AI-driven Uncertainty Quantification & Multi-Physics Approach to Evaluate Cladding Materials in a Microreactor

Alex Foutch, Kazuma Kobayashi, Ayodeji Alajo, Dinesh Kumar, Syed Bahauddin Alam · 2025

Read AI-driven Uncertainty Quantification & Multi-Physics Approach to Evaluate Cladding Materials in a Microreactor by Alex Foutch, Kazuma Kobayashi, Ayodeji Alajo, Dinesh Kumar, Syed Bahauddin Alam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14679.txt.

Introduction

Alex Foutch and co-authors test in 2025 four shell materials for a small, hot, sodium cooled reactor. The shells were first made to make light water reactors safer in a crash. Reuse in new designs could speed work and cut cost.

The team joins neutron, heat, and stress models to score each shell in one test frame. Heat tests favor a silicon based shell for steady heat load. A nickel alloy shell stands out for stress strength. Heat harms the other two shells more. A smart doubt check shows which trait swings drive peak stress the most.

Catalog record

CREATORAlex Foutch, Kazuma Kobayashi, Ayodeji Alajo, Dinesh Kumar, Syed Bahauddin Alam
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14679

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI-driven Uncertainty Quantification & Multi-Physics Approach to Evaluate Cladding Materials in a Microreactor Alex Foutch, Kazuma Kobayashi, Ayodeji Alajo, Dinesh Kumar, Syed Bahauddin Alam Abstract The pursuit of enhanced nuclear safety has spurred the development of accident-tolerant cladding (ATC) materials for light water reactors (LWRs). This study investigates the potential of repurposing these ATCs in advanced reactor designs, aiming to expedite material development and reduce costs. The research employs a multi-physics approach, encompassing neutronics, heat transfer, thermodynamics, and structural mechanics, to evaluate four candidate materials (Haynes 230, Zircaloy-4, FeCrAl, and SiC-SiC) within the context of a high-temperature, sodium-cooled microreactor, exemplified by the Kilopower design. While neutronic simulations revealed negligible power profile variations among the materials, finite element analyses highlighted the superior thermal stability of SiC-SiC and the favorable stress resistance of Haynes 230. The high-temperature environment significantly impacted material performance, particularly for Zircaloy-4 and FeCrAl, while SiC-SiC’s inherent properties limited its ability to withstand stress loads. Additionally, AI-driven uncertainty quantification and sensitivity analysis were conducted to assess the influence of material property variations on maximum hoop stress. The findings underscore the need for further research into high-temperature material properties to facilitate broader applicability of existing materials to advanced reactors. Haynes 230 is identified as the most promising candidate based on the evaluated criteria. 1 Introduction The 2011 Fukushima Daiichi disaster sparked a renewed focus on nuclear innovations for accident prevention, particularly targeting the materials used for uranium fuel and fuel rod claddings Almutairi et al. 2022 . These accident-tolerant fuels and claddings (ATFs and ATCs) are primarily being developed for light water reactors (LWRs) Terrani et al. 2018 . ATCs are engineered to resist oxidation, a critical feature in LWR accident scenarios where increased steam in the coolant system could otherwise accelerate heat generation and hasten core degradation of Nuclear Energy et al. . Yet, their benefits extend beyond oxidation resistance, offering additional advantages for accident tolerance that this paper explores. Zirconium-based claddings have been the main choice for uranium fuel pellets in LWRs since the 1950s Terrani et al. 2018 ; Alam et al. 2019a because of their low thermal neutron absorption cross section and resistance to corrosion. Their adoption in the nuclear industry expanded in the 1960s, establishing zirconium alloys as the preferred cladding material for LWRs globally. However, at high temperatures in water, zirconium alloys exhibit undesirable traits like increased corrosion and material degradation, limiting their in-core lifespan. Furthermore, in severe accidents, the self-accelerating exothermic steam-zirconium reaction at above approximately 1200°C is a major drawback, generating substantial heat and hydrogen gas Hofmann et al. 1999 ; Steinbrück et al. 2011 . The flammability of hydrogen can lead to explosions upon contact with hot surfaces (520-720°C) Hollnagel et al. 2013 . Hydrogen-initiated explosions due to steam-cladding reactions contributed to the Fukushima accident’s failure to