Apparent teleportation of indistinguishable particles
M. Gazdzicki, D. Kikoła, I. Pidhurskyi, L. Tinti · 2025
Read Apparent teleportation of indistinguishable particles by M. Gazdzicki, D. Kikoła, I. Pidhurskyi, L. Tinti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2503-10565.txt.
Introduction
Gazdzicki and co-authors present apparent teleportation, a third effect of this kind beside the two quantum versions. It arises because basic particles and their antimatter twins look exactly alike. Within a simple flat model, creation and drift of such pairs can look like a particle jumping at once across space. The model respects a locality rule for transport. Nothing in the model breaks that rule, and no signal outruns light.
The team suggests hunting the effect in nuclear collisions, through momentum links between charm and anticharm hadrons. Seeing it would reveal basic facts about how such look-alike particles move, a fact hidden because they match.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | M. Gazdzicki, D. Kikoła, I. Pidhurskyi, L. Tinti |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503-10565
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Apparent teleportation of indistinguishable particles M. Gazdzicki, D. Kikoła, I. Pidhurskyi, L. Tinti Abstract Teleportation, introduced in science fiction literature, is an instantaneous change of the position of a macroscopic object. Two teleportation-like phenomena were predicted by quantum mechanics: quantum teleportation and, recently, quantum particle teleportation. The former is investigated experimentally and has applications in quantum communication and computing. Here, we introduced the third teleportation-like phenomenon—apparent teleportation. It seems to be a natural consequence of the Standard Model’s indistinguishable elementary particles and antiparticles. We give an example of a process leading to the apparent teleportation within a 1+1D toy model of particle space-time evolution. It utilizes the local transport of particles and antiparticles and the local creation and annihilation of particle-antiparticle pairs. Furthermore, we suggest a method to observe the apparent teleportation in nucleus-nucleus collisions at properly selected collision energies. The method requires the measurement of correlations between momenta of charm and anticharm hadrons in collisions with a single charm-anticharm quark pair being produced. The ultimate prediction following the apparent teleportation hypothesis is the uncorrelated emission of charm and anticharm hadrons. It can be tested by contemporary experiments. Observing the apparent teleportation would uncover the basic transport properties of indistinguishable particles. In particular, the apparent teleportation may explain the rapid thermalisation of the system created in collisions of two atomic nuclei and the quark-gluon plasma hadronisation paradox. Theoretical and experimental efforts are needed to observe the apparent teleportation processes and study their properties. Teleportation Kaku2008 is rooted in science fiction. It describes the ability of macroscopic objects, for example, humans, to reappear at some distant location without traversing space. Thus, the speed of light does not restrict the possibility of changing our location in space. Needless to say, this also concerns signals. Details depend on the science fiction setup. Quantum teleportation Bennett:1992tv is the standard quantum physics phenomenon - transferring quantum-state properties over arbitrarily large distances in no time. In quantum teleportation, conditional probabilities of measurement outcomes reappear at a distant location using the entanglement of two particles. There is neither a super-luminal transfer of conserved quantities nor super-luminal signalling. The quantum teleportation is measured in numerous experiments Bouwmeester:1997slj ; Yin:2017ips ; Pfaff:2014lgp ; Pirandola:2015nwo . Quantum particle teleportation Porras:2023fgn is an instantaneous transfer of a single particle over a large distance predicted by standard quantum mechanics. The phenomenon appears for particles in a potential. It is induced by frequently monitoring if the particle is at rest (a peculiar quantum Zeno dynamics Facchi:2000bs ; Facchi:2002jgu ; Facchi:2008nrb ). Quantum particle teleportation has the properties of ”science fiction” teleportation, allowing for the reappearance of conserved quantities and signalling. It was predicted in 2023 and has not yet been tested experimentally. Apparent teleportation (AT) is a concept introduced here. It is defined as the time evolution of a system of indistinguishable particles that cannot be mimicked by distinguishable particles moving with luminal or subluminal velocities. Of course, when referring to distinguishable particles mimicking indistinguishable ones, we assume the observer is blind to particle labels. The apparent teleportation seemingly