Cosmic filament spin - I: a comparative study in observation Journal: ApJ
Xiao-xiao Tang(唐潇潇), Peng Wang(王鹏), Wei Wang(王伟), Ming-Jie Sheng(盛明捷), Hao-Ran Yu(于浩然), Haojie Xu(许浩杰) · 2025
Read Cosmic filament spin - I: a comparative study in observation Journal: ApJ by Xiao-xiao Tang(唐潇潇), Peng Wang(王鹏), Wei Wang(王伟), Ming-Jie Sheng(盛明捷), Hao-Ran Yu(于浩然), Haojie Xu(许浩杰) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10841.txt.
Introduction
Xiao-Xiao Tang and five co-authors check whether the giant filaments of the cosmic web really spin, and how much the answer depends on method. Filaments link the walls and clusters of the universe and host much of galaxy growth. Recent studies claimed a rotation signal, but different teams find filaments and measure galaxies in different ways. The authors reran the measurement across identification methods and survey datasets to see what survives.
The spin signal held up in rough terms: it appears reliably when a filament is viewed nearly side-on, at angles above about eighty degrees. Its strength shifts with viewing angle and with the filament's dynamic temperature. The choice of finder algorithm mattered a little, while distortions in the galaxy distance data mattered more. The authors conclude the spin is real but must be read with care.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Xiao-xiao Tang(唐潇潇), Peng Wang(王鹏), Wei Wang(王伟), Ming-Jie Sheng(盛明捷), Hao-Ran Yu(于浩然), Haojie Xu(许浩杰) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10841
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cosmic filament spin - I: a comparative study in observation Journal: ApJ Xiao-xiao Tang(唐潇潇), Peng Wang(王鹏), Wei Wang(王伟), Ming-Jie Sheng(盛明捷), Hao-Ran Yu(于浩然), Haojie Xu(许浩杰) Abstract In the cosmic web, filaments play a crucial role in connecting walls to clusters and also act as an important stage for galaxy formation and evolution. Recent observational studies claim that filaments have spin. In this study, we examined the potential impact of diversity in filament identification algorithms and galaxy survey datasets on the quantification of filament spin. The results of this study demonstrate qualitative agreement with previous research, suggesting that a reliable filament spin signal is detectable when the viewing angle of filament spine larger than 80 degrees under a rough estimation. The detected filament spin signal is intricately linked to the viewing angle, dynamic temperature, etc. The quantitative difference of filament spin signal among samples is slightly dependent on the filament identification algorithms, while the value is relatively greater dependent on the redshift space distortion effect in the galaxy sample. I Introduction The modern standard \Lambda CDM cosmological model suggests that galaxies are not randomly distributed on the large scale of the Universe but instead form the cosmic web ( Bond et al. 1996 ) , which is composed of voids, walls, filaments, and clusters. It has been confirmed by numerous galaxy surveys (such as the 2dF Galaxy Readshift Survey ( Colless et al. 2001 ) , Sloan Digital Sky Survey ( Tegmark et al. 2004 ) ) and simulations (such as EAGLE ( Schaye et al. 2015 ) , illustris ( Nelson et al. 2015 ) , IllustrisTNG ( Springel et al. 2018 ) ). Among the cosmic web, filaments play a crucial role in connecting walls to clusters and also act as an important stage for galaxy formation and evolution. Galaxies tend to form within the cosmic filaments, where the density of dark matter and gas is higher. Studies have shown that the properties of galaxies, such as their morphology ( Zhang et al. 2009 ) , star formation rates ( Coppin et al. 2012 ; Darvish et al. 2014 ) , and shape and spin orientation ( Zhang et al. 2009 ; Zhang et al. 2015 ; Tempel & Libeskind 2013 ; Wang & Kang 2017 ; Wang & Kang 2018 ) , are influenced by their reside cosmic filaments. A variety of methods have been developed to identify and classify cosmic structures such as filaments, clusters, and large-scale features in the cosmic web. These methods use diverse approaches, including graph-based algorithms (e.g., the Minimal Spanning Tree method, Alpaslan et al. 2014 ), stochastic modeling (e.g., Bisous, Tempel et al. 2014 ; Tempel et al. 2016 ; FINE, González & Padilla 2010 ), and tensor-based Hessian analysis (e.g., T-web, Forero-Romero et al. 2009 ; V-web, Hoffman et al. 2012 ; CLASSIC, Kitaura & Angulo 2012 ). Advanced scale-space techniques are utilized by NEXUS+ ( Cautun et al. 2013 ) and MMF-2 ( Aragón-Calvo et al. 2007 ; Aragon-Calvo & Yang 2014 ), while topological approaches are adopted by Spineweb ( Aragón-Calvo et al. 2010b ) and DisPerSE ( Sousbie 2011 ). Phase-space analyses are used in ORIGAMI ( Falck et al. 2012 ; Falck & Neyrinck 2015 ) and MSWA ( Ramachandra & Shandarin 2015 ). These methods vary in the types of structures they identify, such as filaments, clusters, or the entire cosmic web, and in their sensitivity to different datasets, including particles and galaxy/haloes. This variety highlights ongoing efforts to improve cosmic structure detection and advance our understanding of large-scale structure formation. However, the complexity of filamentary structures results in inconsistencies among the outcomes of different algorithms. Currently, there is no universally accepted method for defining filaments. For a detailed review of these classification techniques, we refer readers to ( Libeskind et al. 2018 ) . The investigation revealed that the statistical properties of cosmic filaments are significantly affected by the choice of identification algorithm, as demonstrated in ( Rost et al. 2020 ) . This was shown by comparing three sets of filament catalogues generated by different algorithms applied to the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. The research found variations in statistical features, such as the redshift distribution and length, across different catalog sets. This suggests that the chosen algorithm can lead to differences in filament characteristics, potentially affecting the interpretation of cosmological effects. Consequently, this finding underscores the necessity of performing comprehensive analyzes on filament catalogs developed using various algorithms or data sets for a detailed study of filaments. The investigation of the properties of the filaments themselves has gained significant attention. For example, studies such as Colberg et al. 2005 ; Dolag et al. 2006 ; Aragón-Calvo et al. 2010a ; Aragón-Calvo et al. 2010b ; González & Padilla 2010 ; Bond et al. 2010 ; Cautun et al. 2014 ; Bonjean et al. 2020 ; Galárraga-Espinosa et al. 2020 ; Tanimura et al. 2020 have analyzed the density distributions of mass or galaxy numbers surrounding filament spines. Wang et al. 2024 assessed the galaxy density gradient to determine the radii of the filaments, finding approximately 1 Mpc at z=0 from both state-of-the-art hydrodynamical simulations and observational data. Recently, Wang et al. 2021 offered observational evidence of the rotation of cosmic filaments, demonstrating that cosmic angular momentum can be generated on unprecedented scales. The filament spin, which is our main research interest, in a cosmological context remains a significant issue in cosmology. According to the standard model of structure formation, tiny initial over-density regions in the very early Universe expand through gravitational instability as matter moves from less dense to more dense areas. This mass flow is laminar, indicating the absence of primordial rotation in the early universe, so that angular momentum must form during the formation of structures. Tidal torque theory ( Peebles 1969 ; Doroshkevich 1970a ; Doroshkevich 1970b ; White 1984 ; Barnes & Efstathiou 1987 ; van Haarlem & van de Weygaert 1993 ; Bond & Myers 1996 ; Pichon & Bernardeau 1999 ; Porciani et al. 2002 ) explains how misalignment between the inertia tensor of a collapsing space region ( Peebles 1969 ; Doroshkevich 1970b ; Pichon & Bernardeau 1999 ) and the tidal(shear) field can spin up the collapsing material. This explanation applies when density perturbations are small, known as the linear regime. Following the discovery of possible evidence for filament spin in Wang et al. 2021 , several key tasks are essential to advancing our understanding of this phenomenon: 1. Reconfirming the signals of filament spin: It is essential to verify the filament spin signal, especially in light of the concerns raised in this manuscript. Specifically, we aim to determine whether consistent signals, at least qualitatively, can be obtained across different galaxy datasets and filament identification methods. This forms the primary motivation for our study. 2. Replicating the observed spin signal in numerical simulations: Extending the analysis to simulations is a logical next step to better understand the differences between real and redshift space. 3. Investigating the physical origin of filament spin: Finally, we need to delve deeper into the underlying physical formation and evolution of the filament spin. To address these tasks, we conducted a series of