Content ARCs: Decentralized Content Rights in the Age of Generative AI
Kar Balan, Andrew Gilbert, John Collomosse · 2025
Read Content ARCs: Decentralized Content Rights in the Age of Generative AI by Kar Balan, Andrew Gilbert, John Collomosse (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14519.txt.
Introduction
Kar Balan, Andrew Gilbert, and John Collomosse put forward a plan for paying creators whose work trains AI systems. Their 2025 paper starts from the clash between artists who own work and firms that train models on vast data sets. The plan is called Content ARCs, short for authenticity, rights, and compensation.
The scheme joins proof of where a work came from, licences that can change over time, and credit for whose data was used. It also leans on open, shared record systems rather than one firm in charge. The authors map early licensing efforts onto their scheme. They end by naming the gaps that still block a full end-to-end system.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kar Balan, Andrew Gilbert, John Collomosse |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14519
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Content ARCs: Decentralized Content Rights in the Age of Generative AI Kar Balan, Andrew Gilbert, John Collomosse Abstract The rise of Generative AI (GenAI) has sparked significant debate over balancing the interests of creative rightsholders and AI developers. As GenAI models are trained on vast datasets that often include copyrighted material, questions around fair compensation and proper attribution have become increasingly urgent. To address these challenges, this paper proposes a framework called Content ARCs (Authenticity, Rights, Compensation). By combining open standards for provenance and dynamic licensing with data attribution, and decentralized technologies, Content ARCs create a mechanism for managing rights and compensating creators for using their work in AI training. We characterize several nascent works in the AI data licensing space within Content ARCs and identify where challenges remain to fully implement the end-to-end framework. Figure 1: Content Authenticity, Rights, and Compensation (ARCs) framework, illustrating how content provenance, identification, licensing, and creator identity enable downstream value generation. Green arrows indicate systems feeding into content provenance, while blue arrows feed into licensing. 1 Introduction Generative AI (GenAI) is transforming creative workflows through tools for efficiently generating and manipulating text, images, music, and video. However, the vast datasets used to train commercial GenAI models often include copyrighted material [ 1 ] , causing growing concerns among creative rightsholders about how their work is used and whether they will receive proper recognition and compensation. These concerns have recently surfaced in proposals—and counter-proposals—around changes to copyright legislation in several jurisdictions. The debate has become highly contested; for example, the recent UK copyright consultation [ 2 ] received over 11,000 submissions following a public awareness campaign by creative practitioners. Arguments often centre on the contentious issue of opt-in versus opt-out mechanisms; i.e. whether permission should always be sought to train commercial AI models on copyrighted data ( i.e. opt-in) or there should be a default legal right to train unless counter-indicated by a rightsholder ( i.e. opt-out). Rightsholders often argue that an opt-in model is essential to protect creators’ control over their work and ensure fair compensation [ 3 ] . While, AI developers often contend that an opt-out approach is necessary given the sheer scale of data (often many billions of assets) over which contractual consent and payment would need to be orchestrated [ 4 ] . Political factors also weigh on the debate, such as creating a competitive AI development environment versus jurisdictions with more permissive legislation or less stringent enforcement [ 5 ] . These positions are often deeply polarized and appear difficult to reconcile, highlighting the need for balanced solutions that uphold both creative rights and technological progress. In this paper, we contribute a framework to help resolve this deadlock by leveraging a combination of open standards and emerging data-centric technologies such as data attribution and distributed ledger technology (DLT). We present this as a meta-system design comprising of three core phases (ARC) applied to content: (A)uthenticity , (R)ights , (C)ompensation ; hereafter Content ARCs . Multiple technology choices exist for each phase, and we describe technical options for each. The motivation of Content ARCs is to provide an automated mechanism for clearing rights to, and compensating rightsholders for, the use of copyrighted data in GenAI training. In this way, concerns around the practicality of opt-in are alleviated through an interoperable machine-actionable protocol leveraging open standards. While this framework may not always be necessary—AI developers may own, or collectively license [ 6 ] , large datasets to support training—much of the data used for training GenAI models is drawn from the open internet or other fragmented sources where collective licensing is not feasible. In such cases, a scalable mechanism for licensing content from and returning value to individual rightsholders is essential to support large-scale AI development while ensuring fair compensation for creators. We also discuss legislative support that could benefit the adoption of Content ARCs in the creator economy. 2 Background Technologies to express creator preferences on AI training or processing are (a) site-based (location-level) or (b) unit-based (asset-level), each approach having strengths and limitations in scope and persistence across the content supply chain. Site-based methods allow a creator or content host to apply a blanket permission or restriction to assets on all or part of a website. For decades, the convention (RFC 9309) of parsing a file named ‘robots.txt’ on a server has served as a signal indicating which parts of a website are permitted to be scraped for search indexing. Since different crawlers can be (dis-)allowed per location, and AI training bots self-identify by name, the file can be readily applied for opt-out. Recently, the W3C has proposed a JSON-based variant (TDMRep) [ 7 ] , with language aligned to the EU 2019 Copyright Directive [ 8 ] , specifically Article 4, which describes an opt-out mechanism via the Text and Data Mining (TDM) exception. This use of the term ’Data Mining’ here is interpreted as a catch-all for any AI use, reflecting the tension between rapid technology advances and the pace of legislation, which, even in 2019, was too early to consider GenAI explicitly. Ultimately, both approaches allow for efficient expression of opt-in/out in bulk; however, as the signal is not embedded in the assets, it does not persist when content is copied, shared, or aggregated downstream. This limits its use in enforcing opt-in/out within the content supply chain, and there is no mechanism for specifying licensing arrangements for AI re-use. Unit-based methods allow creators to attach permissions and restrictions directly to individual assets by embedding machine-readable metadata within the file using standards for expressing opt-in/out. Several standards have emerged, ensuring interoperability for this task. The IPTC Photo metadata standard (2024.1) [ 9 ] includes a flag to indicate ’Data Mining’ opt-out, which, similar to TDMRep [ 9 ] , is a catch-all to indicate opt-out from any form of AI use. There is no opt-in flag, nor any implication to be drawn as to granting consent in the absence of the opt-out. Increasingly adopted is the C2PA (Coalition for Content Provenance and Authenticity) [ 10 ] metadata standard that can also be applied to assets of various modalities (e.g. image, video, audio, text) through embedding of XMP metadata within the file, or a side-car (accompanying linked file) if the format does not support metadata embedding. C2PA is primarily designed to communicate provenance information i.e. an audit history of how an asset is created and supports indication of opt-in/out consent within that audit trail. Furthermore, opt-in/out may be specified separately for granular AI uses ( e.g. training or inference) and for generative, non-generative AI, or non-AI analytics (data mining). The metadata is also cryptographically signed to create a non-repudiable, tamper-evident record attached to the asset. Content Identification . The persistence of unit-based metadata through the content supply chain is a challenge for emerging standards like C2PA that have not reached ubiquity in their adoption. Many content platforms (particularly social platforms commonly used to redistribute content) strip such metadata from assets. Therefore, retaining a copy of metadata (including opt-in/out preferences) within a registry is common, coupled with a content identification (Content ID) scheme for looking up that metadata. Examples include invisible watermarking techniques [ 11 , 12 ] that