Tayler instability and dynamo action of cylindric magnetic rings
G. Rüdiger, M. Schultz · 2025
Read Tayler instability and dynamo action of cylindric magnetic rings by G. Rüdiger, M. Schultz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-13181.txt.
Introduction
Gunther Rudiger and Manfred Schultz study the Tayler instability of ring-shaped magnetic fields in rotating fluids. Azimuthal fields can go unstable and drive dynamo action in stars. The setup uses an endless Taylor-Couette flow with slow, planet-like spin.
Fields with one or two radial rings were compared. Without spin, uneven profiles destabilize fields the most. With spin, stability lines hinge on the magnetic Prandtl number. At one key value, ring and smooth profiles behave alike. The flows reach magnetic strengths of astrophysical interest. Wobble patterns create a weak alpha effect for dynamos. That effect flips sign between the cylinder walls always. The results inform models of stellar magnetism.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | G. Rüdiger, M. Schultz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-13181
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Tayler instability and dynamo action of cylindric magnetic rings G. Rüdiger, M. Schultz Abstract The Tayler instability of an azimuthal magnetic field with one or two “rings” along the radius is studied for an axially unbounded Taylor-Couette flow. The rotation law of the conducting fluid is a quasi-Keplerian one. Without rotation all toroidal fields are the more destabilized the more the radial profiles differ from the uniformity. For medium Reynolds numbers of rotation, however, the behaviour of the lines of neutral stability strongly depend on the magnetic Prandtl number. For Pm = 1 \rm{Pm}=1 the differential rotation matches the instability lines of azimuthal fields with and without rings so that the maximally possible Reynolds numbers for fields with smooth radial profiles and such with rings do hardly differ. The magnetic Mach number of the considered examples are of the astrophysically relevant order of magnitude, 10 < Mm < 20 10<\rm{Mm}<20 . The nonaxisymmetric instability fluctuations form a weak α \alpha effect of the mean-field electrodynamics which always changes its sign between the walls independent of the Reynolds number, magnetic Prandtl number or the radial profile of the magnetic background field. The resulting dynamo modes work on a similar axial scale as the Tayler instability, hence they are small-scale dynamos. The fields are axially drifting with high phase velocity where at certain periods the azimuthal fields with one-ring geometry develop to fields with two rings along the radius. It is still open whether and how a nonlinear dynamo model may overcome this puzzling complication. 1 Introduction One of the most challenging problems in astrophysical fluid dynamics is the investigation of the influence of the global rotation on the stability of toroidal magnetic fields. The condition \frac{{\rm d}}{{\rm d}R}(RB_{\phi}^{2})\leq 0 (1) is sufficient and necessary for stability of a stationary ideal magnetized fluid against nonaxisymmetric perturbations ( Tayler 1973 ) . As a consequence, one finds uniform or outwardly increasing magnetic fields unstable against nonaxisymmetric perturbations. This is in particular true for the toroidal field with B_{\phi}\propto R produced by uniform electric currents. The existence of the nonaxisymmetric instability for such a nonrotating ‘ z -pinch’ has experimentally been shown by Seilmayer et al. (2012) using liquid GaInSn as the conducting fluid penetrated by an axial electric current. Flows of the Chandrasekhar-type, where the background field and the background flow have identical isolines, are unstable against nonaxisymmetric perturbations if at least one of the diffusivities is non-zero. For \rm{Pm}\ll 1 the onset of the instability also scales with the Reynolds number and the Hartmann number, i.e. the neutral stability curves converge for \rm{Pm}\to 0 in the Hartmann number/Reynolds number plane. A prominent example of this class of magnetohydrodynamic flows is the axially unbounded rigidly rotating z -pinch exhibiting toroidal flows and fields which only vary with the distance R from the rotation axis ( Gellert et al. 2016 ) . However, for experimental and astrophysical applications of the instability theory the electric current will never be uniform (as it is necessary for the pinch-type solutions) or, with other words, the toroidal magnetic field profile will never be monotonously