Combined climate stress testing of supply-chain networks and the financial system with nation-wide firm-level emission estimates

Zlata Tabachová, Christian Diem, Johannes Stangl, András Borsos, Stefan Thurner · 2025

Read Combined climate stress testing of supply-chain networks and the financial system with nation-wide firm-level emission estimates by Zlata Tabachová, Christian Diem, Johannes Stangl, András Borsos, Stefan Thurner (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10644.txt.

Introduction

Zlata Tabachová and four co-authors run in 2025 a joint stress test of supply chains and banks under carbon pricing in Hungary. Missing firm-level emission data has long blocked such tests. Their data estimate emissions for all 410523 Hungarian firms from fuel purchases.

At a carbon price of 45 euros per ton, direct losses reach 1.3 percent of sales and 1.2 percent of bank equity. About 45 percent of firms face direct exposure. Default chains through supply links can swell losses three to forty-fold, hinging on how well firms swap key inputs. A new ratio of carbon cost to profit flags firms at risk. Cutting reliance on high-carbon inputs is the main shield.

Catalog record

CREATORZlata Tabachová, Christian Diem, Johannes Stangl, András Borsos, Stefan Thurner
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE123 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10644

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Combined climate stress testing of supply-chain networks and the financial system with nation-wide firm-level emission estimates Zlata Tabachová, Christian Diem, Johannes Stangl, András Borsos, Stefan Thurner Abstract On the way towards carbon neutrality, climate stress testing provides estimates for the physical and transition risks that climate change poses to the economy and the financial system. Missing firm-level CO 2 emissions data severely impedes the assessment of transition risks originating from carbon pricing. Based on the individual emissions of all Hungarian firms (410,523), as estimated from their fossil fuel purchases, we conduct a stress test of both actual and hypothetical carbon pricing policies. Using a simple 1:1 economic ABM and introducing the new carbon-to-profit ratio, we identify firms that become unprofitable and default, and estimate the respective loan write-offs. We find that 45% of all companies are directly exposed to carbon pricing. At a price of 45 EUR/t, direct economic losses of 1.3% of total sales and bank equity losses of 1.2% are expected. Secondary default cascades in supply chain networks could increase these losses by 300% to 4000%, depending on firms’ ability to substitute essential inputs. To reduce transition risks, firms should reduce their dependence on essential inputs from supply chains with high CO 2 exposure. We discuss the implications of different policy implementations on these transition risks. T he climate crisis imposes large economic costs ( Kyoto Protocol 1997 ; Paris Agreement 2015 ; Mercure et al. 2018 ; Lamperti et al. 2019 ; on Climate Change IPCC ; Bressan et al. 2024 ) and creates additional risks for financial stability ( Battiston et al. 2017 ; Campiglio et al. 2018 ; Lamperti et al. 2019 ; Battiston et al. 2021 ) . To alleviate the consequences of climate change, numerous policies for reducing CO 2 emissions have been implemented ( Dincer and Rosen 1999 ; Directive EU ; Directive EU ; Regulation EU ; Regulation EU ) . While policies like carbon pricing aim to reduce CO 2 emissions Stechemesser et al. 2024 , they will impose significant costs on economic actors, leading to so-called transition risks Campiglio et al. 2018 ; Mercure et al. 2018 ; Fierro et al. 2024 . Climate stress testing (CST) is the main framework for estimating the potential economic impacts of physical- and transition risks for the economy and the financial system ( Battiston et al. 2017 ; Acharya et al. 2023 ) . Many central banks and international organizations use CST for assessing transition- ( Allen et al. 2020 ; Vermeulen et al. 2021 ; Guth et al. 2021 ; Roncoroni et al. 2021 ; Sever and Perez-Archila 2021 ; Löschenbrand et al. 2024 ) and physical risks Alogoskoufis et al. 2021 ; Hallegatte et al. 2022 ; Lepore and Fernando 2023 ; European Environmental Agency 2024 ; World Bank Group nd , while climate related risks are included into bank