Bitcoin Battle: Burning Bitcoin for Geopolitical Fun and Profit

Kris Oosthoek, Kelvin Lubbertsen, Georgios Smaragdakis · 2025

Read Bitcoin Battle: Burning Bitcoin for Geopolitical Fun and Profit by Kris Oosthoek, Kelvin Lubbertsen, Georgios Smaragdakis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-13052.txt.

Introduction

Kris Oosthoek, Kelvin Lubbertsen, and Georgios Smaragdakis trace Bitcoin that passed through Russian intelligence hands, in a 2025 paper. Addresses linked to those services moved over 7 Bitcoin, worth about 300,000 dollars at the time. Odd marks in the payment records caught the team's eye.

The marks suggest an outsider seized the private keys behind the addresses. Messages left in the records back that reading. Tracing the money backward led to mixing services that hide coin trails. The trail also links to Conti, a known Russian ransomware gang. The study is rare hard evidence of a state actor misusing Bitcoin at scale.

Catalog record

CREATORKris Oosthoek, Kelvin Lubbertsen, Georgios Smaragdakis
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-13052

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bitcoin Battle: Burning Bitcoin for Geopolitical Fun and Profit Kris Oosthoek, Kelvin Lubbertsen, Georgios Smaragdakis Abstract This study empirically analyzes the transaction activity of Bitcoin addresses linked to Russian intelligence services, which have liquidated over 7 Bitcoin (BTC), i.e., equivalent to approximately US$300,000 based on the exchange rate at the time. Our investigation begins with an observed anomaly in transaction outputs featuring the Bitcoin Script OP_RETURN operation code, tied to input addresses identified by cyber threat intelligence sources and court documents as belonging to Russian intelligence agencies. We explore how an unauthorized entity appears to have gained control of the associated private keys, with messages embedded in the OP_RETURN outputs confirming the seizure. Tracing the funds’ origins, we connect them to cryptocurrency mixers and establish a link to the Russian ransomware group Conti, implicating intelligence service involvement. This analysis represents one of the first empirical studies of large-scale Bitcoin misuse by nation-state cyber actors. I Introduction Bitcoin has emerged as a significant instrument of state power in cyber-conflicts, with state actors and their affiliates leveraging the cryptocurrency for strategic advantage. Multiple sources confirm that governments and associated entities exploit Bitcoin’s decentralized nature to circumvent traditional financial systems. For instance, media reports indicate that Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) has engaged in Bitcoin mining to mitigate the impact of international sanctions [ 1 ] and has utilized Bitcoin transactions to fund proxy groups in the Middle East, such as Hamas and Hezbollah [ 2 ] . North Korea has been involved in numerous hacks of cryptocurrency exchanges, amassing approximately US$3 billion over a six-year span [ 3 ] . In 2024, Russia legalized crypto mining [ 4 ] , employing it as a tool to sustain international trade amid economic sanctions [ 5 ] , and Russian ransomware groups have been linked to co-opting with intelligence services. The Conti group, which has generated US$300 million in ransomware profits, is reportedly connected to the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation (FSB) [ 6 ] . Likewise, members of Evil Corp, associated with tge LockBit and BitPaymer ransomware strains, have FSB links either through prior employment [ 7 ] or familial connections [ 8 ] . In addition to its use by adversarial states, Bitcoin has drawn the attention of the United States as a target for surveillance. Leaked documents reveal that, as early as 2013, the U.S. employed signals intelligence to track Bitcoin senders and receivers [ 9 ] . Conversely, Russia’s use of Bitcoin in cyber-espionage campaigns is also well-documented. During the 2016 hack of the Democratic National Committee, attackers linked to Russian intelligence leveraged Bitcoin to purchase servers and domains [ 10 ] . Similarly, in the SolarWinds supply-chain attack in 2020, alleged Russian state-sponsored actors used Bitcoin to purchase infrastructure [ 11 ] . In both instances, Bitcoin’s pseudonymity enabled these actors to obscure their operations, hindering law enforcement efforts to trace activities through traditional financial channels. However, academic work on