Robust tests for log-logistic models based on minimum density power divergence estimators

Felipe, A, Jaenada, M, Miranda, P, Pardo, L · 2025

Read Robust tests for log-logistic models based on minimum density power divergence estimators by Felipe, A, Jaenada, M, Miranda, P, Pardo, L (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14447.txt.

Introduction

Felipe, Jaenada, Miranda and Pardo build robust tests for log-logistic models, in work from 2025. The log-logistic family is used in survival analysis, reliability and econometrics. Classic Wald and Rao tests for its parameters can be swayed by contaminated data, since the test statistics themselves lack robustness.

New Wald-type and Rao-type families rest on minimum density power divergence estimators, which are known to resist outliers. Formulas are derived for simple and composite null cases, and their properties are worked out in detail. A large simulation study shows that the new tests hold up under contamination and compares them with classical methods. The families generalize the older tests while adding their missing robustness.

Catalog record

CREATORFelipe, A, Jaenada, M, Miranda, P, Pardo, L
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14447

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Robust tests for log-logistic models based on minimum density power divergence estimators Felipe, A, Jaenada, M, Miranda, P, Pardo, L Abstract The log-logistic distribution is a versatile parametric family widely used across various applied fields, including survival analysis, reliability engineering, and econometrics. When estimating parameters of the log-logistic distribution, hypothesis testing is necessary to verify assumptions about these parameters. The Wald test and Rao test provide formal methods for testing hypotheses about these parameters. However, these test statistics are not robust, and their rejection decisions may be affected by data contamination. In this paper we develop new families of Wald-type test statistics and Rao-type test statistics based on minimum density power divergence estimators (MDPDEs) for the parameters of the log-logistic distribution. These new families generalize the Wald and Rao test statistics, inheriting the robustness properties from the MDPDEs and thus addressing the lack of robustness of the classical tests. Explicit expressions for the test statistics under the log-logistic model for both simple and composite null hypotheses are derived, and their properties are analyzed in detail. An extensive simulation study empirically demonstrates the robustness of these families and compares their performance with the classical methods. Keywords: Log-logistic distribution, minimum density power divergence estimator, Wald-type tests, Rao-type tests. 1 Introduction The log-logistic distribution is a continuous probability distribution commonly used in survival analysis, reliability engineering, and econometrics. Indeed, the Fisk distribution, a special case of the log-logistic family, is widely used in economics to model income distribution, wealth distribution, and price variations. The log-logistic distribution provides a flexible model for right-skewed data, which is common in economic studies where a small proportion of individuals or entities hold a large share of wealth or income. Further, the log-logistic distribution is also useful in modeling lifetime data, where the hazard function exhibits a non-monotonic shape, allowing for an initial increase followed by a decrease over time. The log-logistic distribution can be defined as the logarithmic transformation of a logistic distribution, similar to how the log-normal distribution is derived from a normal distribution (see Bain (1974) ). The probability density function (pdf) of the log-logistic distribution is given by f_{\alpha,\beta}(x)=\frac{\beta\alpha^{\beta}x^{\beta-1}}{\left(x^{\beta}+\alpha^{\beta}\right)^{2}},\text{ \qquad}x>0\text{ \ }(\alpha,\beta>0) (1) where \alpha>0 is a scale parameter and \beta>0 is a shape parameter. For the log-logistic distribution, the scale \alpha represents the median of the distribution. The distribution is unimodal for \beta>1. Therefore, the parameter space is restricted to \Theta=\left\{\left(\alpha,\beta\right)/\alpha,\beta>0\right\}=\mathbb{R}^{+}\times\mathbb{R}^{+}. Moreover, the log-logistic distribution is a special case of Burr’s type-XII distribution (see Burr (1942) ), and also a special case of the “Kappa distributions” (see Mielke and Johnson (1973) ) widely used in hydrology, meteorology, actuarial science. The log-logistic distribution’s properties and characteristics were first studied in Shah and Davel (1963) , where its flexibility and suitability for modeling right-skewed data was evidenced. For more detail about this distribution, we refer to the works of Tadikamalla and Johnson (1982) and Balakrishnan and Malik (1987) . Due to its strong suitability for modeling right-skewed data, it has been