Meson Mixing Bounds on Z ′ Z^{\prime} Mass in the Alignment Limit: Establishing the Phenomenological Viability of the 331 Model

Patricio Escalona †, João Paulo Pinheiro ‡, A. Doff §, C. A. de S. Pires † · 2025

Read Meson Mixing Bounds on Z ′ Z^{\prime} Mass in the Alignment Limit: Establishing the Phenomenological Viability of the 331 Model by Patricio Escalona †, João Paulo Pinheiro ‡, A. Doff §, C. A. de S. Pires † (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14653.txt.

Introduction

Patricio Escalona and three co-authors stress test a proposed extension of the Standard Model of particle physics, known as the 331 model, in this 2025 paper. The model adds a heavy new force carrier, the Z prime boson. Rare mixing between mesons, particles that briefly turn into their antimatter twins, sets strict limits on how light that boson can be.

The team shows the limits swing wildly with how the quark mixing pattern is chosen. In one pattern the bound drops to about six hundred gigaelectronvolts, a hundred times lower than older claims. In another pattern the same data force the mass far higher. They also check the model's Higgs alignment condition under each pattern. Careful choices, they argue, keep the model within reach of colliders.

Catalog record

CREATORPatricio Escalona †, João Paulo Pinheiro ‡, A. Doff §, C. A. de S. Pires †
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14653

