Understanding coronal rain dynamics through a point-mass model

Andrew Hillier, Ramon Oliver, David Martínez-Gómez · 2025

Read Understanding coronal rain dynamics through a point-mass model by Andrew Hillier, Ramon Oliver, David Martínez-Gómez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-11327.txt.

Introduction

Andrew Hillier and co-authors explain why rain in the Sun's atmosphere falls at a capped speed, using a model simple enough to fit on a page. Their 2025 paper addresses coronal rain: cool, dense plasma blobs that condense in the corona and slide down magnetic loops. Observations and heavy simulations agree the fall accelerates, then saturates at a top speed tied oddly to how much denser the blob is than its surroundings.

Their point-mass model adds one ingredient: the ambient corona moves with the falling drop, and that shared motion feeds back on the descent. The model reproduces the speed cap and its puzzling density relation. What simulation showed but could not explain, a stripped-down mechanism now accounts for. A formula an observer can apply at the telescope beats a simulation that arrives next month.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrew Hillier, Ramon Oliver, David Martínez-Gómez
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-11327

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Understanding coronal rain dynamics through a point-mass model Andrew Hillier, Ramon Oliver, David Martínez-Gómez Abstract Aims. Observations and simulations of coronal rain show that as cold and dense plasma falls through the corona it initially undergoes acceleration by gravity before the downward velocity saturates. Simulations have shown the emergence of an unexpected relation between terminal velocity of the rain and density ratio that has not been explained. Our aim is to explain this relation. Methods. In this paper we develop a simple point-mass model to understand how the evolution of the ambient corona moving with the coronal rain drop can influence the falling motion. Results. We find that this simple effect results in the downward speed reaching a maximal value before decreasing, which is consistent with simulations with realistic coronal rain mass. These results provide an explanation for the scaling of the maximum downward speed to density ratio of the rain to the corona and as such provide a new tool that may be used to interpret observations. 1 Introduction Quiescent coronal rain is a multiphase plasma phenomenon of cool plasma embedded in a hot component that is frequently observed in solar active regions ( Antolin, 2020 ; Antolin & Froment, 2022 ; Şahin & Antolin, 2022 ; Şahin et al., 2023 ) . It starts with the continuous evaporation of cold and dense plasma from the solar chromosphere into the corona. This evaporated plasma, that now has the typical hot and rarefied conditions of the corona, accumulates at the apex of a coronal loop and eventually becomes thermally unstable ( Parker, 1953 ; Field, 1965 ; Antiochos, 1980 ) , which leads to the formation of a dense coronal rain clump some tens of Mm high in the corona. Electron number densities of the order of 2-25\times 10^{10} cm -3 have been measured by Antolin et al. (2015) , compared to characteristic coronal loops densities in active regions of the order of 1-10\times 10^{9}\ \rm{cm^{-3}} ( Reale, 2010 ) . These values translate into clump densities of the order of 3–40 \times 10^{-14} g cm -3 (note that post-flare coronal rain can reach higher densities; see Şahin & Antolin, 2024 , who report values \sim 10^{-12} g cm -3 ) . After this formation phase, coronal rain falls along the loop legs toward the solar surface under the action of gravity, although in many cases it does not attain the gravitational free-fall speed, but instead reaches a constant (or even decreasing) velocity. Coronal rain typically reaches falling speeds of up to 150 km s -1 ( Wiik et al., 1996 ; Antolin & Rouppe van der Voort, 2012 ; Kriginsky et al., 2021 , see, for example,) . The descending phase of coronal rain is characterised by the cold and dense plasma flowing along coronal loops, which are aligned with the coronal magnetic field ( Tripathi et al., 2006 ; Tripathi et al., 2007 , see, e.g.,) implying that some inherent aspects of the dynamics are essentially one-dimensional (1D). This was used by Oliver et al. (2014) to set up 1D hydrodynamic models of coronal rain that reproduce the observed smaller-than-free-fall speed. These authors also found that coronal rain blobs achieve a maximum descending velocity, after which their speed is reduced gradually in time. The work of Oliver et al. (2014) was extended to 2D by Martínez-Gómez et al. (2020) . A very interesting aspect of the simulations of Martínez-Gómez et al. (2020) is that in the limit of strong magnetic field, i.e., |B|\gtrsim 20 G, the simulated coronal rain dynamics effectively became the sum of a set of vertical 1D models of the type presented in Oliver et al. (2014) , meaning that 1D modelling is reasonable given the strong magnetic field of the solar corona as this implies the Alfvén Mach number and plasma beta of the coronal rain is small ( Schad et al., 2016 ; Kuridze et al., 2019 ; Kriginsky et al., 2021 , magnetic field strengths of the order of hundreds of Gauss or even larger have been inferred by) . Both in Martínez-Gómez et al. (2020) and in other multi-dimensional simulations using weaker field strengths ( Fang et al., 2015 , e.g.) it has been found that there is a greater influence of multi-dimensional effects. Assessing the dynamics of their simulated rain blobs, Martínez-Gómez et al. (2020) found, through empirical fit, that the maximum downward velocity of the falling coronal rain scales as the rain to corona density ratio to the power 0.64 (i.e. (\rho_{\rm rain}/\rho_{\rm corona})^{0.64} ). A key question that still remains is: why this particular exponent? One possible way of understanding the dynamics of these simulations may be through simplified point-mass and drag models. These models have been widely applied in many areas of fluid dynamics including the modelling of coronal mass ejection (CME) propagation ( Vršnak et al., 2010 ; Vršnak et al., 2013 , e.g.) . A standard aspect of drag models is that the faster the body moves, the stronger the drag force works to decelerate it. Physically, this relates to the moving structure having to do more work to push aside the ambient material as it moves faster. This model predicts a terminal fall velocity that scales (in the large density contrast limit) as approximately the density ratio to the power 0.5 ( Zhou et al., 2021 , e.g.) . This discrepancy to the exponent found by Martínez-Gómez et al. (2020) for their simulations is interesting as it implies that some different physics needs to be considered. Another key aspect of point-mass models, including drag models, is that as the mass moves through the medium, a portion of the ambient fluid, which will be referred to as the virtual mass, moves with the body. In effect, this adds to the mass of the moving body. For a standard drag problem, including one that involves incompressible flow, the virtual mass of the system is expected to not change significantly over time ( Vršnak et al., 2010 ; Vršnak et al., 2013 , e.g. as used in ) . If the mass of the body is larger than that of the virtual mass, then the virtual mass does not change the dynamics in any significant way. Due to the high mass of a coronal rain blob, we may naturally expect this to be the case. However, this assumption may not hold for the coronal rain falling along magnetic field as a significant amount of material in front of and behind the moving coronal rain has to move as well. In this paper we develop a simple model for the coronal rain dynamics simulated by Oliver et al. (2014) and Martínez-Gómez et al. (2020) looking at the role of virtual mass to quantify how it controls the evolution of the rain motion. We then use this model to provide an explanation for the density and coronal rain velocity scaling presented in Martínez-Gómez et al. (2020) . 2 An overview of the numerical modelling We consider a one-dimensional vertical slice of a fully ionised hydrogen plasma. The adiabatic hydrodynamic evolution of this system is described by the continuity equations of mass, momentum and pressure: \displaystyle\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial t} \displaystyle=-v\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial z}-\rho\frac{\partial v}{\partial

Read the complete text