build containment. This event prompted the industry to re-evaluate fuel and cladding designs for improved accident tolerance. As one of the most common Zr alloys, Zircaloy-4 was chosen for this paper. Although it is not designated an ATC, Zircaloy-4 will provide a baseline for the other candidates. Iron-based nuclear claddings have been used since 1951, where austenitic stainless steel was deployed in the Experimental Breeder Reactor I Terrani et al. 2018 . Survey tests of Fe-based alloys found the high-temperature oxidation resistance of FeCr, FeAl, and FeCrAl made them desirable. Of these, FeCrAl was chosen to move forward and has undergone significant testing. Normal operational and anticipated operational occurrence behavior are expected to be superior to Zr-based cladding, but based mainly on its enhanced oxidation resistance Terrani et al. 2018 . FeCrAl will be one of the candidate claddings. Silicon Carbide (SiC)’s use in the nuclear industry reaches far back, but high-strength fiber-reinforced composites (SiC-SiC, as opposed to bulk SiC) date to research in the 1970s. The technology for its production has improved since, and owing to its exceptional oxidation resistance, it is likewise deemed an ideal accident-tolerant cladding Terrani et al. 2018 . Its status as a ceramic also lends itself to different material behaviors from metals, which may prove noteworthy for this analysis. SiC-SiC will thus be another candidate cladding. Also, Haynes 230, the original choice for the heat pipes and ring clamps, will be included in the simulations as another baseline for Kilopower Reactor Using Stirling Technology (KRUSTY) benchmarking. Table 1: Candidate Cladding Material Properties Haynes 230 International et al. 2021 Zircaloy-4 Technologies SiC-SiC Koyanagi et al. 2018 ; NEI 2013 FeCrAl AB 2012 ; Field et al. 2017 Young’s Modulus ( GPa ) 159 99.3 240 135 Poisson’s Ratio 0.34 0.37 0.191 0.3 Thermal Expansion Coefficient ( 1/K ) 15.2e-6 6e-6 5.5e-6 13.4e-6 Thermal Conductivity ( W/m*K ) 24.4 21.5 68.85 22 Specific Heat Capacity ( J/kg*K ) 595 285 1200 710 Density ( kg/m^{3} ) 8970 6550 2700 7150 Melting / Subl. Point ( K ) 1574 2123 2700 1773 The oxidation resistance of these candidates will not be relevant to this analysis. Rather, it is their thermodynamic and mechanical behaviors that will be examined. The properties used for the four candidates are compiled in Table 1 . Also included is the melting point/sublimation point (for SiC-SiC), a common failure limit against which the candidates’ performance can be measured. Although not a candidate cladding, the maximum temperature of the U-8Mo (8 wt\% Mo/(U+Mo) ) fuel will be compared against its melting point, 1408 \rm K , as another performance metric Creasy 2011 . Variable\ Fraction=\frac{Maximum\ Measure\ of\ Variable}{Limit\ of\ Variable} (1) Figure 1: Yield strength (YS) or flexural strength (FS) for each candidate cladding Field et al. 2017 ; Xu et al. 2019 ; Geelhood et al. 2008 ; International et al. 2021 . Another failure limit, yield strength (YS) / flexural strength (FS) (for SiC-SiC), is plotted against temperature in Figure 1 . If temperatures exceed the limits of this data, the closest data point will simply be used (so 1800 K FeCrAl would use 30 MPa, the same as 1100 K FeCrAl). This failure analysis will be further elaborated on in Section 3.2 . The measurement for any failure limit will be their ‘fraction,’ Equation 1 , each named after the environment, component, and operating variable. For instance, a comparison of maximum fuel temperature and fuel melting point during NOC (Normal Operating Conditions) would be the ‘NOC fuel temperature fraction. Such new materials take long periods to be fabricated, tested and implemented. The landscape of nuclear power production is also changing with the advent of advanced and small modular reactor designs that are very different from existing LWRs. To save future development time on claddings for advanced / small modular reactors, this paper seeks to examine the performance of candidate ATCs in such an environment. Compared to LWRs, this will impact the temperatures, pressures, irradiation, and stresses experienced by cladding. This includes experiences at NOC and during a loss of coolant accident (LOCA). This will mainly measure the materials’ proximities to failure limits during simulation, comparing the candidates’ fractions of performance vs limit between each other and determining which is least likely to reach those limits (or which already exceeds them). A LOCA occurs when coolant is blocked or diverted and cannot flow through the reactor core.

Read the complete text