Comparison Between Cycle-to-Cycle Variations in the Coefficient of Joy’s Law and Covariance of Rotation Residuals and Meridional Motions of Sunspot Groups 2015 Comparison Between Cycle-to-Cycle Variations in the Coefficient of Joy’s Law and Covariance of Rotation Residuals and Meridional Motions of

J. Javaraiah · 2025

Read Comparison Between Cycle-to-Cycle Variations in the Coefficient of Joy’s Law and Covariance of Rotation Residuals and Meridional Motions of Sunspot Groups 2015 Comparison Between Cycle-to-Cycle Variations in the Coefficient of Joy’s Law and Covariance of Rotation Residuals and Meridional Motions of by J. Javaraiah (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-14236.txt.

Introduction

Sunspot groups lean: their tilt grows with latitude, a rule called Joy's law, thought to arise as the Sun's rotation twists rising magnetic tubes. Javaraiah analyzed in 2025 more than a century of sunspot records from Greenwich, Debrecen, and Mount Wilson observatories, tracking how the strength of Joy's law changes from solar cycle to cycle.

The slope of the law drifts on a roughly eight-cycle rhythm, the Gleissberg cycle. More telling, that slope correlates, in both hemispheres during cycles 16 to 21, with a second measure. It captures how groups' leftover rotation links to their drift toward or away from the poles, read tentatively as angular momentum transport. North–south differences in the two measures also track together. The author suggests the strength of Joy's law depends on how strongly the Sun's surface and depths move angular momentum poleward.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. Javaraiah
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-14236

