Is Crime Displacement Inevitable? Evidence from Police Crackdowns in Fortaleza, Brazil

José Raimundo Carvalho, Marcelino Guerra · 2025

Read Is Crime Displacement Inevitable? Evidence from Police Crackdowns in Fortaleza, Brazil by José Raimundo Carvalho, Marcelino Guerra (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-13571.txt.

Introduction

José Raimundo Carvalho and Marcelino Guerra ask whether police crackdowns just push crime elsewhere, using data from Fortaleza, Brazil, in a 2025 paper. The city ran 3,423 short, highly visible police blitzes in 2012 and 2013, each precisely logged. Fine-grained phone and GPS records let the team compare tiny areas hour by hour. They separated true deterrence from crime simply moving in space or time.

An average blitz cut violent crime nearby by about 35 percent. Extra hours in one spot bought less and less safety. Crime ticked up about six percent right after a blitz ended, but a deterrent glow lasted two to three days and canceled the rebound. No spillover appeared in blocks up to a kilometer and a half away. The authors say the tactic passes a first cost-benefit test.

Catalog record

CREATORJosé Raimundo Carvalho, Marcelino Guerra
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-13571

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Is Crime Displacement Inevitable? Evidence from Police Crackdowns in Fortaleza, Brazil José Raimundo Carvalho, Marcelino Guerra Abstract We evaluated one of the most common policing strategies in Brazil: the allocation of police blitzes. This place-based focused deterrence intervention has well-defined assignments, and 3,423 interventions were precisely recorded in Fortaleza-CE, Brazil, between 2012 and 2013. Our analysis takes advantage of the high spatiotemporal daily data resolution coming from an unprecedented longitudinal micro-Big Data (GPS and PING records) to make comparisons of small intervention areas, while controlling for common daily trends, deterrence (spatial and temporal), and diffusion; to show that an average police crackdown causes a 35% decrease in violent crime occurrences. There are diminishing returns of public safety to hours spent by police in a single area, corroborating what police officers know well from their own experience and discretionary behavior. Although crime increases by 6% immediately after the end of a blitz, we observe lasting deterrent effects (diffusion) after 2-3 days. The residual deterrence cancels the relocation of the crime, and the intervention does not generate significant temporal displacement. In addition, we do not find spatial displacement from crime in blocks up to 1.5 km from a blitz. This type of micropolicing tactics generates deterrence by being highly visible in a street segment for a short period and intermittently quasirandom in space-time, which produces uncertainty that might be crucial in minimizing the temporal and spatial displacement of crime. Of public policy interest, we show that the allocation of blitzes passes in an initial cost-benefit analysis. Key words : crime displacement, spillover effects, spatio-temporal models, and econometric evaluation JEL codes : K42, D62, C23, C54 1 Introduction and Background In the last three decades, Latin America has been described as an unsafe and violent region. This is the case, despite all the socioeconomic progress experienced by the region, see ?? \Hy@backout Chioda2017-wb). Throughout this time, cities in the region have consistently ranked among the 50 most violent places in the world, and by 2021, a total of 38 cities belong to the region 1 1 1 Indeed, in 2013, of the top 50 most violent cities in the world, 42 were in the region, including the top 16. . Not less than nine cities on this list are in Brazil, accounting for almost 20 percent of the 2021 ranking, ?? \Hy@backout Lista50). More specifically, Fortaleza (a large coastal city, the capital of the state of Ceará in northeastern Brazil) has consistently ranked on that list. The city is considered the “crown jewel” of transnational traffic routes to North Africa and Europe; and, as a consequence, Brazil’s two main gangs, the First Capital Command (Primeiro Comando da Capital – PCC) and the Red Command (Comando Vermelho - CV) have spent considerable efforts there in turf wars that profoundly transformed the landscapes of social, homicidal, and violence in the city. In fact, empirical studies have shown the role that gangs play in shaping crime rates in large cities of Latin America by promoting the diffusion of violent crimes, especially through the formation of social networks with the objective of killing members of rival gangs or controlling local drug markets; see ?? \Hy@backout De_Oliveira2019-vl), see ?? \Hy@backout SullivanGANGS2022) and ?? \Hy@backout BunkerSulivan2022) and the references therein. Not