Finite groups with dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups

Ryan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu · 2025

Read Finite groups with dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups by Ryan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-12302.txt.

Introduction

Ryan McCulloch and Marius Tărnăuceanu study finite groups in which a special family of subgroups is dense. Density here means that between any two subgroups in the full ordering of a group's subgroups, one can always find a member of the special family, called the Chermak-Delgado lattice. Their short note asks which finite groups have that property and describes the groups that do.

Catalog record

CREATORRyan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE9 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-12302

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Finite groups with dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups Ryan McCulloch, Marius Tărnăuceanu Abstract A group G G is said to have dense 𝒞𝒟 {\cal CD} -subgroups if each non-empty open interval of the subgroup lattice L ⁡ ( G ) L(G) contains a subgroup in the Chermak–Delgado lattice 𝒞𝒟 ⁡ ( G ) {\cal CD}(G) . In this note, we study finite groups satisfying this property. MSC2000 : Primary 20D30; Secondary 20D60, 20D99. Key words : finite group, Chermak–Delgado lattice, subgroup lattice, density. 1 Introduction Let \mathcal{X} be a property pertaining to subgroups of a group. We say that a group G has dense \mathcal{X} -subgroups if for each pair (H,K) of subgroups of G such that H<K and H is not maximal in K , there exists a \mathcal{X} -subgroup X of G such that H<X<K . Groups with dense \mathcal{X} -subgroups have been studied for many properties \mathcal{X} : being a normal subgroup [ 9 ] , a pronormal subgroup [ 19 ] , a normal-by-finite subgroup [ 5 ] , a nearly normal subgroup [ 6 ] or a subnormal subgroup [ 7 ] . In our note, we will focus on the property of being a {\cal CD} -subgroup, that is a subgroup contained in the Chermak–Delgado lattice. Let G be a finite group and L(G) be the subgroup lattice of G . We recall that the Chermak–Delgado measure of a subgroup H of G is defined by m_{G}(H)=|H||C_{G}(H)|. Let m^{*}(G)={\rm max}\{m_{G}(H)\mid H\leq G\}\mbox{ and }{\cal CD}(G)=\{H\leq G\mid m_{G}(H)=m^{*}(G)\}. Then the set {\cal CD}(G) forms a modular, self-dual sublattice of L(G) , which is called the Chermak–Delgado lattice of G . It was first introduced by Chermak and Delgado [ 4 ] , and revisited by Isaacs [ 8 ] . In the last years there has been a growing interest in understanding this lattice (see e.g. [ 1 ] - [ 3 ] , [ 10 ] - [ 14 ] , [ 16 ] - [ 18 ] and [ 20 ] ). We also recall several important properties of the Chermak–Delgado measure: \bullet if H\leq G then m_{G}(H)\leq m_{G}(C_{G}(H)) , and if the measures are equal, then C_{G}(C_{G}(H))=H ; \bullet if H\in{\cal CD}(G) then C_{G}(H)\in{\cal CD}(G) and C_{G}(C_{G}(H))=H ; \bullet the maximal member M of {\cal CD}(G) is characteristic and satisfies {\cal CD}(M)={\cal CD}(G) ; \bullet the minimal member M(G) of {\cal CD}(G) (called the Chermak–Delgado subgroup of G ) is characteristic, abelian and contains Z(G) . Our main results are stated as follows. The first one gives some information about finite p -groups having dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Obviously, finite p -groups of order p satisfy this property. Theorem 1.1 . Let G be a finite p -group of order p^{n} , n\geq 2 , having dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Then: a) |Z(G)|=p and m^{*}(G)=p^{n+1} . b) All subgroups of order p^{2} of G contain Z(G) . Moreover, all normal subgroups of order p^{2} of G are contained in {\cal CD}(G) . c) {\rm Im}(m_{G})=\{p^{n},p^{n+1}\} . Theorem 1.1 shows that the finite p -groups with dense {\cal CD} -subgroups are a subclass of the class \cal C described in Section 3 of [ 17 ] . Note that all extraspecial p -groups belong to class \cal C , but only some of the extraspecial