Parallel Collisionless Shocks in strongly Magnetized Electron-Ion Plasma. I. Temperature anisotropies

Mohamad Shalaby, Antoine Bret, Federico Fraschetti · 2025

Read Parallel Collisionless Shocks in strongly Magnetized Electron-Ion Plasma. I. Temperature anisotropies by Mohamad Shalaby, Antoine Bret, Federico Fraschetti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10758.txt.

Introduction

Mohamad Shalaby, Antoine Bret, and Federico Fraschetti simulate shocks in magnetized space plasma in a 2025 paper. In such shocks, particles rather than collisions do the work of slowing a supersonic flow, and these fronts light up supernova remnants and other cosmic sites.

Running a one-dimensional particle code, the team varied the field strength that ions feel. Strongly magnetized shocks compressed less, heated unevenly in a stable pattern, and accelerated fewer particles. Weakly magnetized shocks, by contrast, spawned downstream instabilities from that uneven heating. This first part of a series maps how magnetism governs the physics of the shock jump itself.

Catalog record

CREATORMohamad Shalaby, Antoine Bret, Federico Fraschetti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10758

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Parallel Collisionless Shocks in strongly Magnetized Electron-Ion Plasma. I. Temperature anisotropies Mohamad Shalaby, Antoine Bret, Federico Fraschetti Abstract Collisionless electron-ion shocks are fundamental to astrophysical plasmas, yet their behavior in strong magnetic fields remains poorly understood. Using Particle-in-Cell (PIC) simulations with the SHARP-1D3V code, we investigate the role of the ion magnetization parameter σ i \sigma_{i} in parallel shock transitions. Strongly magnetized converging flows ( σ i > 1 \sigma_{i}>1 ) exhibit lower density compression ratios ( R ∼ 2 R\sim 2 ), smaller entropy jumps, and suppressed particle acceleration, while maintaining pressure anisotropy stability due to conserved perpendicular temperatures across the shock, alongside increased parallel temperatures. In contrast, weakly magnetized shocks drive downstream mirror and firehose instabilities due to ion temperature anisotropy, which are suppressed in strongly magnetized cases. Additionally, weakly magnetized shocks exhibit the onset of a supra-thermal population induced by shock-drift acceleration, with most of the upstream kinetic energy thermalized for both electrons and ions in the downstream region. Our results demonstrate that perpendicular temperatures for both species are conserved in strongly magnetized cases and highlight deviations from standard ideal magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) behavior. These findings provide critical insights into the role of magnetic fields in parallel collisionless astrophysical shocks. I Introduction Shock waves in fluids are fundamental phenomena that have been studied for over 100 years ( Salas 2007 ) . In astrophysical context, shock waves are often collisionless, i.e. they propagate in a medium where the mean free path is much greater than the shock front. Since in a fluid, binary collisions mediate the transition between the upstream and the downstream, the absence of such collisions long cast some doubts on the very existence of collisionless shock waves ( Sagdeev & Kennel 1991 ) , the study of which dates back to the 1960s with the pioneering work of Sagdeev ( Sagdeev 1966 ) . Their reality has now been established for decades thanks, for example, to in situ observations of the bow shock of the Earth’s magnetosphere in the solar wind ( Bale et al. 2003 ; Schwartz et al. 2011 ) . It is now well-established that shocks are ubiquitous in astrophysics, ranging from interplanetary shocks in the solar system to supernova remnants ( McKee & Hollenbach 1980 ) . In-situ measurements at Earth’s bow shock have revealed temperature anisotropies in the downstream plasma, which are known to trigger firehose instabilities at quasi-parallel shocks and mirror instabilities at quasi-perpendicular shocks ( Bale et al. 2009 ; Maruca et al. 2011 ; Schlickeiser et al. 2011 ) . For instance, Wind measurements ( Vogl et al. 2001 ) during an oblique crossing of Earth’s bow shock show \sim\%1 deviations in density compression, which were explained therein by pressure anisotropies. Similarly, Voyager 1 data from the quasi-perpendicular solar wind termination shock crossing provided evidence of mirror instabilities in downstream region ( Liu et al. 2007 ; Génot 2008 ) . A statistical analysis of 91 interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejection (ICME) sheaths using Wind data has demonstrated that the Alfvén Mach number is a key parameter governing mirror-mode instabilities at interplanetary shocks ( Ala-Lahti et al. 2018 ) . Such magnetic fluctuations are likely driven by temperature anisotropies generated by instabilities near the shock. Therefore, a kinetic-scale analysis of the relationship between the Mach number and temperature anisotropy can provide valuable insights for interpreting such observations. In contrast, temperature anisotropies at quasi-parallel shocks are more challenging to study numerically and model due to the significantly higher level of upstream fluctuations compared to quasi-perpendicular shocks. As a result, fewer studies have been reported on this topic ( Fuselier et al. 1994 ; Rojas Mata et al. 2023 ) . Collisionless shocks are often studied using the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) formalism, although this formalism is ultimately based on fluid mechanics, which assumes a small mean free path. Global magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations suggest that mirror-mode-dominated turbulence may be prevalent in the inner heliosheath behind the termination shock ( Fichtner et al. 2020 ) , potentially influencing the transport of galactic cosmic rays as they enter the heliosphere. It is therefore important to consider the extent to which such an approach is justified when one of its basic hypothesis is no longer valid. In general, two potential sources of divergence between the behavior of a collisionless shock and that of an MHD shock, have been identified in recent years (see Bret 2020 and references therein). First, in the absence of collisions, a magnetized plasma can be stable even if anisotropic ( Gary 1993 ) . Yet, MHD jump equations consider, at least in their simplest version, an isotropic medium. Secondly, it is known that collisionless shocks can accelerate particles ( Axford et al. 1977 ; Blandford & Eichler 1987 ) This is even the reason for the keen interest they arouse in astrophysics, since they are likely to explain, at least in part, the origin of cosmic rays. However, these accelerated particles escape the so to speak “Rankine Hugoniot budget” on which the MHD jump conditions are based ( Berezhko & Ellison 1999 ; David et al. 2022 ) . This budget assumes that all of the upstream fluid passes into the downstream, together with the matter, momentum, and energy it carries. If some of it, the cosmic rays, moves back and forth around the shock front or returns from the downstream to the upstream, this assumption of integral transport from the downstream to the upstream is no longer valid. The present article deals with the first cause of divergence, namely the possibility that an anisotropy developing at the front crossing remains stable in the downstream. In the absence of an ambient magnetic field, such a configuration would return to isotropy on a time scale given by the Weibel instability ( Weibel 1959 ; Silva et al. 2021 ) . However, in the presence of an ambient magnetic field, an anisotropic configuration can be stable. In the case of a parallel collisionless shock, i.e. a shock that propagates parallel to the ambient magnetic fields, Bret & Narayan 2018 developed a model capable of accounting for these phenomena. This model considered the simple case of a shock in a pair plasma, which makes it possible to treat the parallel and perpendicular temperatures of electrons and positrons on an equal footing. Confirmed by Particle-in-Cell (PIC) simulations ( Haggerty et al. 2022 ) , the main conclusion is that a strong parallel magnetic field reduce the density ratio R of a strong sonic shock from 4 to 2. Such a reduction in the density jump would have significant effects on the production of cosmic rays since the power-law index of their momentum spectrum is 3R/(R-1) ( Blandford & Ostriker 1978 ) . Further studies varying field obliquity showed that the departure from MHD is indeed maximum for parallel shocks and minimum for perpendicular shocks ( Bret & Narayan 2019 ; Bret et al. 2024 ) . It is therefore relevant to emphasize parallel shocks. In particular, while the model of Bret & Narayan 2018 and the PIC simulations confirming it ( Haggerty et al. 2022 ) , considered pair plasmas, it is important to assess the case of electrons/ions plasmas. Such is the aim of

Read the complete text