Energy-time and time-bin entanglement: past, present and future

Guilherme B. Xavier, Jan-Åke Larsson, Paolo Villoresi, Giuseppe Vallone, Adán Cabello · 2025

Read Energy-time and time-bin entanglement: past, present and future by Guilherme B. Xavier, Jan-Åke Larsson, Paolo Villoresi, Giuseppe Vallone, Adán Cabello (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14675.txt.

Introduction

Guilherme Xavier and co-authors review a pair of linked forms of quantum entanglement that rest on when a photon pair is born, and how that fact can be used. The first form was proposed in 1989, and a tweak of it gave the second, which now sits at the heart of many quantum link systems.

The review traces key tests through the 1990s and 2000s that stretched what could be done. Later tweaks opened a path to proof of entanglement that trusts no device, a goal for ultra secure links. The authors close with the place of both forms in the quantum networks to come.

Catalog record

CREATORGuilherme B. Xavier, Jan-Åke Larsson, Paolo Villoresi, Giuseppe Vallone, Adán Cabello
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14675

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Energy-time and time-bin entanglement: past, present and future Guilherme B. Xavier, Jan-Åke Larsson, Paolo Villoresi, Giuseppe Vallone, Adán Cabello Abstract Entanglement is a key resource in many quantum information tasks. From a fundamental perspective entanglement is at the forefront of major philosophical discussions advancing our understanding of nature. An experimental scheme was proposed in 1989 by Franson that exploited the unpredictability in the generation time of a photon pair in order to produce a then new form of quantum entanglement, known as energy-time entanglement . A later modification gave rise to the very popular time-bin entanglement , an important cornerstone in many real-world quantum communication applications. Both forms of entanglement have radically pushed forward our understanding of quantum mechanics throughout the 1990s and 2000s. A decade later modifications to the original proposals were proposed and demonstrated, which opens the path for the highly sought-after device-independence capability for entanglement certification, with a goal of ultra-secure quantum communication. In this review we cover the beginnings of energy-time and time-bin entanglement, many key experiments that expanded our understanding of what was achievable in quantum information experiments all the way down to modern demonstrations based on new technological advances. We will then point out to the future discussing the important place that energy-time and time-bin entanglement will have in upcoming quantum networks and novel protocols based on nonlocality. I Introduction Entanglement is widely considered to be the key feature of quantum mechanics having been referred to by Schrödinger himself as “ the characteristic trait of quantum mechanics” Schrödinger 1935 . It has represented the most intriguing aspects of nature being at the forefront of historical discussions Einstein et al. 1935 ; Bohr 1935 ; Bell 1964 that have pushed forward our understanding of the quantum domain. More recently, practical applications based on entanglement have emerged. For example, the remarkable connection between entanglement and remote and secure cryptographic key generation was discovered in 1991 Ekert 1991 , greatly pushing forward the field of quantum communication and information. Polarization entanglement has been for decades the workhorse of studies of foundations of quantum mechanics Freedman and Clauser 1972 ; Aspect et al. 1982 ; Weihs et al. 1998 ; Giustina et al. 2015 ; Shalm et al. 2015 and practical applications of quantum information Poppe et al. 2004 ; Ono et al. 2013 ; Yin et al. 2020 ; Schiansky et al. 2023 . In spite of its great success as a quantum information resource, the polarization degree-of-freedom has one main limitation which hinders its application in modern quantum information science: the fact that it is limited to encoding of two-dimensional systems (qubits). With the recent discovery of many tasks that are significantly enhanced by high-dimensional entanglement, the use of other degrees-of-freedom that can support high-dimensionality is a necessity Erhard et al. 2020 . Franson proposed a novel setup for generating and analyzing a radically different form of entanglement in 1989 Franson 1989 . It exploited the random nature in the generation time of a photon pair from the cascaded decay in a three-level atomic system, which was then analyzed by unbalanced Mach-Zehnder interferometers Jin et al. 2024a . The scheme was demonstrated already shortly afterwards Kwiat et al. 1990 ; Ou et al. 1990a and it quickly became the mainstay for long-distance Bell violation experiments during the 90s Tapster et al. 1994 ; Tittel et al. 1998a . At the time, these were the longest distance Bell inequality violations performed, and it showed the potential of quantum communications. In 1999, an important modification to the original Franson setup, which allowed precise time synchronization, was proposed and demonstrated Brendel et al. 1999 . Originally called pulsed energy-time entanglement, this was later referred to as time-bin entanglement, and it opened up the path for large increases in propagation distance Marcikic et al. 2004 . Apart from Bell tests and entanglement propagation, energy-time and time-bin entanglement were employed as a resource in many applications in quantum information such as entanglement-based quantum key distribution Ekert et al. 1992 and later its multi-user version Wen et al. 2022 , quantum random number generation Xu et al. 2016 , transferring quantum information between photons of different wavelengths Tanzilli et al. 2005 , used to construct hyper-entanglement Barreiro et al. 2005 , storage of entanglement onto quantum memories Clausen et al. 2011 , quantum teleportation van Houwelingen et al. 2006a entanglement swapping Sun et al. 2017a , cluster states for one-way quantum computing Reimer et al. 2019 , entanglement distillation Ecker et al. 2021 and quantum secret sharing Takesue and Inoue 2006 . In this review we will cover both energy-time and time-bin entanglement from their origins, go over many key experiments that have significantly advanced our knowledge of quantum communications and foundations of quantum mechanics, review the current state-of-the-art and give an outlook of the many open challenges as well as point important directions to pursue. II Energy-time entanglement and early experiments In 1964 a now well-known proposal to test the existence of local hidden variables was put forth by John Bell Bell 1964 , in which an inequality based on the assumptions of measurement, parameter and outcome independence could be tested in an experiment with correlated particles. Throughout the 70s and 80s experimental violations of Bell inequalities were carried out Freedman and Clauser 1972 ; Aspect et al. 1982 using polarization entanglement generated from atomic cascades. The completely new scheme proposed by Franson in 1989 instead uses entanglement generated from the uncertainty in the generation time of a photon pair (Fig. 1 a) Franson 1989 . It is based on a continuous laser beam, usually referred to as the pump with coherence time \tau , which passes through a non-linear (NL) medium having a small probability of generating a photon pair within a time uncertaintly equal to the same \tau (Fig. 1 b). The two photons, usually referred to as signal and idler are correlated in time and energy, due to the momentum and energy conservation in the non-linear process. Figure 1: Scheme for the generation and measurement of energy-time entanglement. a) Franson’s original proposal. Reproduced with permission from Franson 1989 Copyright (1989) American Physical Society. b) A continuous laser beam of coherence time \tau is fed to a non-linear (NL) process, having a small probability of creating a photon pair at a random time within this time \tau . Since the pair is correlated in energy (due to conservation in the NL process) and in creation time, this form of entanglement is referred to as energy-time. c) Unbalanced interferometers, often called Franson’s interferometers, are employed which superpose half of the arriving wavefunction joint amplitude probabilities erasing their time information, making these indistinguishable processes entangled. The other half of the coincident detection events can be distinguished in principle, due to the paths taken in the interferometers. These must be post-selected by the detection electronics in order to attain a Bell violation. The NL process produces entangled photons of the form \int{d\omega_{i}d\omega_{s}\phi(\omega_{i},\omega_{s})|\omega_{i}\rangle|\omega_{s}\rangle} , where \omega_{i} and \omega_{s} are the frequencies of the generated signal and idler photons, respectively, and \phi(\omega_{i},\omega_{s}) is the amplitude probability of generation of the photon pair at the specific generated photon frequencies, which is dependent on the NL

Read the complete text