Disentangling the Power Dynamics in Participatory Data Physicalisation
Silvia Cazacu, Georgia Panagiotidou, Thérèse Steenberghen, Andrew Vande Moere · 2025
Read Disentangling the Power Dynamics in Participatory Data Physicalisation by Silvia Cazacu, Georgia Panagiotidou, Thérèse Steenberghen, Andrew Vande Moere (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-13018.txt.
Introduction
When stakeholders build a data display with their hands, power quietly decides whose meaning sticks. Silvia Cazacu and co-authors study in 2025 participatory data physicalisation, workshops where people jointly construct physical charts. They first forge an ontology from visualization and participatory design theory, naming the decisions where power hides, then apply it to twenty-three real artifacts.
Six recurring agendas emerge, from genuine sharing to extraction dressed as inclusion. The authors close with balancing practices: question how issues are framed, let participants speak in their own terms, and build in room to dissent. The work advances a feminist agenda for honest participation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Silvia Cazacu, Georgia Panagiotidou, Thérèse Steenberghen, Andrew Vande Moere |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 100 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-13018
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Disentangling the Power Dynamics in Participatory Data Physicalisation Silvia Cazacu, Georgia Panagiotidou, Thérèse Steenberghen, Andrew Vande Moere Abstract . Participatory data physicalisation (PDP) is recognised for its potential to support data-driven decisions among stakeholders who collaboratively construct physical elements into commonly insightful visualisations. Like all participatory processes, PDP is however influenced by underlying power dynamics that might lead to issues regarding extractive participation, marginalisation, or exclusion, among others. We first identified the decisions behind these power dynamics by developing an ontology that synthesises critical theoretical insights from both visualisation and participatory design research, which were then systematically applied unto a representative corpus of 23 PDP artefacts. By revealing how shared decisions are guided by different agendas, this paper presents three contributions: 1) a cross-disciplinary ontology that facilitates the systematic analysis of existing and novel PDP artefacts and processes; which leads to 2) six PDP agendas that reflect the key power dynamics in current PDP practice, revealing the diversity of orientations towards stakeholder participation in PDP practice; and 3) a set of critical considerations that should guide how power dynamics can be balanced, such as by reflecting on how issues are represented, data is contextualised, participants express their meanings, and how participants can dissent with flexible artefact construction. Consequently, this study advances a feminist research agenda by guiding researchers and practitioners in openly reflecting on and sharing responsibilities in data physicalisation and participatory data visualisation. Conference: CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 26-May 1, 2025; Yokohama, Japan CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI ’25), April 26-May 1, 2025, Yokohama, Japan DOI: 10.1145/3706598.3713703 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1394-1/25/04 CCS: Human-centered computing visualisation theory, concepts and paradigms CCS: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models Figure 1. By analysing a corpus of 23 PDP artefacts, we synthesised six agendas that highlight different orientations towards using PDP as a participatory method: Pedagogy , Action Research , Practice , Engagement , Exploration , Validation. Image credits belong to the respective authors. This teaser image showcases 23 PDP artefacts organised into six categories: Pedagogy, Action Research, Practice, Engagement, Exploration, and Validation. Pedagogy: Includes artefacts such as a physical toolkit with colourful components (1), a grid with coloured discs representing data points (2), and a LEGO-based model for data interaction (3). Action Research: Features hands manipulating various physical models—building blocks on a paper grid (4), glowing cubes floating on water at night (5), and interactive boxes with lights and tactile components (6). Practice: Displays interactive wearable devices, such as custom badge-making kits (7) and geometric models for organising data visually (8). Engagement: Visualises interactive installations where participants engage with physical representations of data, such as multi-coloured buttons and pins (9), acrylic