increasing. It will be more realistic to probe the stability/instability of toroidal fields having a maximum somewhere between the boundaries. For simplicity we shall only consider the maximum in the radial center of the gap. The ring is added to a quasi-uniform background field. Throughout the whole paper we have used a quasi-Keplerian rotation law where the cylinders´ rotation rates fulfill the Kepler law. We shall see that without rotation the toroidal fields with a ring-shaped structure are more unstable against nonaxisymmetric disturbances than a quasi-uniform toroidal field between the cylinders, see also Dikpati et al. (2009) for axisymmetric instability. This particular result does not depend on the magnetic Prandtl number. The opposite is true for models with differential rotation. Then the rings do not play an important role for magnetic Prandtl number unity but for small magnetic Prandtl number they do. Another interesting question concerns the construction of dynamos from the interaction of magnetic instabilities and differential rotation ( Spruit 2002 ) . This is indeed possible. Guseva et al. have shown dynamo action by numerical simulations of a quasi-Keplerian Taylor-Couette flow including a toroidal magnetic field which only depends on the radius in form of 1/R ( Guseva et al. 2017 ) . There is no axial large-scale current so that the field is stable without rotation. With differential rotation, however, this very simple system may become unstable against nonaxisymmetric perturbances for suitable choices of parameters, ( Rüdiger et al. 2014 ) . It is shown by simulations that toroidal field is maintained after switching off its external sources if \rm{Pm}=10 rather than for \rm{Pm}=1 . The axial scales of the field are similar to the radial scale of the Tayler cell, i.e. the gap width of the container, hence the dynamo is a small-scale dynamo. Magnetic energy slightly eceeds the kinetic energy as it is typical for AMRI simulations for \rm{Pm}\lower 3.01385pt\hbox{$\;\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\textstyle>}}{{\sim}}\;$}1 , see Rüdiger et al. (2018) . Also the numbers of the total torques \nu_{\rm T}/\nu= O(100) are very similar in the simulation of the dynamo and the azimuthal magnetorotational instability In a recent paper Tayler-Spruit dynamo simulations are prsented in a spherical shell filled with a fluid of \rm{Pm}=1 ( Petitdemange et al. 2024 ) . The differential rotation is due to the rotation differences \Delta{\it\Omega} of inner and outer spheres, where \Delta{\it\Omega}/{\it\Omega}=3\ \rm{E}\ \rm{Re} with fixed Ekman number \rm{E}= O( 10^{-5} ). The Reynolds number \rm{Re} is defined with \Delta{\it\Omega} rather then the more convential value {\it\Omega} . The fluid is stably density-stratified where the Rayleigh number \rm{Ra} directs the strength of the temperature gradient. The top panel of Fig. 3 of their paper, which presents simulations for \rm{Ra}=10^{7} and with the weakest stratification, may exhibit a dynamo solution with toroidal and poloidal fields of rather small scales. It is a dipolar solution with the azimuthal field component B_{\phi} only slightly exceeding the radial field B_{r} very similar to the result of numerical simulations of the (nonaxisymmetric modes) of the pinch instability without rotation ( Rüdiger et al. 2011 ) . If a dynamo exists with differential rotation then the ratio of the azimuthal and the radial field axisymmetric component should be basically larger than unity (see below). There are also numerical simulations about the Tayler instability in rotating spheres with positive shear (“superrotation”). For Ekman number \rm{E}=10^{-5} and magnetic Prandtl number \rm{Pm}=1 dynamo solutions have been found close to the inner tangent cylinder which are clearly small-scaled ( Barrère et al. 2023 ) . The pinch-type instability, however, is strongly suppressed by superrotation so that only fields with small magnetic Mach number \rm{Mm}<1 become unstable under the conditions of Taylor-Couette flows. A subcritical excitation of the nonaxisymmetric disturbances does only exist or \rm{Pm}\neq 1 ( Rüdiger et al. 2016 ) . Consequently, that the mentioned simulations provide an instability for superrotating fluids with \rm{Mm}\simeq 100 cannot be explained by consideration of simple Taylor-Couette flows. 2 Basic equations The geometrical quantities R , z and the wave numbers k are normalized with R_{0}=\sqrt{(R_{\rm out}-R_{\rm in})R_{\rm in}}, (2) the frequencies with {\it{\it\Omega}_{\rm in}} and the magnetic fieds with