smythe in [ Smy22 ] . We fully characterize those forcing posets for which the corresponding equivalence of generics is smooth using the purely topological property of condensation. Next we leverage our characterization to show that there are non-homogeneous forcing for which equivalence of generics is not smooth. Then we prove hyperfiniteness in the case of Prikry forcing and some additional results addressing the problem whether generic equivalence for Cohen forcing is hyperfinite. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 03E15, 03E40 1. Introduction Let M a countable transitive model of a sufficient fragment of ZFC , and fix a partial order \mathbb{P} in M . We can define the Polish space \operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P}) of M -generic filters for \mathbb{P} . This space has a basis of clopen sets of the form N_{p}=\{G\in\operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P})\mid p\in G\} for all p\in\mathbb{P}\cap M . We say that two generic filters G,H\in\operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P}) are equivalent (in symbols, G\equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{P}}H ) if and only if they produce the same generic extension. I.e., we define G\equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{P}}H\qquad\iff\qquad M[G]=M[H]. The equivalence relation \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{P}} was first analyzed from the point of view of the Borel complexity theory by Smythe [ Smy22 ] . By the definability of the forcing relations, this is a countable Borel equivalence relation on the Polish space \operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P}) . (See [ Smy22 , Lemma 2.6] .) The case where \mathbb{P} is the Cohen forcing \mathbb{C} is particularly compelling, and it is motivated by a long-standing open problem in descriptive set theory. Recall that a Borel equivalence relation is hypefinite if is the increasing union of a sequence of Borel equivalence relations with finite equivalence classes. While [ Smy22 , Theorem 3.1] proves that \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{C}} is an increasing union of hyperfinite equivalence relations, it is unclear whether \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{C}} is hyperfinite. Therefore, the question whether \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{C}} is hyperfinite is a specific instance of the (increasing) union problem posed as early as [ DJK94 ] . And people have wondered whether \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{C}} constitutes a counterexample. (For a discussion about this, we refer the reader to [ Kec24 , Page 82] ). In addition to that, Smythe [ Smy22 , Question 1] asks to determine the Borel complexity of equivalence of generics for other forcings. In Section 3 we provide a new characterization of smoothness for \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{P}} . In Sections 4 we prove that \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{P}} is hyperfinite in the case of Prikry. In Section 5 we prove some additional results about genric equivalence and we discuss some equivalence relations closely related to \equiv^{\mathbb{C}}_{M} . We believe that these would be useful to address the problem of finding the Borel complexity of \equiv^{\mathbb{C}}_{M} and other forcing in the future. 2. Preliminaries 2.1. Forcing Recall that \mathbb{P} is weakly homogeneous if for all pairs of conditions q,r , there is an automorphism e\colon\mathbb{P}\rightarrow\mathbb{P} , such that e(q) is compatible with r . Note that this implies that there are generic filters G,H , such that q\in G,r\in H and V[H]=V[G] . Also, recall that if, on the other hand G and H are two generic filters for \mathbb{P} with V[H]=V[G] , and \overline{\mathbb{P}} is the Boolean completion of the poset, then there is an automorphism e\colon\overline{\mathbb{P}}\rightarrow\overline{\mathbb{P}} , such that e"G=H . Weak homogeneity can be used to detect non-smoothness in the following precise sense. Recall that a poset is atomless if and only if every condition has incompatible extensions. Theorem 2.1 (Smythe [ Smy22 , Theorem 2.12] ) . If \mathbb{P} is