widely applied across various fields, including Hydrology, Economics, Survival, and Quality Control, among many others. For instance, Shoukri et al. (1988) applied the log-logistic distribution to model precipitation data from some Canadian areas. In Ashkar and Mahdi (2003) the superior fit of the log-logistic distribution compared to the lognormal, Weibull, and other extreme Type-I distributions for modeling maximum annual streamflow data was shown. Surendran and Tota-Maharaj (2015) considered the log-logistic distribution to model water demand data. Other interesting studies in hydrological analysis that apply the log-logistic distribution include the works of Cunnane (1989) ; Gunasekara and Cunnane (1992) ; Haktanir and Horlacher (1993) ; Rowinski et al. (2002) , and references therein. For Economics applications, we refer to Kleiber and Kotz (2003) and the original paper of Fisk Fisk (1961) , where it is shown that the log-logistic distribution is an appealing choice for modeling the distribution of wealth or income. Further, the log-log distribution has been widely applied in Survival Analysis to model for events in which the rate initially increases and then decreases, see e.g. the paper of Collet Collet (2003) where it is applied to cancer mortality after treatment. Finally, it is possible to develop control charts and the corresponding control limits based on log-logistic distribution the same way as Shewhart-charts, see Kantam et al. (2007) . Different estimation methods for the log-logistic distribution parameters, \alpha and \beta, have been considered in the literature. For example, Balakrishnan et al. (1987) developed BLUE (Best linear unbiased estimators) for both parameters. Kantam and Srinavasa (2002) studied the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) of the scale parameter \alpha for known shape parameter \beta, and ater, Chen (2006) studied the estimation of the shape parameter for known scale. From maximum likelihood theory, it can be seen that the MLEs of \alpha and \beta are given by the solution of the following system of the two equations \left\{\begin{array}[]{l}-\dfrac{n\beta}{\alpha}+\dfrac{2\beta}{\alpha}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\log x_{i}-2\sum_{i=1}^{n}\log\left(1+\left(\frac{x_{i}}{\alpha}\right)^{\beta}\right)=0\\ -\dfrac{n}{\beta}-n\log\alpha+\sum_{i=1}^{n}\log x_{i}-2\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(\frac{x_{i}}{\alpha}\right)^{\beta}\log\frac{x_{i}}{\alpha}\left(1+\left(\frac{x_{i}}{\alpha}\right)^{\beta}\right)^{-1}=0.\end{array}\right. Because no closed-form solution of the MLEs can be found, numerical methods such as the Newton-Raphson or quasi-Newton algorithms are needed to obtain approximated MLEs. Some available optimization methods to obtain the MLEs can be found e.g. in Press et al. (1986) ; Lange (1999) . In terms of efficiency, the asymptotic properties of the MLE are well established, as it is a Best Asymptotically Normal (BAN) estimator. However, it is also well-known that the MLE has two important drawbacks: It might be a biased estimator for small or moderate sample sizes, and it might be heavily affected by data contamination. To correct the bias on the estimation, several approaches have appeared in the literature, see e.g. Giles et al. (2013) ; Giles et al. (2016) Reath et al. (2018) ; Wang and Wang (2017) . This method reduces the bias of MLEs to the second order of magnitude by subtracting the estimated bias from the MLEs. On the other hand, regarding the lack of robustness, the use of minimum distance estimators based on the density power divergence (DPD) for the log-logistic distribution were proposed as a robust alternative to the MLE in Ma et al. (2023) and Felipe et al. () . The minimum density power divergence estimator (MDPDE) family generalizes the MLE by a tuning parameter \tau controlling the trade-off between efficiency and robustness on the estimation. Since the log-logistic distribution is widely used in different applied fields, defining statistical test statistics allow researchers to determine assess specific hypotheses related to lifetime characteristics, failure rates, and risk factors. In this paper, robust test statistics based on minimum distance estimator for the log-logistic parameters are developed. Particularly, the Rao test (also known as the Score test) and the Wald test are two fundamental statistical tests based on the MLE used for hypothesis testing in parametric models. They are flexible and allow testing a wide range of hypotheses related to model parameters. However, there is no definitive choice between the two, as both have proven to perform better in different applications depending on the context. In this work we aim to develop Wald and Rao-type test statistics based on the MDPDE, thereby extending the classical Wald and Rao tests to a broader family of statistics that remain resilient in the presence of outliers, and effectively addressing

Read the complete text