Multi-wavelength Constraints on Dust Dynamics and Size Evolution in Protoplanetary Disk Rings. I. Method

Linhan Yang(杨林翰), Ya-Ping Li(李亚平), Ruobing Dong(董若冰), Kiyoaki Doi (土井聖明), Hauyu Baobab Liu(呂浩宇), Pinghui Huang(黄平辉) · 2025

Read Multi-wavelength Constraints on Dust Dynamics and Size Evolution in Protoplanetary Disk Rings. I. Method by Linhan Yang(杨林翰), Ya-Ping Li(李亚平), Ruobing Dong(董若冰), Kiyoaki Doi (土井聖明), Hauyu Baobab Liu(呂浩宇), Pinghui Huang(黄平辉) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-13818.txt.

Introduction

Linhan Yang and five co-authors present a 2025 astronomy paper on dust rings in planet-forming disks, the first in a series. Telescopes often see rings that look like dust traps at pressure bumps in the gas. Past models used one dust type in a steady drift state and skipped how grain sizes change by sticking and breaking.

Their simulations join dust-gas motion with size growth. They find that grains of all sizes up to the breaking limit share near the same spread in a ring, since growth beats drift. On that result, they build a self-consistent theory of ring structure that counts size change. The theory links the true dust layout to what telescopes see, and it sets up later work on real disks.

Catalog record

CREATORLinhan Yang(杨林翰), Ya-Ping Li(李亚平), Ruobing Dong(董若冰), Kiyoaki Doi (土井聖明), Hauyu Baobab Liu(呂浩宇), Pinghui Huang(黄平辉)
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-13818

