Evaluating and improving wave and non-wave stress parametrisations for oceanic flows
2025
Read Evaluating and improving wave and non-wave stress parametrisations for oceanic flows (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-12845.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Johnston, Callum Shakespeare, and Navid Constantinou review and test formulas for the drag that rough seafloor exerts on ocean currents, in a paper from 2025. The catalog record leaves the creator field blank; the text names the three authors. When currents cross hills and ridges, pressure gaps slow the flow and stir up internal waves. Global ocean models are too coarse to see those hills.
Stand-in formulas must add the missing drag, but each covers only part of the picture. Some suit tiny hills, others suit steady or pulsing flow, rarely both. The team ran hundreds of test flows over a single smooth hill in two and three dimensions. They scored the most used formulas against those runs. Where a formula missed, they used the data to draft a better one. The work seeds a fuller drag scheme for ocean models.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2025 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-12845
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evaluating and improving wave and non-wave stress parametrisations for oceanic flows Abstract Whenever oceanic currents flow over rough topography, there is an associated stress that acts to modify the flow. In the deep ocean, this stress is predominantly form drag, caused by the formation of internal waves and other baroclinic motions: processes that act on such small scales most global ocean models cannot resolve. Despite the need to incorporate this stress into ocean models, existing parametrisations are limited in their applicability. For instance, most parametrisations are only suitable for small-scale topography and are either for periodic or steady flows, but rarely a combination thereof. Here we summarise these existing parametrisations and evaluate their accuracy using hundreds of idealised two-dimensional and three-dimensional simulations spanning a wide parameter space. In cases where the parametrisations prove to be in inaccurate, we use our data to suggest improved formulations. Our results thus provide a basis for a comprehensive parameterisation of stress in ocean models where fine scale topography is unresolved. † † authors: Daniel R. Johnston, \aff a,b Callum J. Shakespeare, \aff b and Navid C. Constantinou, \aff c,d \statement As the ocean flows over topographic features it experiences a force. Such topographic features include abyssal hills that are too small to be accurately described by global ocean and climate models. These forces shape the ocean structure considerably and affect large-scale ocean circulation features, like the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation. Because there is no hope to accurately include these small-scale features in climate projections we need expressions (a.k.a. parametrisations) for the collective force they exert on the ocean. Here, we evaluate existing parametrisations for the force created when an oceanic current flows over an underwater hill by comparing them to the output of small-scale, high-resolution ocean simulations. Compared to previous studies, we cover a much wider range of cases. This allows us to suggest improvements to the existing parametrisations, taking us closer to the goal of developing a general and widely applicable mathematical description of this phenomenon. 1 Introduction In shallow seas, fast moving currents are subject to significant energy losses from frictional drag along the ocean bottom. However in the deep ocean, where currents are slower, there is still a significant amount of energy dissipation attributed to the formation of internal waves in regions of rough topography ( Ledwell et al. 2000 ; Egbert and Ray 2000 ; Egbert and Ray 2001 ; Naveira Garabato et al. 2013 ) . These waves can cause substantial mixing, which plays a role in nutrient transport and large scale ocean circulation ( Sandstrom and Elliott 1984 ; Munk and Wunsch 1998 ; Melet et al. 2013 ; Melet et al. 2014 ) . The horizontal extent of many oceanic topographical features is on the scale of 1-10\ \text{km} . In particular, over half of the ocean floor is covered by abyssal hills and mountains, defined respectively as having a variation in height of 300-1000 m and greater than 1000\ \text{m} ( Harris et al. 2014 ) . Resolving internal waves generated by such features is often not possible with current global ocean models ( Ansong et al. 2015 ; Kiss et al. 2020 , e.g.,) , which generally have horizontal resolutions on the order of 10 to 100 km. As a result, it is important to have parametrisations for the effects of internal waves that would be generated at such unresolved hills. Existing parametrisations have mainly focused on computing the energy flux extracted from the flow due to the generation of internal waves ( Llewellyn Smith and Young 2002 ; Khatiwala 2003 ; Perfect et al. 2020 ; Baker and Mashayek 2022 , e.g.,) . Such a focus is justified, as it has allowed better understanding of the contribution of internal waves to ocean mixing and tidal dissipation. There has however, been far less attention on parametrising the stress due to internal wave formation and other related effects such as blocking ( Winters and Armi 2014 , e.g.,) or bottom-trapped tides ( Falahat and Nycander 2015 , e.g.,) . Such parametrisations are vital to obtaining accurate representations of eddies and tides in global models ( Arbic et al. 2019 ) . Notably, the energy loss from a spatially mean flow \overline{\bm{u}} and topographic stress \bm{\tau} is equal to \overline{\bm{u}}\cdot\bm{\tau} , and the topographic stress also acts to modify \overline{\bm{u}} . Thus, the topographical stress is a more fundamental quantity to study, in that it can be used to compute energy loss, but this is not necessarily true the other way around. Due to the complexity of developing a generic parametrisation for stress, existing parametrisations ( Bell 1975 ; Jayne and St. Laurent 2001 ; Klymak et al. 2010 ; Shakespeare et al. 2020 , e.g.,) have focused on special cases. For instance, previous studies have treated steady and tidal flows in isolation. However, since the steady and tidal components of a flow can interact ( Shakespeare 2020 ) , it is important for existing parametrisations to be extended to mixed flows. Existing parametrisations also have several other assumptions that can reduce their accuracy if incorporated into ocean models. For example, it is often assumed that the topographical height is small ( Bell 1975 ; Shakespeare et al. 2020 ) or that the latitude is close to 0^{\circ} ( Jayne and St. Laurent 2001 ; Klymak et al. 2010 ) . The first goal of this paper is to evaluate the accuracy of existing wave and non-wave stress parametrisations. This is done by comparing theoretical expressions to a large suite of ocean simulations. To limit the scope of these comparisons, we focus on the case of an isolated Gaussian hill in either two or three dimensions. Working with isolated hills is useful as there are only a small number of parameters to consider, allowing us to ensure that the basic physics and scalings of the parametrisations are correct. This is in contrast to other studies (e.g. Jayne and St. Laurent 2001 ; Buijsman et al. 2015 ; Shakespeare et al. 2021 ) which tend to only test stress parametrisations with global models or more complicated topography. We also note that whilst three-dimensional simulations are physically accurate, they are more computationally expensive than two-dimensional simulations. Moreover, two-dimensional topography may be interpreted as approximating a section of a three-dimensional ridge, which can be sites of significant internal wave generation ( Ledwell et al. 2000 ; Garrett and Kunze 2007 ) . Two-dimensional simulations are thus useful despite being less applicable than three-dimensional models. As a result, our general procedure is to run a large number of tests in two dimensions, and then further analyse any interesting phenomena in three dimensions. The second goal of this paper is to then suggest improvements to these existing stress parametrisations. This is done using predominantly mathematical or physical arguments that are supported by the simulation data. Notably, one of the common shortcomings in existing parametrisations is the assumption of small topographical height. Large topographical features however, are abundant in the ocean ( Harris et al. 2014 ) . Moreover, large isolated hills called seamounts are of interest in ecology, vulcanology and ship navigation ( Clark et al. 2010 ; Watts 2019 ) .