A study of Kock’s fat Delta
Tom de Jong, Nicolai Kraus, Simona Paoli, Stiéphen Pradal · 2025
Read A study of Kock’s fat Delta by Tom de Jong, Nicolai Kraus, Simona Paoli, Stiéphen Pradal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10963.txt.
Introduction
Four category theorists give a full study of the fat Delta category, a variant of the simplex category introduced by Kock. The work is driven by weak identity structures in higher category theory, where the usual strict rules are relaxed. The authors approach the category through monads with arities, a framework that controls which shapes a theory can see.
They prove that the key monad is strongly cartesian and identify a dense generator for it. That single step delivers a nerve theorem, which says the category can be probed faithfully by a simpler one. They then pin down which objects the nerve produces, using the Segal condition, and show the category splits maps into active and inert parts. Finally, they prove that two standard presentations of fat Delta are actually the same category in disguise.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tom de Jong, Nicolai Kraus, Simona Paoli, Stiéphen Pradal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 130 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10963
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A study of Kock’s fat Delta Tom de Jong, Nicolai Kraus, Simona Paoli, Stiéphen Pradal Abstract Motivated by the study of weak identity structures in higher category theory we explore the fat Delta category, a modification of the simplex category introduced by J. Kock and provide a comprehensive study via the theory of monads with arities. Specifically, by proving that the free relative semicategory monad is strongly cartesian and identifying a dense generator, the theory of monads with arities immediately gives rise to the nerve theorem. We characterise the essential image of the nerve via the Segal condition, and show that fat Delta possesses an active-inert factorisation system. Building on these results, we also establish an isomorphism between two presentations of fat Delta. Contents Introduction Higher categories come with many levels of structure, and each of the various approaches to higher category theory needs to provide a way to organise, represent and work with this structure. One very fruitful approach to higher categories has been to use simplicial and multi-simplicial objects, that is functors from the opposite of the simplicial category \Delta and its products, satisfying additional conditions that encode the composition of higher morphisms and their behaviour. This simplicial approach has given rise to models of ( \infty , 1 )-categories (in particular quasi-categories [ Joy08 , Lur09 ] and complete Segal spaces [ Rez01 ] ) and, more generally, models of ( \infty , n )-categories [ Ber11 ] , that is categories with morphisms in all dimensions but weakly invertible in dimension higher than n . These have found important applications to mathematical physics in the field of TQFTs [ Lur08 , Ber11 , GP22 ] . Multi-simplicial models have also been used to describe truncated higher categories, that is those with morphisms only in dimension up to n . These arise naturally in homotopy theory, where, in the higher groupoidal case, they describe the building blocks of spaces, called homotopy n -types. Such models include the Tamsamani model [ Tam99 ] and the weakly globular n -fold categories of one of the authors [ Pao19 ] . The current paper studies the so-called fat Delta category ( \underline{\Delta} , cf. Fig. 1 ), a modification of \Delta introduced by J. Kock [ Koc06 ] with the motivation of weakening the identity structure of higher categories. In fact, \underline{\Delta} can be used as a means to give a diagrammatic interpretation of weak identity arrows in higher categories. A variation of \underline{\Delta} was later (independently) suggested by C. Sattler and one of the current authors [ KS17 ] , with a very different motivation stemming from type theory. Before describing the focus of this paper, we explain the motivation for our interest in this category, which comes from different areas. {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[0]}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[1]}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[2]}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[0]}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[1]^{\flat}}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[2]^{\flat}}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[1]^{\sharp}}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\sigma^{1}_{0}}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{\sigma^{1}_{1}}} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces{[2]^{\sharp}}} Figure 1: Initial segments of the categories \Delta (left) and its modification \underline{\Delta} (right) by Kock [ Koc06 ] . While \Delta is a Reedy category (having positive and negative morphisms which go “up” and “down”), \underline{\Delta} is a direct category (its morphisms only go “up”). The objects of \underline{\Delta} are the epimorphisms of \Delta : the top row of \underline{\Delta} are the identities, the second row shows the epimorphisms of \Delta that are drawn in the diagram on the left, and the third row represents [2]\twoheadrightarrow[0] . Motivation from higher category theory It is well known that strict n -categories (that is, those where higher morphisms have compositions that obey associative and unit laws strictly) are insufficient for many applications. For instance, strict n -groupoids cannot model homotopy n -types. Explicit examples have been found in which strict 3 -groupoids cannot model the homotopy 3 -types of spaces with non-trivial Whitehead products [ Sim98 ] . Likewise, higher order cobordism categories necessitate weak higher categories [ Lur08 , §2.2] : that is, those where compositions of higher morphisms obey associative and unit laws only up to an invertible higher morphism in the next dimension, and these associativity and unit isomorphisms are sufficiently compatible or coherent. C. Simpson conjectured in [ Sim98 ] that any such model of weak n -category should be suitably equivalent to one in which the composition laws are strictly associative, that is they hold as equalities, and the unit laws hold up to coherent isomorphism. This is usually referred to as the weak units conjecture for truncated weak n -categories. J. Kock used the fat Delta category to give a precise formulation of the weak units conjecture (namely, as stating that the Tamsamani n -categories are suitably equivalent to fair n -categories) [ Koc06 ] . The category of fair n -categories is built from functors from the opposite of \underline{\Delta} and its products in an inductive way, formally analogous to the Tamsamani model, but with the simplex category replaced by fat Delta. A main difference however is that in the fair n -categories model, all Segal maps are isomorphisms, hence all compositions of higher morphisms are (strictly) associative, while the unit laws hold only up to isomorphisms. The combinatorics of fat Delta allows precisely to decouple the units structure from the composition structure to make this possible, unlike in the simplicial approach. For general n , this conjecture is open. However, in the case n=2 this has been proved by one of the authors using the intermediary of weakly globular double categories [ Pao25 ] , and it is hoped that this approach could in the future be extended to higher dimensions. For n=3 , A. Joyal and J. Kock have given a proof for one-object 3-groupoids [ JK07 ] . More recently, S. Henry has given a proof of the conjecture for regular \infty -groupoids [ Hen18 ] . The study of models of weak and semistrict ( \infty ,1)-categories based on \underline{\Delta} will appear in the forthcoming PhD thesis of the last author. We have so far described weak units in the context of a strict composition structure. It is possible to weaken the unital structure even if the composition structure is already weak. In the context of infinity categories, studies in this direction include [ Har15 ] and [ Hau21 ] . This direction is closely related to what we discuss next, namely the motivation for \underline{\Delta} stemming from type theory. Motivation from type theory A further motivation for studying \underline{\Delta} comes from type theory , a foundation for mathematics that is used as a basis for programming languages and proof assistants [ Mar84 , NPS90 ] . As a foundational system, type theory is often compared to set theory, where the primitive objects are sets . In contrast, types (the primitive objects of type theory) behave more akin to spaces , i.e. \infty -groupoids or homotopy types, a view that homotopy type theory (HoTT) [ Uni13 ] is built upon. There have been extensive discussions about the philosophical and practical differences between set theory and type theory (cf. [ CKS19 ] ) that are unimportant for the current paper. It suffices to understand that, while the predominant approach is to define the notion of a space in terms of sets (for example, as a Kan simplicial set), every