p -groups have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. For p odd, all extraspecial groups of order p^{3} have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups, and all extraspecial groups of order p^{k} , k\geq 5 , do not have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups (such groups have subgroups of order p^{2} that intersect the center trivially). For p=2 the situation is similar, except that one of the extraspecial groups of order 32 has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups and the other one does not. The second result classifies finite groups which are not p -groups, but have dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Theorem 1.2 . Let G be a finite group with |\pi(G)|\geq 2 . The group G has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups if and only if G is a nonabelian group of order pq , where p and q are primes. Most of our notation is standard and will not be repeated here. Basic definitions and results on groups can be found in [ 8 ] . For subgroup lattice concepts we refer the reader to [ 15 ] . 2 Proofs of the main results Proof of Theorem 1.1. a) Let H\leq G with |H|=p^{2} . By hypothesis, there is K\in{\cal CD}(G) such that 1<K<H . Then |K|=p and since Z(G)\subseteq K , it follows that Z(G)=K . Thus |Z(G)|=p , Z(G)\in{\cal CD}(G) and m^{*}(G)=p^{n+1} . b) Since every subgroup of order p^{2} of G contains a {\cal CD} -subgroup of order p , we infer that it contains Z(G) . The second statement follows from Corollary 4.5.5 of [ 18 ] . c) Suppose H\leq G with |H|=p and H\neq Z(G) . Then there is K\in{\cal CD}(G) such that |K|=p^{2} and H\subset K . We get C_{G}(K)\subseteq C_{G}(H) and since C_{G}(K) is of order p^{n-1} , we obtain C_{G}(H)=C_{G}(K) . Thus m_{G}(H)=|H||C_{G}(H)|=p\cdot p^{n-1}=p^{n} . Now, suppose A\leq G with |A|\geq p^{2} and A\notin{\cal CD}(G) . Then there are B,C\in{\cal CD}(G) such that B\subset A\subset C and |A|/|B|=|C|/|A|=p . It follows that C_{G}(C)\subseteq C_{G}(A)\subseteq C_{G}(B) and |C_{G}(B)|/|C_{G}(C)|=p^{2} . We cannot have C_{G}(A)=C_{G}(B) because this implies m_{G}(A)>m^{*}(G) , a contradiction. Also, we cannot have |C_{G}(A)|=p|C_{G}(C)| because this implies A\in{\cal CD}(G) , a contradiction. So, C_{G}(A)=C_{G}(C) , which leads to m_{G}(A)=p^{n} . Finally, note that m_{G}(1)=|G|=p^{n} . Thus {\rm Im}(m_{G})=\{p^{n},p^{n+1}\} .∎ Proof of Theorem 1.2. If G is a nonabelian group of order pq , p and q primes, then 1<N<G where N is a normal subgroup of prime order, and {\cal CD}(G)=\{N\} , and thus G has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Conversely, suppose that G has dense {\cal CD} -subgroups. Let |G|=p_{1}^{n_{1}}\cdots p_{k}^{n_{k}} with k\geq 2 . If n_{i}=1 , \forall\,i=1,...,k , then G is a ZM-group and so its Chermak–Delgado lattice is a chain of length 0 by Theorem 3 of [ 12 ] . This satisfies the density property if and only if k=2 , that is, G is a nonabelian group of order p_{1}p_{2} . In what follows, we assume that n_{1}\geq 2 and let H_{1}\leq G with |H_{1}|=p_{1}^{2} . Then between 1 and H_{1} there is a subgroup K_{1}\in{\cal CD}(G) of order p_{1} . Since Z(G)\subseteq K_{1} , we have the following two cases: Case 1. Z(G)=K_{1} . Then n_{2}=\dots=n_{k}=1 and so |G|=p_{1}^{n_{1}}p_{2}\cdots p_{k} . Indeed, if n_{i}\geq 2 for some i=2,...,k , then there is K_{i}\in{\cal CD}(G) of order p_{i} . This implies Z(G)\subseteq K_{i} , that is K_{1}\subseteq K_{i} , which leads to p_{1}\mid p_{i} , a contradiction. Clearly, we can choose M_{1}\leq G with |M_{1}|=p_{1}^{n_{1}-1} and M_{1}\in{\cal CD}(G) . Now, subgroups in {\cal CD}(G) are permutable, and {\cal CD}(G) is closed under conjugation, and so the normal closure M_{1}^{G} is a p_{1} -subgroup. Now the quotient group G/M_{1}^{G} is a ZM-group and hence solvable, and M_{1}^{G} is a p_{1} -subgroup which is solvable, and so it follows that G is solvable. (Note: the solvability of a ZM-group can be proven as a consequence of Burnside’s normal complement

Read the complete text