nation-state actors’ use of cryptocurrency is limited compared to cybercriminal Bitcoin usage. Beyond analyzing financial transactions, which has become commonplace through blockchain analysis, investigating other blockchain events can yield interesting results. One of these is burning , which can manifest itself in three ways. First, Bitcoin (BTC) is forever lost, that is, burned, if a miner fails to claim the block reward in the coinbase transaction. Second, BTC is removed from circulation when sent to a non-existing address as it distorts the cryptographic rule in which each address is a public key controlled with a secret key. Third, a non-existing or fabricated address is essentially a public key for which no private key exists, making the BTC unspendable. Our analysis focuses on the third burn option named OP_RETURN an operation code (opcode) within the Bitcoin blockchain script to mark a transaction output as invalid. Also called nulldata field, it can add up to 80 bytes of arbitrary data to the transaction stored permanently on the blockchain. Sending to OP_RETURN creates an unspendable output, removing funds from circulation [ 12 ] . The OP_RETURN opcode was added to Bitcoin in March 2014 as part of the Bitcoin Core version 0.9.0 release [ 13 ] . It was originally introduced to provide a way for developers to store small amounts of data on the blockchain to minimize network impact and avoid known downsides of previous data storage methods in Bitcoin transactions. With its introduction, Bitcoin Core developers did not endorse storing data on the blockchain, as it would bloat the unspent transaction output (UTXO) database. Speculatively, this is why the feature was designed to render any amount of BTC unspendable when used. Technically, an OP_RETURN output with a zero value can be included in a larger transaction with multiple outputs. There is no requirement to attach a meaningful amount of satoshis (one one-hundred-millionth of a BTC, the smallest unit of account) to the OP_RETURN output, but it is used rarely; the mean value of BTC sent daily to OP_RETURN from January 1, 2023, until August 1, 2024, was 0.00805 BTC. OP_RETURN allows users to store small amounts of data on the Bitcoin blockchain, taking advantage of the irreversible and immutable nature of the blockchain. Once the data are included in a block, it becomes a permanent tamper-resistant record that is accessible to anyone inspecting the blockchain. As an example, El Salvador’s announcement of accepting Bitcoin [ 14 ] as legal tender was recorded on the blockchain using OP_RETURN. 1 1 1 Transaction hash: cb01ea705494ce66d7e5b7cb51bb5b39b8e8ce 31e168d1bd7dda253af359cc77 The introduction of Taproot in 2021 significantly improved Bitcoin’s scripting capabilities, allowing more efficient use of transaction space and greater data storage flexibility [ 15 ] . This inadvertently facilitated the creation of the Ordinals protocol, which uses Taproot’s expanded data storage features to inscribe arbitrary data, such as text or images, onto individual satoshis, without relying on OP_RETURN. Hence accounts of usage of OP_RETURN instructions are scarce, let alone coverage of their use in the context of nation-state actors’ cyber operations. The only coverage we are aware of is by Sophos and Google, which in 2020 [ 16 ] and 2022 [ 17 ] reported on malware being controlled through OP_RETURN outputs. In addition to analysis by cybersecurity firms, this is the first academic account of nation-state actors’ usage of OP_RETURN outputs in order to indefinitely burn a record amount of Bitcoin. The contributions of this paper are as follows: • We analyze the largest event of rendering BTC unspendable in the history of Bitcoin. • We characterize the events in a geopolitical and cyber context, linking them to cyber espionage. • We link wallets to cyber espionage, ransomware and hacking based on open and semi-open sources. • We analyze significant simultaneous activity in over 60,000 automated fractional payment transactions between these wallets. • We release 1,011 labeled wallet addresses to the community based on the analysis of this work [ 18 ] . The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. Section 2 provides an overview of the related work on the OP_RETURN instruction and exploits thereof. Section 3 provides an overview of Russian Cyber Operations. Section 4 describes the methodology of our analysis, including our initial findings. Section 5

Read the complete text