surprisingly, there is considerable interest among public policy makers in acquiring knowledge and expertise in the prevention of urban crime and violence. The local government police authorities are continually seeking to identify innovative interventions that can be implemented, managed, and assessed on a micro-urban scale. Since there is much more evidence that crime is responsive to police compared to alternatives such as attractive legitimate labor market opportunities or the severity of criminal sanction, see ?? \Hy@backout chalfin2017criminal); it is understandable that policing are gaining prominence these days. In fact, ?? \Hy@backout Weisburd2021-eu) points out that, today, innovative crime prevention programs tend to focus on high doses of deterrence in small areas or over short time periods, i.e., hot spot policing, pulling-levers policing, police crackdowns, community interventions via neighborhood policing or broken-windows policing. Such type of micro-policing focused deterrence can reduce violence in urban hot spots and is very welcomed as local governments face diminishing police resources resulting from tight city budgets and scarce federal money. However, these authorities are aware of the need to adopt only innovations whose impacts have been validated by rigorous research and empirical evidence brought about by scientific traditions like crime economics, especially those that are thoroughly framed on the preventive role of deterrence. Most of the crime economics and criminology research focuses on estimating the deterrent effect. Following ?? \Hy@backout becker1968crime) seminal work, which models criminal behavior as a cost-benefit calculus, the efforts of economists and criminologists were devoted to credibly establishing causality between crime and punishment, as well as incentives (positive or negative). The relevance of knowing the impact of treatments and interventions in crime for criminologists is epitomized by the voluminous and influential academic literature on what has been termed the ‘What Works’ movement, see ?? \Hy@backout Weisburd2017-nx). From a predominant narrative in crime prevention and rehabilitation that nothing works, nowadays Law & Order institutions have more than 40 years of theoretical, methodological and evaluative developments on ‘What Works’ to combat crime and disorder, broadly classified into the following tags ( ?? \Hy@backout Weisburd2017-nx)): developmental and social prevention, community interventions, situational prevention; policing, sentencing, correctional interventions and drug treatment and interventions. Although policing encompasses any police programs, training, interventions, or activities (for example, patrolling beats, police crackdown, police station allocation, police-monitored cameras, police body-worn cameras, etc.) that sought to impact crime and other police outcomes; our analysis here is focused on a specific type of policing strategy, commonly referred to as police crackdowns. Since policing often reacts to higher levels of crime, creative research designs have been used to avoid that endogeneity 2 2 2 As to economists contributions, see ?? \Hy@backout levitt1997using), ?? \Hy@backout levitt2002using), ?? \Hy@backout di2004police), ?? \Hy@backout klick2005using), ?? \Hy@backout evans2007cops), ?? \Hy@backout draca2011panic), and ?? \Hy@backout mello2019more), among others. Regarding the voluminous and seminal contributions of criminologists, see ?? \Hy@backout Kelling1974-cq), ?? \Hy@backout Sherman1984-mm), ?? \Hy@backout Sherman1995-ky), ?? \Hy@backout Taylor2011-fq), ?? \Hy@backout Braga2001-bm), ?? \Hy@backout piza2014saturation), ?? \Hy@backout Petersen2023-fb), ?? \Hy@backout Weisburd2023-wv), among many others. and show the causal effect of police on crime. However, these studies do not have a definitive opinion on what more police would exactly do on the streets to stop unlawful behavior beyond making arrests (see ?? \Hy@backout nagin2013deterrence)), nor on how such police interventions impact crime both spatially and temporally; supporting a rather pessimistic consensus about the likely impacts epitomized by ?? \Hy@backout Guerette2009-rh)’s say that “despite emerging evidence to the contrary, the prevailing sentiment seems to be that crime displacement is inevitable’. Relocation of crime across space and time due to changes in patrolling (displacement) is compatible with the rational approach toward deviance but has received less attention from the field. For example, offenders facing a higher probability of apprehension caused by police presence in one area may relocate their criminal activities to blocks farther away to avoid arrests or wait until cops are gone to commit a crime. According to ?? \Hy@backout Guerette2009-rh), displacement is the relocation of

Read the complete text