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Meson Mixing Bounds on Z ′ Z^{\prime} Mass in the Alignment Limit: Establishing the Phenomenological Viability of the 331 Model Patricio Escalona †, João Paulo Pinheiro ‡, A. Doff §, C. A. de S. Pires † Abstract We perform a systematic study of flavor-changing neutral currents (FCNCs) in the 331 model with right-handed neutrinos (331RHNs), analyzing constraints on the Z ′ Z^{\prime} boson mass from K K -, D D -, B d B_{d} -, and B s B_{s} -meson oscillations. By explicitly incorporating scalar sector dynamics and quark rotation ambiguities ( V L u , d V_{L}^{u,d} ), we demonstrate that Z ′ Z^{\prime} mass limits depend critically on the parametrization of Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix factors. Three scenarios are explored: (i) V L u = V CKM † V_{L}^{u}=V_{\text{CKM}}^{\dagger} (FCNCs restricted to D D -mesons), (ii) V L d = V CKM V_{L}^{d}=V_{\text{CKM}} (dominant B s B_{s} constraints), and (iii) a hybrid mixing pattern. Strikingly, scenario i) reduces the Z ′ Z^{\prime} mass bound to M Z ′ ≳ 600 ​ GeV M_{Z^{\prime}}\gtrsim 600\;\text{GeV} at leading order and M Z ′ ≳ 473 ​ GeV M_{Z^{\prime}}\gtrsim 473\;\text{GeV} at next-to leading order—two orders of magnitude below literature values—by leveraging large experimental uncertainties in D D - D ¯ \bar{D} oscillations. Conversely, scenario ii) requires M Z ′ ≳ 165 ​ TeV M_{Z^{\prime}}\gtrsim 165\;\text{TeV} due to stringent B s B_{s} data. We further establish the alignment limit cos ⁡ ( ϕ + φ ) = 0 \cos(\phi+\varphi)=0 for the SM-like Higgs, showing its viability depends on V L u , d V_{L}^{u,d} configurations, with B s B_{s} systems enforcing | cos ⁡ ( ϕ + φ ) | < 0.01 |\cos(\phi+\varphi)|<0.01 in down-sector FCNC scenarios. Our analysis reveals that strategic choices of quark mixing matrices can suppress FCNC visibility, reconciling the 331 framework with flavor data without ultra-heavy Z ′ Z^{\prime} bosons. This work provides the first unified treatment of SM-like Higgs- and Z ′ Z^{\prime} -mediated FCNCs in 331 models, identifying viable parameter spaces for collider phenomenology. I Introduction The Glashow-Iliopoulos-Maiani (GIM) mechanism Glashow et al. 1970 suppresses Flavor-Changing Neutral Current (FCNC) processes in the Standard Model (SM). Due to this mechanism, these processes are absent at tree-level and highly suppressed at one-loop. This suppression arises from the unitarity of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix, making FCNC-sensitive observables like meson-antimeson oscillations ( K^{0} - \bar{K}^{0} , B^{0}_{s} - \bar{B}^{0}_{s} , etc.) exceptionally precise probes of physics beyond the SM (BSM). Experimental measurements of these oscillations, particularly in B_{s} - and K -meson systems Aaij et al. 2022 , align with SM predictions at the \mathcal{O}(1\%) level, leaving minimal room for new physics (NP) contributions. Consequently, BSM models must either replicate SM loop-level predictions or introduce mechanisms to evade these stringent constraints (see, e.g. Ref. Buras 2023 ). Among NP frameworks, 331 models Singer et al. 1980 ; Frampton 1992 ; Pisano and Pleitez 1992 ; Foot et al. 1994 ; Long 2024 —gauge extensions of the SM based on the SU(3)_{C}\times SU(3)_{L}\times U(1)_{X} symmetry—naturally incorporate tree-level FCNCs Montero et al. 1993 . Anomaly cancellation in these models requires non-universal quark family assignments: one generation transforms as an SU(3)_{L} triplet, while others are antitriplets. This asymmetry misaligns quark mass and interaction eigenstates, generating tree-level FCNCs mediated by a heavy Z^{\prime} boson Frampton 1992 ; Ng 1994 ; Liu and Ng 1994 ; Gomez Dumm et al. 1994 ; Pisano 1996 . Current limits on meson oscillations constrain the Z^{\prime} mass to multi-TeV scales (e.g., M_{Z^{\prime}}\gtrsim 1 – 100 TeV) Long and Van 1999 ; Martinez and Ochoa 2008 ; Buras et al. 2013 ; Cogollo et al. 2012 ; Queiroz et al. 2016 ; Okada et al. 2016 ; Cárcamo Hernández et al. 2023 ; de Jesus et al. 2024 ; Oliveira and de S. Pires 2023 ; Oliveira and de S. Pires 2023 ; Buras and De Fazio 2023 ; Buras 2023 ; Huitu et al. 2025 , highlighting the tension between 331 models and flavor data. However, existing studies predominantly focus on Z^{\prime} -mediated processes, neglecting the scalar sector’s role—a critical lapse given its inherent capacity to induce FCNCs. The scalar sector of 331 models, responsible for breaking SU(3)_{L}\times U(1)_{X} to the SM electroweak symmetry, includes multiple Higgs fields Foot et al. 1994 . These scalars not only generate fermion masses but also introduce flavor-violating Yukawa couplings due to the family-dependent SU(3)_{L} assignments. Crucially, the observed CKM matrix emerges as a product of the left-handed quark rotation matrices V_{\text{CKM}}=V_{L}^{u}(V_{L}^{d})^{\dagger} where V_{L}^{u,d} are unitary matrices that diagonalize the up- and down-type quark mass matrices, respectively. Unlike Z^{\prime} -mediated FCNCs, scalar-induced flavor transitions cannot be suppressed by simply increasing the mediator mass Cogollo et al. 2012 ; Okada et al. 2016 ; Oliveira and S. Pires 2023 : the scalar couplings are tied to quark masses and CKM parameters, while at least one of them should play the role of the SM Higgs, required to mimic the observed 125 GeV boson and inevitably acquires flavor-violating couplings, mediating processes like D^{0} - \bar{D}^{0} mixing via c\leftrightarrow u transitions. Such contributions scale as 1/m_{h}^{2} , conflicting with experimental bounds unless finely tuned. Conversely, as we will discuss in this paper, the extended scalar sector accommodates the alignment limit , albeit under conditions distinct from those in the conventional Two Higgs Doublet Model (2HDM) Branco et al. 2012 ; Gunion and Haber 2003 . For the first time in the literature, a detailed exploration of these modified conditions, along with their implications, will be presented in this work. Importantly, the structure of V_{L}^{u,d} —and their impact on V_{\text{CKM}} —plays a crucial role in determining the magnitude of FCNCs. By parameterizing these rotations, one can systematically explore how deviations from specific V_{L}^{u,d} configurations alter predictions for meson oscillations and, consequently, the inferred lower bounds on the Z^{\prime} mass. This work addresses this gap by analyzing the scalar sector’s impact on FCNC observables and its interplay with Z^{\prime} -mediated processes. We demonstrate that the interplay between V_{L}^{u,d} rotations and scalar/gauge couplings imposes bounds on the Z^{\prime} mass that depend critically on the parameterization of the quark mixing matrices. For instance, certain V_{L}^{u,d} configurations suppress Z^{\prime} -mediated contributions to B_{s} - \bar{B}_{s} mixing, relaxing M_{Z^{\prime}} constraints, while others exacerbate tensions with data. By scanning over viable V_{L}^{u,d} parametrizations, we determine the allowed upper and lower bounds on Z^{\prime} mass limits via meson oscillation observables. By scanning over viable V_{L}^{u,d} parametrizations, we identify the most stringent allowed bounds on the Z^{\prime} mass, reducing previous limits to \sim 600\;\text{GeV} at leading order (LO) (and \sim 473\;\text{GeV} at next-to leading order (NLO)) through optimized choices of the quark rotation matrices V_{L}^{u,d} . Notably, we establish the alignment limit in the scalar sector of the 331 model and demonstrate its explicit dependence on the V_{L}^{u,d} parametrization. While our study focuses on the variant where the third fermion family transforms distinctively under the gauge group, we emphasize that alternative 331 model variants—coupled with distinct V_{L}^{u,d} rotations—would yield different bounds on both the alignment limit and the Z^{\prime} mass. These results underscore the necessity of a comprehensive framework for 331 models, as scalar-sector dynamics and quark rotation ambiguities critically govern their viability against precision

Read the complete text