regulation ( Basel Committee on Banking Supervision 2021a ; Basel Committee on Banking Supervision 2021b ; Basel Committee on Banking Supervision 2022 ) . The most important policy for reducing emissions to date is carbon pricing ( on Climate Change IPCC ; Stechemesser et al. 2024 ) . For example, the new pricing mechanism of the European Union is the Emissions Trading System II (EU ETS II) ( Directive EU ) . It covers emissions from fuel combustion in buildings, road transport, and other industrial sectors, starting in 2027. Initially, the price per ton of CO 2 equivalent emissions will be capped at 45 EUR/t and will float freely from 2030 onward. To limit global warming to 2 degrees, integrated assessment models estimate that carbon prices will need to range between 5–220 USD/t of CO 2 -equivalent in 2030, and 45–1050 USD/t in 2050 ( on Climate Change IPCC , Section 2.5.2) . In such a framework, many firms will face a potentially large cost shock depending on their emissions and future carbon prices. In the short-term, firms either have to pass on increased costs along their supply chains or reduce profit margins Duprez and Magerman 2018 ; if neither is feasible, they face bankruptcy, affecting additional firms through supply-chain dependencies. To assess the transition risks of carbon pricing, reliable CO 2 emission estimates for individual firms are essential, however, barely available ( Löschenbrand et al. 2024 ) . Reliable estimates only exist for a tiny fraction of firms — covered by the existing emission trading schemes like, ETS I, ( NGFS 2024 ; Löschenbrand et al. 2024 ) or future reporting requirements for the largest firms ( European Parliament and Council of the European Union 2022 ) . This lack of data makes it de facto impossible for CST models to comprehensively assess the direct effects of carbon prices on firms, and the corresponding consequences for financial risks faced by banks and the financial system. Currently, the state-of-the-art for estimating (financial) transition risks is the taxonomy of Climate Policy Relevant Sectors (CPRS) ( Battiston et al. 2017 ; Battiston et al. 2020 ; Kosztowniak 2023 ; Battiston et al. 2023 ) that categorizes NACE 4-digit industry sectors, based on their fossil fuel use, but lacks the actual emissions of firms. Using sector-level instead of firm-level data for assessing transition risks can lead to substantial underestimations of economic losses due to supply network effects ( Diem et al. 2024a ) . To capture the indirect economic impacts of carbon pricing, firm-level supply chain network (SCN) data and appropriate shock propagation models are crucial ( Barrot and Sauvagnat 2016 ; Inoue and Todo 2019 ; Carvalho et al. 2021 ; Diem et al. 2022 ; Pichler et al. 2023a ; Diem et al. 2024a ; Tabachová et al. 2024 ) . Yet, CST models today predominantly rely on industry-level data Tabachová et al. 2024 . Here, we conduct the first data driven firm-level-based climate stress test for an entire country. First, we estimate the CO 2 emissions of all 410,523 firms in Hungary that pay value added tax (VAT), based on their oil and gas purchases. We use unique transaction-level VAT records that cover all supply chain links (10 million) between Hungarian firms. Second, we quantify how different CO 2 price levels affect firms’ profitability and calculate whether firms are likely to default due to carbon price shocks, should they fail to adapt. Third, comprehensive country-wide bank-firm loan records allow us to assess the impact on banks’ financial stability. Fourth, we estimate the effect of carbon-price-induced firm defaults spreading along supply chains which potentially amplifies the direct carbon price shock. This is done with the supply chain contagion model presented in Diem et al. 2022 ; Reisch et al. 2022 ; Diem et al. 2024a ; Stangl et al. 2024 ; Diem et al. 2024b . Finally, we simulate one pessimistic scenario, where firms can’t substitute essential inputs sourced from defaulted suppliers and one optimistic scenario, where full substitution is allowed for. We estimate the resulting losses to the banking system with the financial stress testing framework developed in Tabachová et al. 2024 . Figure 1: Estimated and reported emissions of firms in Hungary. (a) CO 2 emissions ( y -axis) of firms aggregated to 21 NACE 1-digit industry sectors (

Read the complete text