Finite groups with dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups
Ryan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu · 2025
Read Finite groups with dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups by Ryan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-12302.txt.
Introduction
Ryan McCulloch and Marius Tărnăuceanu study finite groups in which a special family of subgroups is dense. Density here means that between any two subgroups in the full ordering of a group's subgroups, one can always find a member of the special family, called the Chermak-Delgado lattice. Their short note asks which finite groups have that property and describes the groups that do.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ryan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 9 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-12302
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Finite groups with dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups Ryan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu Abstract A group G G is said to have dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups if each non-empty open interval of the subgroup lattice L ( G ) L(G) contains a subgroup in the Chermak–Delgado lattice 𝒞𝒟 ( G ) {\cal CD}(G) . In this note, we study finite groups satisfying this property. MSC2000 : Primary 20D30; Secondary 20D60, 20D99. Key words : finite group, Chermak–Delgado lattice, subgroup lattice, density. 1 Introduction Let \mathcal{X} be a property pertaining to subgroups of a group. We say that a group G has dense \mathcal{X} -subgroups if for each pair (H,K) of subgroups of G such that H<K and H is not maximal in K , there exists a \mathcal{X} -subgroup X of G such that H<X<K . Groups with dense \mathcal{X} -subgroups have been studied for many properties \mathcal{X} : being a normal subgroup [ 9 ] , a pronormal subgroup [ 19 ] , a normal-by-finite subgroup [ 5 ] , a nearly normal subgroup [ 6 ] or a subnormal subgroup [ 7 ] . In our note, we will focus on the property of being a {\cal CD} -subgroup, that is a subgroup contained in the Chermak–Delgado lattice. Let G be a finite group and L(G) be the subgroup lattice of G . We recall that the Chermak–Delgado measure of a subgroup H of G is defined by m_{G}(H)=|H||C_{G}(H)|. Let m^{*}(G)={\rm max}\{m_{G}(H)\mid H\leq G\}\mbox{ and }{\cal CD}(G)=\{H\leq G\mid m_{G}(H)=m^{*}(G)\}. Then the set {\cal CD}(G) forms a modular, self-dual sublattice of L(G) , which is called the Chermak–Delgado lattice of G . It was first introduced by Chermak and Delgado [ 4 ] , and revisited by Isaacs [ 8 ] . In the last years there has been a growing interest in understanding this lattice (see e.g. [ 1 ] - [ 3 ] , [ 10 ] - [ 14 ] , [ 16 ] - [ 18 ] and [ 20 ] ). We also recall several important properties of the Chermak–Delgado measure: \bullet if H\leq G then m_{G}(H)\leq m_{G}(C_{G}(H)) , and if the measures are equal, then C_{G}(C_{G}(H))=H ; \bullet if H\in{\cal CD}(G) then C_{G}(H)\in{\cal CD}(G) and C_{G}(C_{G}(H))=H ; \bullet the maximal member M of {\cal CD}(G) is characteristic and satisfies {\cal CD}(M)={\cal CD}(G) ; \bullet the minimal member M(G) of {\cal CD}(G) (called the Chermak–Delgado subgroup of G ) is characteristic, abelian and contains Z(G) . Our main results are stated as follows. The first one gives some information about finite p -groups having dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Obviously, finite p -groups of order p satisfy this property. Theorem 1.1 . Let G be a finite p -group of order p^{n} , n\geq 2 , having dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Then: a) |Z(G)|=p and m^{*}(G)=p^{n+1} . b) All subgroups of order p^{2} of G contain Z(G) . Moreover, all normal subgroups of order p^{2} of G are contained in {\cal CD}(G) . c) {\rm Im}(m_{G})=\{p^{n},p^{n+1}\} . Theorem 1.1 shows that the finite p -groups with dense {\cal CD} -subgroups are a subclass of the class \cal C described in Section 3 of [ 17 ] . Note that all extraspecial p -groups belong to class \cal C , but only some of the extraspecial p -groups have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. For p odd, all extraspecial groups of order p^{3} have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups, and all extraspecial groups of order p^{k} , k\geq 5 , do not have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups (such groups have subgroups of order p^{2} that intersect the center trivially). For p=2 the situation is similar, except that one of the extraspecial groups of order 32 has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups and the other one does not. The second result classifies finite groups which are not p -groups, but have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Theorem 1.2 . Let G be a finite group with |\pi(G)|\geq 2 . The group G has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups if and only if G is a nonabelian group of order pq , where p and q are primes. Most of our notation is standard and will not be repeated here. Basic definitions and results on groups can be found in [ 8 ] . For subgroup lattice concepts we refer the reader to [ 15 ] . 2 Proofs of the main results Proof of Theorem 1.1. a) Let H\leq G with |H|=p^{2} . By hypothesis, there is K\in{\cal CD}(G) such that 1<K<H . Then |K|=p and since Z(G)\subseteq K , it follows that Z(G)=K . Thus |Z(G)|=p , Z(G)\in{\cal CD}(G) and m^{*}(G)=p^{n+1} . b) Since every subgroup of order p^{2} of G contains a {\cal CD} -subgroup of order p , we infer that it contains Z(G) . The second statement follows from Corollary 4.5.5 of [ 18 ] . c) Suppose H\leq G with |H|=p and H\neq Z(G) . Then there is K\in{\cal CD}(G) such that |K|=p^{2} and H\subset K . We get C_{G}(K)\subseteq C_{G}(H) and since C_{G}(K) is of order p^{n-1} , we obtain C_{G}(H)=C_{G}(K) . Thus m_{G}(H)=|H||C_{G}(H)|=p\cdot p^{n-1}=p^{n} . Now, suppose A\leq G with |A|\geq p^{2} and A\notin{\cal CD}(G) . Then there are B,C\in{\cal CD}(G) such that B\subset A\subset C and |A|/|B|=|C|/|A|=p . It follows that C_{G}(C)\subseteq C_{G}(A)\subseteq C_{G}(B) and |C_{G}(B)|/|C_{G}(C)|=p^{2} . We cannot have C_{G}(A)=C_{G}(B) because this implies m_{G}(A)>m^{*}(G) , a contradiction. Also, we cannot have |C_{G}(A)|=p|C_{G}(C)| because this implies A\in{\cal CD}(G) , a contradiction. So, C_{G}(A)=C_{G}(C) , which leads to m_{G}(A)=p^{n} . Finally, note that m_{G}(1)=|G|=p^{n} . Thus {\rm Im}(m_{G})=\{p^{n},p^{n+1}\} .∎ Proof of Theorem 1.2. If G is a nonabelian group of order pq , p and q primes, then 1<N<G where N is a normal subgroup of prime order, and {\cal CD}(G)=\{N\} , and thus G has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Conversely, suppose that G has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Let |G|=p_{1}^{n_{1}}\cdots p_{k}^{n_{k}} with k\geq 2 . If n_{i}=1 , \forall\,i=1,...,k , then G is a ZM-group and so its Chermak–Delgado lattice is a chain of length 0 by Theorem 3 of [ 12 ] . This satisfies the density property if and only if k=2 , that is, G is a nonabelian group of order p_{1}p_{2} . In what follows, we assume that n_{1}\geq 2 and let H_{1}\leq G with |H_{1}|=p_{1}^{2} . Then between 1 and H_{1} there is a subgroup K_{1}\in{\cal CD}(G) of order p_{1} . Since Z(G)\subseteq K_{1} , we have the following two cases: Case 1. Z(G)=K_{1} . Then n_{2}=\dots=n_{k}=1 and so |G|=p_{1}^{n_{1}}p_{2}\cdots p_{k} . Indeed, if n_{i}\geq 2 for some i=2,...,k , then there is K_{i}\in{\cal CD}(G) of order p_{i} . This implies Z(G)\subseteq K_{i} , that is K_{1}\subseteq K_{i} , which leads to p_{1}\mid p_{i} , a contradiction. Clearly, we can choose M_{1}\leq G with |M_{1}|=p_{1}^{n_{1}-1} and M_{1}\in{\cal CD}(G) . Now, subgroups in {\cal CD}(G) are permutable, and {\cal CD}(G) is closed under conjugation, and so the normal closure M_{1}^{G} is a p_{1} -subgroup. Now the quotient group G/M_{1}^{G} is a ZM-group and hence solvable, and M_{1}^{G} is a p_{1} -subgroup which is solvable, and so it follows that G is solvable. (Note: the solvability of a ZM-group can be proven as a consequence of Burnside’s normal complement