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multi-wavelength Constraints on Dust Dynamics and Size Evolution in Protoplanetary Disk Rings. I. Method Linhan Yang(杨林翰), Ya-Ping Li(李亚平), Ruobing Dong(董若冰), Kiyoaki Doi (土井聖明), Hauyu Baobab Liu(呂浩宇), Pinghui Huang(黄平辉) Abstract Observations with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) and the Jansky Very Large Array (JVLA) have revealed many dust rings in protoplanetary disks, often interpreted as dust traps at gas pressure bumps. Previous studies have typically modeled these rings by assuming a single dust species in drift-diffusion equilibrium, neglecting dust size evolution resulting from coagulation and fragmentation. In this work, we perform numerical simulations that incorporate both dust-gas dynamics (drift and diffusion) and dust size evolution. Our results show that the radial distributions of different dust species (up to the fragmentation limit) are nearly identical in the dust ring, as dust growth dominates over drift and diffusion (e.g., with a typical dust-to-gas ratio of ϵ ∼ 10 − 2 \epsilon\sim 10^{-2} ). Building on this finding, we develop a comprehensive, self-consistent analytical theory that describes the dust ring structure while explicitly accounting for size evolution effects. Our model provides a unified framework for interpreting multi-wavelength observations by linking the physical dust distribution to the observed ring properties, thus laying the foundation for future observational modeling. I Introduction Planets are thought to form and evolve within the protoplanetary disks (PPDs). These disks are primarily composed of gas, with a small fraction of solid material in the form of dust, which constitutes the building blocks of planets [ 91 , 70 ] . The Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA), with its long-baseline configuration, has enabled high-resolution observations of these disks, revealing the widespread presence of dust substructures [ 1 ] . A prominent substructure observed in these disks is the concentric ring formation [ 2 , 4 , 61 , 3 , 87 ] . These rings, which are axisymmetric features in millimeter continuum maps, typically exhibit radial intensity profiles that can be approximated by a Gaussian distribution [ 35 , 84 , 16 ] : I\mathrm{{}_{ring}}(r)=I_{0}\exp{\left(-\frac{(r-r_{0})^{2}}{2w_{\mathrm{i}}^{2}}\right)}, (1) where the standard deviation w\mathrm{{}_{i}} is defined in this study as the observed width of the ring. Understanding these ringed substructures is of great significance, as they provide valuable insights into the physical processes governing dust evolution and gas-dust interactions within PPDs, thereby setting the initial stage for planet formation [ 83 , 47 ] . The prevailing theory attributes the observed rings to dust trapping, with the spatial distribution of grains evolving passively in response to gas dynamics [ 4 , for a recent review, see] . Other scenarios include the snow line [ 102 , 75 , 80 ] , dust-induced instabilities [ 38 ] and traffic jam effects [ 46 , 15 ] . This work focus on the dust-trapping model. In this scenario, a gas pressure bump, caused by either a temperature or surface density perturbation, is required, though the former tends to be unstable in the absence of a surface density component [ 19 ] . The latter can result from density perturbations induced by embedded planets (e.g., Lin & Papaloizou 58 , Bae et al. 5 , Dong et al. 32 , Dong et al. 31 , Li et al. 56 , Meru et al. 69 , Chen et al. 21 , see Paardekooper et al. 79 for a review) or other dynamical processes, such as magnetohydrodynamics zonal flows [ 6 , 48 , 49 , 24 ] , dead zones [ 65 , 57 ] , magnetized disk winds [ 90 , 82 ] , vertical shear instability [ 73 , 59 ] , the eccentric mode [ 63 , 54 ] , vortex-disk interactions [ 66 ] , and secular gravitational instability [ 99 , 92 ] . Within the pressure bump, drag forces arising from the velocity difference between dust and gas cause dust grains to drift toward the pressure maximum. Meanwhile, gas turbulence induces dust diffusion, broadening the ring. The drift-diffusion equilibrium for a single dust species (Eq. 16 ) is widely used to interpret ring widths measured at a single wavelength [ 84 , 16 , 35 ] . However, previous studies have largely neglected dust collisions, induced by gas turbulence, Brownian motion, differential settling, and other physical processes. These collisions play a critical role in dust evolution, leading to coagulation, fragmentation, erosion, and bouncing of dust aggregates [see 7 , for a recent review] . Moreover, in typical PPDs, dust collisions operate on the shortest timescales and dominate dust evolution. With the advent of multi-wavelength, high-resolution observations of PPDs [ 94 , 14 , 87 , 39 , 93 , 41 , 98 , 16 , e.g.,] , the brightness profiles of dust rings have been observed to vary across wavelengths [ 30 , 16 , 86 , e.g.,] . While the spectral energy distribution (SED) has been used to infer dust size distributions [ 12 , 51 , e.g.,] , which inherently reflect the outcomes of dust collisions, interpretations of ring width variations across multiple wavelengths have largely relied on the drift-diffusion equilibrium scenario [ 30 , e.g.,] , which neglects dust collisions. A comprehensive understanding of both spectral and spatial features requires integrating these approaches into a unified framework that self-consistently accounts for multi-species dust dynamics, including coagulation, fragmentation, diffusion, and drift. This integration presents a significant challenge, as it requires solving integro-differential equations governing dust evolution, typically through computationally intensive numerical simulations. Several studies have employed hydrodynamical models to investigate the coupled evolution of dust and gas, incorporating coagulation and fragmentation in PPDs [ 57 , 33 , 89 , 50 , 55 , 20 , 42 ] . However, the computational cost of such simulations scales exponentially with the number of free parameters, severely constraining the feasibility of extensive parameter studies and rendering exhaustive exploration impractical. To enable more efficient modeling of steady-state dust rings and to provide a robust tool to constrain dust properties from multi-wavelength observations of rings, we introduce a novel, fully self-consistent analytical framework for dust rings incorporating dust drift, diffusion, coagulation, and fragmentation. This theory is calibrated against numerical simulations. In a subsequent paper, we will apply this model to multi-wavelength observations of PPDs to constrain both dust and gas properties. The structure of this paper is as follows: Section II outlines the key dust physics. Sections III and IV present the numerical simulation setups and results, respectively. Section V develops the analytical framework for modeling dust ring dynamics, which could be applied in future observational modeling. Finally, Section VI summarizes our findings. II Dust Physics This section presents the fundamental physical processes that govern dust dynamics, coagulation, and fragmentation in PPDs, as illustrated in Figure 1 . We also introduce the characteristic timescales associated with these processes, which determine their relative importance in dust evolution. Lastly, we establish the notation system used throughout this study. II.1 Main Physical Processes Figure 1: Illustration of the primary physics around the pressure bump. Large pebbles, which drift efficiently, become trapped at the pressure maximum(upper), while small particles diffuse effectively and escape the trap(lower). Dust collisions facilitate interactions between these two populations. Large pebbles can fragment into smaller grains and diffuse away(left), while small grains can coagulate

Read the complete text