shapes resembling leaves (10), and a coin-operated panel with visual data feedback (11-13). Exploration: Represents a diverse array of artefacts like a crocheted data visualisation (17), a map with small blocks placed on key points (18), and physical stacks that represent renewable energy usage (20). Validation: Highlights hands-on group interactions with physical tools and digital screens for validation of data points (21-23). † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Data physicalisation involves the construction of ‘a physical artefact whose geometry or material properties encode data’ ( Jansen et al., 2015 ) . Interacting with such a physical artefact enhances the cognitive understanding of data ( Jansen et al., 2013 ) , as an individual can more easily relate the physical affordances and interaction mechanisms ( Sauvé et al., 2022 ) into their personal experiences ( Bressa et al., 2022 ) . By embodying data in a way that is both relatable ( Zhao and Vande Moere, 2008 ) and aesthetically pleasing ( Hogan and Hornecker, 2017 ) , a data physicalisation can be experienced through multiple senses ( Hogan and Hornecker, 2012 ) , evoke enjoyment ( Hogan, 2018 ) , and even engage the body as a whole ( Hornecker et al., 2023 ) . For an individual, the process of constructing a data physicalisation can become a profound experience ( Huron et al., 2014b ) , as it allows them to explore and convey meanings that are otherwise challenging to measure or quantify ( Van Koningsbruggen et al., 2024 ) . This process not only fosters creative data exploration ( Bae et al., 2023 ) , but also empowers individuals to address personal needs ( Bae et al., 2022 ) , and express their concerns tangibly ( Thudt et al., 2018 ) . The natural affordances of data physicalisation enable individuals to integrate data in their daily life ( Bhargava and D’Ignazio, 2017 ) , empowering them to meaningfully participate in various complex data practices like data creation, data analysis, and data-driven decision-making ( Neff et al., 2017 ) . By bringing multiple individuals together to construct a shared artifact, data physicalisation also facilitates collaborative data practices. Through this shared construction process, individuals align their personal meanings into a collective, data-driven narrative ( Lockton et al., 2020 ) enabling discussions about their individual inputs with one another ( Sauvé et al., 2023 ) and fostering negotiations on how their personal meanings contribute to the group narrative ( Panagiotidou et al., 2023 ) . These collaborative aspects have allowed data physicalisation to address various civic issues by fostering participatory decision-making. For example, it has been used to combat environmental pollution ( Perovich et al., 2021 ) , promote health awareness ( Moretti and Mattozzi, 2020 ) , and investigate energy availability ( Daniel et al., 2019 ) . Such applications often take place through participatory activities, such as mental mapping workshops ( Panagiotidou et al., 2022 ) , where participants collectively visualise data related to their surroundings; or prototyping sessions ( Bae et al., 2023 ) where they build physical artefacts together. Several community engagement events ( Gourlet and Dassé, 2017 ) and community action initiatives ( Perovich et al., 2021 ) also leveraged data physicalisation as an inclusive data practice, enabling directly impacted stake-holders to engage with and make informed decisions about local challenges. Among the diverse stakeholders who already integrated physicalisation into their data practices are local communities ( Perovich et al., 2021 ) , schools ( Veldhuis et al., 2020 ; Bae et al., 2023 ) , non-profit organisations ( Panagiotidou et al., 2023 ) , and even local enterprises ( Lechelt et al., 2023 ) . These collaborative practices have been defined as participatory data physicalisation (PDP) - ‘a physical visualisation that allows a co-located audience to physically participate in the creation of the visualisation by directly encoding their data while following predetermined rules’ ( Sauvé et al., 2023 ) or ‘a collaborative physical representation of data by multiple people’ ( Panagiotidou and Vande Moere, 2022 ) . The participatory process of constructing a data physicalisation aligns with participatory design , as it similarly brings together multiple stakeholders in making decisions ( Halskov and Hansen, 2015 ) around developing a common solution for a fuzzy, yet meaningful, problem by way of creative ( Cross, 2011 ) and iterative prototyping ( Cross, 2006 ) . Participatory design (PD) is an established research discipline that aims to empower individuals to shape issues of their concern ( Bødker and Kyng, 2018 )