Identified hadron production at hadron colliders in NNLO QCD Preprint: Cavendish-HEP-25/01, IFJPAN-IV-2025-6, P3H-25-016, TTK-25-09
Michał Czakon, Terry Generet, Alexander Mitov, Rene Poncelet · 2025
Read Identified hadron production at hadron colliders in NNLO QCD Preprint: Cavendish-HEP-25/01, IFJPAN-IV-2025-6, P3H-25-016, TTK-25-09 by Michał Czakon, Terry Generet, Alexander Mitov, Rene Poncelet (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-11489.txt.
Introduction
Michał Czakon, Terry Generet, Alexander Mitov, and Rene Poncelet compute hadron production at colliders to one order higher in precision, in a paper from 2025. Such calculations test quantum chromodynamics and feed fits of how quarks turn into hadrons. Missing higher orders were a key source of theory error.
Their next-to-next-to-leading order result shifts all observables they study and shrinks scale uncertainty, with mostly moderate changes and good convergence. Remaining theory error is now dominated by poor knowledge of fragmentation functions, which dwarfs scale error in most ranges. The authors call for a new generation of fragmentation fits at matching precision.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michał Czakon, Terry Generet, Alexander Mitov, Rene Poncelet |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-11489
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Identified hadron production at hadron colliders in NNLO QCD Preprint: Cavendish-HEP-25/01, IFJPAN-IV-2025-6, P3H-25-016, TTK-25-09 Michał Czakon, Terry Generet, Alexander Mitov, Rene Poncelet Abstract In this work we calculate for the first time the next-to-next-to leading order (NNLO) QCD corrections to identified hadron production at hadron colliders. The inclusion of the NNLO correction has an important impact on all observables considered in this work. Higher order corrections reduce scale uncertainty and in almost all cases are moderate. Overall, good perturbative convergence is observed across kinematics and observables. The uncertainty due to missing higher orders is relatively small and, in many cases, smaller than the experimental uncertainty. The largest source of theoretical uncertainty at present is from the knowledge of the non-perturbative parton-to-hadron fragmentation functions (FF), which dwarfs the scale uncertainty in most kinematic ranges. The inclusion of NNLO corrections demonstrates the precision studies potential of this class of observables. To fully realize this potential, however, a new generation of improved fragmentation functions may be needed. The results of the present work will enable global fits of FF with NNLO precision. I Introduction The theory of the strong interactions, Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), is a pillar of collider physics. Almost all collider measurements rely on QCD, either as a direct input to measurements, or as part of the interpretation of Standard Model (SM) measurements and searches for physics beyond the SM. Given QCD’s importance, it is natural to ask how one would test and validate QCD itself in the perturbative regime. To this end, ideally, one would like to compare QCD predictions with measurements of observables that are as little sensitive as possible to the electroweak part of the SM. A prime example is the class of observables based on identified light hadrons like \pi^{\pm},\pi^{0},p , etc. Such observables provide direct access to the non-perturbative aspect of QCD via the so-called parton-to-hadron fragmentation functions (FF). A detailed study of the production of single and multiple identified hadrons allows one to study the FF universality and scaling violations, verify QCD factorization theorems and place quantitative constraints on non-perturbative power-suppressed corrections in collider processes. Observables based on identified hadrons are also sensitive to perturbative corrections, which are computable in perturbation theory. Existing hadron collider studies have been restricted to next-to-leading order (NLO) in QCD Aversa:1988vb ; Jager:2002xm . Very recently soft-gluon resummation for this class of observables was extended to full next-to-next-to leading logarithmic (NNLL) accuracy Hinderer:2018nkb . Hadron-in-jet observables, also considered in this work, are known through NLO and NLL Arleo:2013tya ; Kaufmann:2019ksh ; Liu:2023fsq ; Caletti:2024xaw . Presently, FF cannot be derived in QCD from first principles and have to be extracted from data. A principal source for fitting FF is semi-inclusive annihilation (SIA) e^{+}e^{-} data. Semi-inclusive DIS (SIDIS) is another important source for extracting FF. The excellent LHC data taking ability makes the use of hadron collider data for extracting FF an attractive possibility. Many FF sets exist at present Hirai:2007cx ; deFlorian:2007ekg ; Albino:2008fy ; deFlorian:2014xna ; Bertone:2017tyb ; Bertone:2018ecm ; Moffat:2021dji ; Khalek:2021gxf ; Borsa:2021ran ; Borsa:2022vvp ; AbdulKhalek:2022laj ; Gao:2024dbv . Almost all are with NLO accuracy since, until recently, only SIA data could be fitted with NNLO accuracy. Very recently, NNLO calculation of SIDIS appeared Goyal:2023zdi ; Bonino:2024qbh ; Goyal:2024tmo ; Bonino:2024wgg ; Ahmed:2024owh ; Goyal:2024emo which now makes possible the extraction of FF with NNLO precision also from DIS processes. The only major process not yet available with NNLO precision is identified hadron production in hadron collisions. This capability gap is a major obstacle to performing truly global FF fits with NNLO precision. In this work we initiate a research program which aims to conclusively address some of the above questions. Specifically, we use recent advances in pQCD calculations to produce, for the very first time, QCD predictions for single and multiple identified hadrons at hadron colliders with full next-to-next-to leading order (NNLO) precision. We clarify questions like the level of improvement the NNLO QCD correction brings to these observables, if higher order corrections can remove any remaining discrepancy between QCD and data and, finally, assess the possibilities for future extraction of FF with NNLO precision from hadron collider data. While our immediate goal is to improve the description of single and multiple identified hadron production, we hope that ultimately, our results will help place improved constraints on non-perturbative, power-suppressed corrections to hadron collider observables. II Calculating the NNLO correction The differential cross-section for producing an identified light hadron h with momentum p in hadron collisions, pp\to h+X , reads d\sigma_{pp\to h}(p)=\sum_{i}\int dz~d\hat{\sigma}_{pp\to i}\left(\frac{p}{z}\right)D_{i\to h}(z)\,, (1) where d\hat{\sigma}_{pp\to i} is the \overline{\rm MS} -subtracted partonic cross-section for producing a parton i with momentum p_{i}=p/z . The sum in eq. ( 1 ) runs over all massless partons i which can contribute at the factorization scale implicit in eq. ( 1 ). Throughout this work we use n_{f}=5 massless flavors. D_{i\to h} is a set of non-perturbative fragmentation functions which we take from the literature. Specifically, in this work we use the NNFF Bertone:2017tyb and MAPFF AbdulKhalek:2022laj sets for pion final states, and the NNFF Bertone:2018ecm and JAM Moffat:2021dji FF sets for charged hadron observables. The FFs depend on the factorization scale and partonic fraction z . All FF sets used in this work are available as LHAPDF library Buckley:2014ana grids, which incorporate DGLAP evolution. Throughout this work we use the parton distribution set NNPDF3.1 NNPDF:2017mvq , which is implicitly included in the partonic coefficient function d\hat{\sigma} . The strong coupling constant \alpha_{S} is taken at NNLL as provided by the pdf’s LHAPDF grids. The calculation of the NNLO massless coefficient function d\hat{\sigma}_{pp\to i} is purely numeric. It was recently used in ref. Czakon:2024tjr in the NNLO calculation of open B production at hadron colliders. The handling of infrared singularities at NNLO follows the STRIPPER approach of refs. Czakon:2010td ; Czakon:2011ve as implemented in refs. Czakon:2014oma ; Czakon:2019tmo . The \overline{\rm MS} subtraction of the final state collinear singularities associated with the final state parton p_{i} is performed numerically as explained in ref. Czakon:2021ohs . The required two loop four-parton massless amplitudes are taken from ref. Broggio:2014hoa , which are in agreement with the earlier calculations of refs. Bern:2002tk ; Bern:2003ck ; Glover:2003cm ; Glover:2004si ; DeFreitas:2004kmi . The required one loop amplitudes are taken from the library OpenLoops 2 Buccioni:2019sur . Tree-level amplitudes are computed with the help of the AvH library Bury:2015dla . In our calculations we set the central values of the factorization, renormalization and fragmentation scales to a common value. This value is chosen individually for each observable. The scale choices we make are specified in section III . Scale variation is performed in the 15 point approach. Another novel feature of this work is the calculation of two-hadron inclusive observables at NNLO. Specifically, we provide predictions for the invariant mass m(h_{1},h_{2}) of two identified hadrons h_{1} and h_{2} . Such an observable is defined through a straightforward extension of eq. ( 1 ) \displaystyle d\sigma_{pp\to h_{1}h_{2}}(p_{1},p_{2}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{i,j}\int dz_{1}\int dz_{2}~d\hat{\sigma}_{pp\to ij}\left(\frac{p_{1}}{z_{1}},\frac{p_{2}}{z_{2}}\right) (2) \displaystyle\times~D_{i\to h_{1}}(z_{1})D_{j\to h_{2}}(z_{2})\,, with p_{i}=p_{1}/z_{1} and p_{j}=p_{2}/z_{2} . The collinear singularities associated with each one of the identified final state partons i,j is performed in the \overline{\rm MS} scheme just like