requires superluminal velocities of particles. This illusion results from particle trajectories and velocities being defined for distinguishable particles but undefined for indistinguishable ones. I Results Elementary particles and antiparticles of the Standard Model are indistinguishable bosons and fermions. Objects composed of many indistinguishable elementary particles and antiparticles are close to unique and thus can be approximately treated as distinguishable ones 1 1 1 An internally consistent model covering distinguishable and indistinguishable particles and antiparticles has to give identical predictions for a single particle or antiparticle in the system when treating it as distinguishable and indistinguishable. . Classical physics is rooted in our daily experience within the world of macroscopic, distinguishable humans and other objects. In particular, it is well established that they can move only with velocities smaller than the speed of light. However, applying time evolution limits of distinguishable objects to indistinguishable particles and antiparticles imposes human-centred experience on a fundamentally different world. The inadequacy is obvious if these limits are given in quantities undefined for indistinguishable particles and antiparticles, like particle velocity. In this sense, apparent teleportation is the natural property of models postulating the indistinguishability of elementary particles and antiparticles. In the following, we give a simple example of a model predicting the apparent teleportation. It is a toy model of particle-antiparticle creation, annihilation, and transport. Secondly, we present an idea of experimentally observing the apparent teleportation in collisions of two nuclei. I.1 Toy model of apparent teleportation Cell Model is a dynamical model based on the 1+1D discrete-time Markov chain framework Gazdzicki:2017rfe ; Gazdzicki:2022zej . Space is assumed to be a vector of V discrete cells (v_{1},v_{2},\ldots,v_{V}) arranged in a ring. At the given time t , the system microstate is fully defined by a cell distribution of particles and antiparticles. The system’s evolution in time is assumed to be discrete, and the time steps are numbered by t . During evolution, transitions between the microstates occur. The transition probability from a microstate X at t to a microstate Y at t+1 depends only on the microstate X - the basic assumption of Markov chains. For this paper, we consider three types of reactions changing the system’s microstates: - particle-antiparticle creation in a single cell, - particle-antiparticle annihilation in a single cell and, - redistribution of particles and antiparticles between cells. The first two reactions change the number of particles and antiparticles, whereas the third only changes the distribution of (anti) particles in cells. The difference between particle and antiparticle numbers of a given type is conserved in the whole system. This is the only conservation law imposed on the system. Concerning quantum mechanics, the time steps relate to time intervals between measurements of (anti-)particles’ positions, and the uncertainty principle gives the size of cells in space. To sum up, the distribution of particles and antiparticles in cells generally differs at different time steps. This can be due to particle-antiparticle creation-annihilation reactions and particle and antiparticle redistribution. Now, we postulate that only changes obeying the transport locality are allowed during the redistribution. For distinguishable particles, the transport-locality requirement reduces to a requirement of each particle moving by no more than \Delta cells. In physics, this corresponds to particle velocities, which are limited by the speed of light in a vacuum. For indistinguishable particles, the particles’ trajectories and velocities are undefined. Thus, the transport locality condition for distinguishable particles does not apply to indistinguishable ones. The condition for indistinguishable particles and antiparticles is unknown, and experiments are needed to uncover it. Here, we assume that the transport locality condition introduced for conserved particle number in Ref. Gazdzicki:2022zej (see below) is valid separately for redistributions of indistinguishable particles and antiparticles. It implies the following. During a single time step, the particle (antiparticle) number in any interval of cells cannot be transported beyond an interval by \Delta cells longer on the left and right. Moreover, it cannot be squeezed into an interval by \Delta cells shorter on the left and right. The condition means that only those redistributions of particles (antiparticles) that can be mimicked by distinguishable particles (antiparticles) are possible. The condition is given by two transport-locality inequalities Gazdzicki:2022zej : \displaystyle\sum_{j=i}^{i+k}n_{j}^{X}\leq\sum_{l=i-\Delta}^{i+k+\Delta}n_{l}^{Y}\penalty\ ,