atomless and weakly homogeneous, then \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{P}} is not smooth. In fact, Smythe [ Smy22 , Lemma 2.11] proved that \mathbb{P} is weakly homogeneous if and only if the action of \Aut^{M}(\mathbb{P}) on \operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P}) is generically ergodic. In Proposition 3.4 below, we show that the sufficient condition in Theorem 2.1 is not necessary. We will say that \mathbb{P} is densely weakly homogeneous if for densely many p , \mathbb{P}_{\leq p} is weakly homogeneous (i.e., the poset \{q\in\mathbb{P}\mid q\leq p\} ). Clearly, weak homogeneity implies densely weak homogeneity. For an example of densely weakly homogeneous poset that is not weakly homogeneous, take a lottery sum of non isomorphic weakly homogeneous forcings. Recall that the lottery sum of a collection \{\mathbb{P}_{i}:i\in I\} of forcing posets is the poset \bigoplus_{i\in I}P_{i}\coloneqq\{\langle i,p\rangle:i\in I\text{ and }p\in\mathbb{P}_{i}\}\cup\{\mathbb{1}\} , ordered with \mathbb{1} weaker than everything else and \langle i,p\rangle\leq\langle j,q\rangle when i=j and p\leq_{\mathbb{P}_{i}}q . Then for all \langle i,p\rangle , the forcing below \langle i,p\rangle , the poset \mathbb{P}\downarrow{\langle i,p\rangle} is isomorphic to \mathbb{P}_{i}\downarrow p , which is just \mathbb{P}_{i} by homogeneity, and therefore weakly homogeneous, and so the full forcing is densely weakly homogeneous. On the other hand, since the \mathbb{P}_{i} ’s are no isomorphic, the full forcing is not weakly homogeneous 2.2. Countable Borel equivalence relations An equivalence relation E is countable if every E -class is countable. It is finite if every E -class is finite. Let X=2^{\mathbb{N}} . Then the eventual equality relation x\mathbin{E}_{0}y\quad\iff\quad\exists m\forall n\geq m(x_{n}=y_{n}). It is immediate that E_{0} is hyperfinite because E_{0}=\bigcup{i\in\mathbb{N}}F_{i} , where x\mathbin{F_{i}}y\iff x_{n}=y_{n} for all n\geq i . Clearly each F_{i} class has cardinality 2^{i} . Let \Gamma be a countable group with the discrete topology. If X is a Polish space and a\colon\Gamma\times X\to X is a continuous action of \Gamma on X we say that X is a Polish \Gamma -space . In which case, we denote by \mathcal{R}(\Gamma\curvearrowright X) the corresponding orbit equivalence relation. Given a Polish \Gamma -space X , a point x\in X is condensed if x is an accumulation point of its orbit. That is, for all open neighborhoods U of x , |U\cap[x]|\geq 2 . In the sequel, we make use of the following well-known fact. For a proof see e.g. [ CC24 , Proposition 2.2] . Fact 2.2 . Let X be a Polish \Gamma -space. The orbit equivalence relation \mathcal{R}(\Gamma\curvearrowright X) is not smooth if and only if there is a condensed point. 3. Characterization of smoothness The main goal in this section is to present a characterization of non-smoothness for \equiv_{M}^{\mathbb{P}} . (Theorem 3.3 below.) First we spell out condensation in the case when X is \operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P}) and \Gamma=\Aut^{M}(\mathbb{P}) . Recall that N_{p}=\{G\in\operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P})\mid p\in G\} . It is crucial for us that the set \{N_{p}\mid p\in\mathbb{P}\cap M\} is a basis for the space \operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P}) . (For the details see [ Smy22 , Lemma 2.3] .) Therefore we can refer to the basic (cl)open sets N_{p} , rather than referring to all open subset of the space. Definition 3.1 . An M -generic filter G\in\operatorname{Gen}(M,\mathbb{P}) is condensed if for all N_{p} with G\in N_{p} , there is H\neq G , such that M[H]=M[G] and H\in N_{p} . Definition 3.2 . Let \mathbb{P} be a forcing poset in M . For any p\in\mathbb{P} define the statement ( 1 ) as follows: (1) \text{For all $p^{\prime}\leq p$, there are incompatible $q,r\leq p^{\prime}$,}\\ \text{such that there exists distinct generic filters $G,H$,}\\ \text{such that $q\in G,r\in H$ and $V[H]=V[G]$\lx@text@rbrace.} In other words condition ( 1 ) says that we can find instances of homogeneity densely often below p . Clearly, densely weakly homogeneous implies (\dagger)_{p} for all p . We will show