Consistencies and inconsistencies in redshift-independent distances

José Antonio Nájera, Harry Desmond · 2025

Read Consistencies and inconsistencies in redshift-independent distances by José Antonio Nájera, Harry Desmond (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-13658.txt.

Introduction

José Antonio Nájera and Harry Desmond ask in 2025 whether ways of measuring distance in space agree with each other. Such measures do not rely on redshift, and they support much work on galaxies. The authors build a test that checks measures of the same galaxy against each other, using a large NASA database.

Of the methods they could test, only a small share gave results that matched their own past work and the work of others. A few methods, such as those based on masers and some bright stars, did well. The authors also check Cepheid measures and find no hidden error there, while warning that many methods still need work.

Catalog record

CREATORJosé Antonio Nájera, Harry Desmond
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-13658

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Consistencies and inconsistencies in redshift-independent distances José Antonio Nájera, Harry Desmond Abstract Redshift-independent distances underpin much of astrophysics, and there exists a plethora of methods to estimate them. However, the extent to which the distances they imply are consistent, while crucial for the integrity of the distance ladder, has been little explored. We construct a statistical framework to assess both internal (between measurements with the same method) and external (between-method) consistency by comparing differences between distances to their quoted statistical uncertainties in the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database of Distances (NED-D). 66 of the 76 indicators in NED-D are amenable to a consistency test by having at least two measurements to the same galaxy or at least one measurement to a galaxy also measured by another method. We find that only 12 of these methods produce self-consistent distances across literature determinations, of which 7 are also consistent with distances to the same galaxies measured by all other methods. The most consistent 6 methods (M-stars luminosity, Novae, Masers, Globular Cluster Fundamental Plane, O- and B-type Supergiants and BL Lac Luminosity) also give similar average distances to the mean of all indicators, while the 7th (Proper Motion) underestimates distances relative to the mean by 17.1%. We also investigate consistency of Cepheid distances in the SH0ES 2022 catalogue, finding no evidence for unaccounted-for systematics. Our NED-D results imply that considerable work remains to obtain reliable distances by a multitude of methods, a crucial endeavour for constructing a multiply cross-checked and fully robust distance ladder. We make our code publicly available. 2025 Consistencies and inconsistencies in redshift-independent distances – 1 Introduction Much of modern cosmology depends on redshift-independent distances to astrophysical objects. Historically the first application of such distances was to combine with redshifts to produce a “Hubble diagram”, which provided the first evidence that the Universe is expanding ( Hubble, 1929 ) and that the expansion of the Universe is accelerating ( Riess et al., 1998 ; Perlmutter et al., 1999 ) . Hubble diagrams remain a crucial tool in cosmology today, providing precise constraints on parameter values and distinguishing between different gravitational and cosmological models (e.g. Li et al. 2021 ; Pourojaghi et al. 2022 ; Rezaei et al. 2022 ; Anton & Clifton 2024 ). This is particularly pertinent currently in the context of the “Hubble tension”, a claimed \sim 5 \sigma tension ( Riess et al., 2022 ) between the present-day expansion rate of the Universe, H_{0} , derived from the Hubble diagram versus inferred from the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) assuming the expansion history of the Universe implied by the standard model of cosmology, \Lambda CDM (for recent reviews see Freedman & Madore 2023 ; Riess & Breuval 2024 ). Even more recently, the Hubble diagrams of baryon acoustic oscillations and Type Ia supernovae (SNIa) appear to favour dynamical dark energy models over a cosmological constant for explaining the Universe’s accelerated expansion ( DESI Collaboration et al., 2024 ) . Assuming a cosmological model (e.g. \Lambda CDM) with calibrated values for its free parameters, distances in the Universe may be estimated from objects’ redshifts alone. However, within the local \sim 100 Mpc redshifts provide inaccurate distance estimates because galaxies’ velocities are not predominantly due to the expansion of the Universe. There is a significant contribution from “peculiar velocities”, galaxies’ individual motions superimposed on the Hubble flow generated by gravitational interaction with their cosmic environment (for reviews see Strauss & Willick 1995 ; Turner 2024 ). If distances to such galaxies can be measured redshift-independently then peculiar and expansion velocities can be determined separately. The pattern of peculiar velocities provides evidence concerning the large-scale structure of the local Universe ( Dupuy & Courtois, 2023 ; Valade et al., 2024 ) , the growth rate of cosmic structure ( Boruah et al., 2020 ; Said et al., 2020 ; Stiskalek et al., 2025 ) , extensions to General Relativity ( Lyall et al., 2023 ; Lyall et al., 2024 ) , the large-scale isotropy of the Universe (e.g. Feindt et al. 2013 ; Watkins et al. 2023 ) and the typicality or otherwise of the Milky Way’s place in the Universe ( Bovy et al., 2009 ; McMillan, 2016 ) . It also allows the distance–redshift relation to test, rather than assume, cosmological models. Given these many and varied opportunities, much effort has naturally been devoted to measuring redshift-independent (or direct) distances. This is done in a series of steps, likened to rungs of a ladder: direct geometric methods (mainly parallax) are used to establish distances to nearby objects (mainly stars within the Milky Way), which are in turn used to calibrate objects on the “first rung” of the distance ladder. The most common such objects are Cepheid stars—which obey a linear relation between their distance-independent pulsation period and distance-dependent luminosity (for reviews see Freedman & Madore 2024 ; Anderson 2024 )—and the Tip-of-the-Red-Giant-Branch (TRGB) feature of the colour–magnitude diagram, which has a fixed luminosity arising from the Helium flash in an electron-degenerate stellar core of intermediate-to-low-mass stars. Hence, it acts as a standard candle ( Lee et al. 1993 ; for a review see Li & Beaton 2024 ). Once calibrated, these methods can be used to establish direct distances to \sim 50 Mpc. They in turn are used to calibrate the ladder’s “second rung”. A key method here is SNIa which are standardisable candles: after correction for the colour and width of their light-curves they have a fixed luminosity, so that if this is calibrated using e.g. Cepheids or TRGB the measured flux determines the distance. This allows the Hubble diagram to be extended out to z\approx 1 ( \sim 3 Gpc; Brout et al. 2022 ; Rubin et al. 2023 ; Vincenzi et al. 2024 ). Parallax–Cepheid/TRGB–SNIa is the best-known route to the distance ladder, but there is in fact a plethora of methods for determining redshift-independent distances. Based on standard candle, standard ruler, standard siren and other techniques, these employ different objects, different physics, different measurement methods and different systematics, and operate at various locations of the ladder (i.e. requiring varying degrees of calibration). Given the crucial importance of the distance ladder for cosmology, and the tensions it has thrown up, it seems prudent to compare carefully as wide as possible a range of methods to assess possible systematic errors and with an eye to swapping out or supplementing some methods for others in constructing a maximally robust, precise and far-reaching ladder. That is the aim of this paper. We take as our starting point the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database of Distances (NED-D), 1 1 1 https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/Library/Distances/ a compilation containing > 270,000 extragalactic distances measured to > 140,000 galaxies using 76 different distance indicators ( Steer et al., 2016 ) . Our particular focus here is on quantifying the statistical consistency of distances measured to the same galaxies, either of multiple estimates with the same method (self-consistency) or between methods (cross-consistency). This depends crucially on the quoted uncertainties, which are themselves model-dependent quantities with their own uncertainties. We apply the same methods to the Supernova H_{0} for the Equation of State (SH0ES) pipeline as a leading example of distance ladder-based H_{0} inference framework ( Riess et al., 2009 ; Riess

Read the complete text