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparison Between Cycle-to-Cycle Variations in the Coefficient of Joy’s Law and Covariance of Rotation Residuals and Meridional Motions of Sunspot Groups 2015 Comparison Between Cycle-to-Cycle Variations in the Coefficient of Joy’s Law and Covariance of Rotation Residuals and Meridional Motions of Sunspot Groups – References J. Javaraiah Abstract The tilts of bipolar magnetic regions are believed to be caused by the action of Coriolis force on rising magnetic flux tubes. Here we analysed the combined Greenwich and Debrecen observatories sunspot-group data during the period 1874 – 2017 and the tilt angles of sunspot groups measured at Mt. Wilson Observatory during the period 1917 – 1986 and Debrecen Observatory during the period 1994 – 2013. We find that there exists about 8-solar cycle (Gleissberg cycle) trend in the long-term variation of the slope of Joy’s law (increase of tilt angle with latitude). There exists a reasonably significant correlation between the slope/coefficient of Joy’s law and the slope (namely, residual covariance) of the linear relationship between the rotation residuals and meridional motions of sunspot groups in the northern hemisphere and also in the southern hemisphere during Solar Cycles 16 – 21. We also find that there exists a good correlation between north–south difference (asymmetry) in the coefficient of Joy’s law and that in the residual covariance. We consider the residual covariance represents tentatively the coefficient of angular momentum transport. These results suggest that there exists a relationship between the surface/subsurface poleward/equatorward angular momentum transport and the Joy’s law. There is a suggestion of the strength of the Joy’s law depends on the strength of the poleward angular momentum transport. 1 Introduction Ward 1965 analyzed Greenwich sunspot-group data during the period 1935 – 1944 and found a significant correlation between the angular and meridional velocities of sunspot groups and interpreted it as meridional flows transfer angular momentum toward equator. Later many scientists studied this correlation by using various data and methods ( Sudar et al. 2014 ; Sudar et al. 2017 ; Javaraiah 2021 , and references therein) . Theoretical models predicted this correlation as reflection of equatorial angular momentum transport caused by Reynolds stresses near the surface ( Gilman 1986 , e.g.) . Earlier, ( Javaraiah 2021 ) , we analysed the combined Greenwich and DPD sunspot-group data during the period 1874 – 2017 and studied solar cycle-to-cycle variation in the slope (namely, “residual covariance") of the linear relationship between the rotation residuals and meridional motions of sunspot groups in the Sun’s whole-sphere. In the present analysis we analysed the same sunspot-group data and determined the residual covariance and its solar cycle-to-cycle modulations in northern and southern hemispheres. The line joining the leading and following parts of an active region makes an angle to the parallel of the local latitude. This angle is referred to as tilt angle of the active region. Various dynamic characteristics of active regions seem to be depend on the tilt angles of active regions ( Howard 1991 ; Howard 1996c ) . The average tilt angle of active regions increases with latitude ( Hale et al. 1919 ) . It is referred to as Joy’s law and has been studied extensively ( Gao 2023 , for references see) . Recently, ( Javaraiah 2023 ) , we analysed Mt. Wilson Observatory (MWOB) sunspot-group data during the period 1917– 1986 and studied the solar cycle-to-cycle modulations in the coefficient of Joy’s law during Solar Cycles 15 – 21 in the whole-sphere and northern and southern hemispheres. The tilts of bipolar magnetic regions are believed to be caused by the action of Coriolis force on rising magnetic flux tubes. Coriolis force may be responsible for Joy’s law and hence the latter could be related to the equatorward/poleward angular momentum transport. In the present analysis, in order to check whether there exists a relationship between the cycle-to-cycle variations in the Joy’s law and the poleward/equatorward angular momentum transport, we determined correlation between the cycle-to-cycle variations in the coefficients of Joy’s law and residual covariance during Solar Cycles 15 – 21 determined from the whole-sphere data and the northern and southern hemispheres’ data separately. We consider the residual covariance as the coefficient of angular momentum transport. In the next section we describe the data and analysis. In Section 3 we describe the results and in Section 4 we present the conclusions and briefly discuss them. 2 Data Analysis 2.1 Determination of the "Residual Covariance" From Greenwich and DPD Sunspot-group Data Earlier, Javaraiah 2021 , we analysed the combined Greenwich Photoheliographic Results (GPR) and Debrecen Photoheliographic Data (DPD) of sunspot-group during 1874 – 2017. The solar sidereal angular velocity \omega (in degree day -1 ) was calculated as \omega(\theta)=\frac{L_{i}-L_{i-1}}{t_{i}-t_{i-1}}+14^{\circ}.18 , and the meridional velocity v_{mer} (in degree day -1 ) of the sunspot group was calculated as v_{mer}(\theta)=\frac{\lambda_{i}-\lambda_{i-1}}{t_{i}-t_{i-1}} , where L_{i-1} and L_{i} are heliographic longitudes, and \lambda_{i-1} and \lambda_{i} are heliographic latitudes of a sunspot group measured at times t_{i-1} and t_{i} during the life time (disk passage) of the sunspot group, \theta=\lambda_{i-1} , and 14^{\circ}.18 day -1 is the Carrington rigid body rotation rate. These daily values in each year during 1874 – 2017 were binned into different 5^{\circ} latitude intervals (0 – 5^{\circ} ), (5 – 10^{\circ} ),…,(35 – 40^{\circ} ) of the northern and southern hemispheres, and calculated the mean values of \langle\bar{\omega}\rangle(\lambda) and \langle\bar{v}_{mer}\rangle(\lambda) in each latitude interval in which the data were available, where \lambda is the middle value of a latitude interval (note that ‘ - ’ indicates mean over a latitude interval and ‘ \langle.\rangle ’ indicates mean over time, a year). Using the \langle\bar{\omega}\rangle(\lambda) of all the latitude intervals in all the years during the whole period 1874 – 2017 we obtained the grand differential rotation law, \langle\bar{\omega}\rangle(\lambda)=(14.5\pm 0.01)-(2.2\pm 0.07)\sin^{2}{\lambda} degree/day. For each latitude interval of a year we determined the residual rotation \Delta\langle\bar{\omega}_{rot}\rangle(\lambda)=\langle\bar{\omega}\rangle(\lambda)-\xi(\lambda) , where \xi(\lambda) is the value of \langle\bar{\omega}\rangle(\lambda) deduced from the differential rotation law. The \Delta\langle\bar{\omega}\rangle(\lambda) degree/day was converted into \Delta\langle\bar{v}_{rot}\rangle(\lambda) meter/second and the values of \langle\bar{v}_{mer}\rangle(\lambda) was also converted to the unit meter/second. The values of \Delta\langle\bar{v}_{rot}\rangle(\lambda) and \langle\bar{v}_{mer}\rangle(\lambda) of all the years of a solar cycle were fitted to the following linear equation: \langle\bar{v}_{mer}\rangle=D\Delta\langle\bar{v}_{rot}\rangle+C. (1) From this equation we have the following possibilities: When \langle\bar{v}_{rot}\rangle is a positive value, a positive/negative D mostly produces a positive/negative \langle\bar{v}_{mer}\rangle (poleward/equatorward motion). Obviously, it is opposite when \langle\bar{v}_{rot}\rangle is a negative value. That is, the slope D (namely, residual covariance) is a dimensionless quantity, its sign indicates the direction of angular momentum transport. Therefore, we consider that the slope D represents tentatively the coefficient of poleward/equatorward angular momentum transport. A negative/positive value of D indicates equatorward/poleward angular momentum transport ( Sudar et al. 2014 ; Sudar et al. 2017 , also see) . Note that the correlation between the two horizontal forces (the ‘covariance’), the rotational and meridional motions, may represent angular momentum transport toward equator by Reynolds stresses that is believed to be responsible for solar differential rotation. Numerical simulations by Brun 2004 suggest that the Maxwell tresses related to the magnetic fileds tend to oppose the Reynolds stresses causing poleward angular momentum transport. It may be also worth to note that sunspots exhibit both equatoward and poleward meridional motions

Read the complete text